3 ms·
Viewing it as a game, I'm absolutely amazed (I'm a sucker for kinetic game ideas and this got me in instant Shut Up And Take My Money! mood - yes, I'm an adult,
by xg15 9y ago
Viewing it as a game, I'm absolutely amazed (I'm a sucker for kinetic game ideas and this got me in instant Shut Up And Take My Money! mood - yes, I'm an adult, don't judge me :P)
However I don't see this game to be very successful in making someone curious about programming. It's based on the concept of using a computer as a mechanical calculator and, while this is the formal underpinning of all programming, it's not avery spectacular application.
I think the thing that is most mind-blowing from a user perspective is how to get a computer to perform all kinds of tasks that don't seem to have to do anything to do with computations: Creating images and animations, driving complex machinery, communicating, etc. The gap from theory to application isn't that interesting from a theoretical CS point of view but I think it's more important for teaching programming.
- sohkamyung 9y agoI think it can be more than a mechanical calculator. The creator says it is "Turing complete" (i.e., a Turing machine) which means you could use it to perform other operations One of the examples given in the Kickstarter page is pattern forming: a group of 2 blue balls, then a group of 4 blue balls, and then a group of 8 blue balls, with each group separated by a single red ball It would be fun to try to form your own patterns or do other operations. If you get the CAD files, you could add your own parts, make a bigger board, and do other computations.
- seertaak 9y ago> However I don't see this game to be very successful in making someone curious about programming. I kind of agree with you... but on the other hand, I distinctly remember asking as a child: "But why?" in an almost endless chain. Apply that question to most ideas about programming, and you'll eventually end up at ideas that are reified by this board. So what I'm saying is that -- assuming my son or daughter take up programming as an interest -- this will be one of the legs of tuition. You're right that the initial excitement will probably come from doing some cool graphics or audio stuff, but this will make all the "magic" vanish. In that sense, as a dad, this is definitely interesting!
- xg15 9y agoI agree. My concern is that the order of things might be problematic - i.e., at the time they're playing with the mechanism, it might not be clear why the fact that the mechanism can arrange marbles in particular orders is so important. i could imagine, if one started (somehow) with some actual application (maybe a grid that could arrange the marbles as "pixels" of an image) and from there worked back to the core, it might be easier.
- saulrh 9y agoOn the contrary, I think that this would be incredibly valuable even if the only thing it did was teach that numbers could be encoded using a series of left or right flips on bits of plastic. I've done little "computers 101" tutorials for a few of my friends and coworkers that have "never been good at math", and every single time the star of the show was that epiphany about binary and what it meant about the nature of numbers and how we represent them. It may not be spectacular to us, but to someone that's never been able to handle math before, it's a whole new way of looking at the universe. Giving people that little tiny rock to stand on before throwing them into school would be a huge deal.
- 24gttghh 9y ago>...epiphany about binary and what it meant about the nature of numbers and how we represent them. Would you please expand on this thought?
- saulrh 9y agoCeci n'est pas une pipe. I've found that a lot of people that "aren't good at math" don't have a good grasp on what a number is, beyond a couple letters on a sheet of paper. They're stuck manipulating numbers by rote, with no understanding of what they're doing past the shapes on the paper changing into different shapes. Showing them how binary works, pulling back the curtain and revealing the difference between the platonic ideal of an integer and our representation of it, is pretty mind-blowing. Then you move from that to instantiating binary representations in the real world, with light switches or checkboxes, and you start getting the "this is how it works in real life" light bulbs that embed the new knowledge in their existing web of knowledge where it'll become permanent. (edit: let me plug my favorite how-to-program book here, while I'm thinking about it. It and GEB were the kernel of understanding around which I built the rest of my knowledge of math and CS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code:_The_Hidden_Language_of_Computer_Hardware_and_Software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code:_The_Hidden_Language_of_C...)
- xg15 9y agoI absolutely agree with this. my issue was more that I was missing exactly that kind of connection to existing knowledge in the game - it's not aimed at teaching math but teaching the basic concepts of programming after all and for such an audience, I wonder if the goal "bring a sequence of colored marbles in a particular order" has any significance or connection to things they already know. Once that conncetion is there, you absolutely want to teach more abstract concepts. As an alternative example, I remember a nold intro to programming that involved a "turtle" - a virtual robot that you could direct on screen and that would draw a line. You could give it basic commands to move around and see it react. then, you could introduce more complex concepts (loops etc) that would enable you to draw more complex pictures - and so on...