7 ms·
Everything's Blub All Over Again
Just a random observation, but the recent founders vs. employees kvetch-storm reminds me strongly of the response to Paul's original Blub Languages article.
"Blub's a great language! And there are lots of jobs programming Blub! Why would I be happier using that weird language? Not everybody wants to take risks using an unpopular language. And how dare you say I'm inferior for not using something else!"
I'm not passing value on the essay or its critics, but I just think it's interesting how much the two essays and their responses have in common.
- icky 19y agoNote also the correlation: startups get to choose their tools, so they usually go with cool "new" languages (yes, I'm aware that Ruby and Python are technically older than Java, and that C# is technically newer than any of the three, but here I use "new" to mean, "not the next COBOL" ;-). Bigger, older companies tend to be more conservative, or simply have a large legacy codebase, so they tend to use Blub more often. Languages can also stagnate and become Blub, compared to newer languages. Think of a 10-year-old dot-com-era company who used Perl 5 because it was the best thing around at the time, and now, 10 years later, has a bunch of legacy Perl code that seemed like the coolest thing ever, but somehow looks like Blub now...
- Xichekolas 19y agoI'm just sick of hearing about it. This is like the OJ Simpson trial of hacker news. Or I should say Reddit. The responses here were fairly normal until someone pointed out that reddit-ers were freaking out about it. I really hate to beat the old 'reddit is teh dumb' dead horse, but it kind of seems like it sometimes. I think someone read into that essay what he wanted in a search for controversy, and then a lot of people jumped on the bandwagon in order to grind an axe with PG or YC, or to appear politically correct, or any number of other reasons. It's just like when the whole world had a cow over the (lack of) unicode support in Arc0. I am currently a caged lion, and I feel like one. I dream of nothing else but the open savanna and a tasty gazelle. How is that for taking a metaphor too far? I understood the whole thing as "startups are liberating to hackers" ... not "hackers that aren't doing startups suck" as others have suggested. I think his points about giant organizations not being natural make sense, and I really don't see why everyone took it personally. Sure, people can enjoy their big company jobs. But you have to wonder... I have yet to meet an (ex)entrepreneur that hated running his own business. Just because you happen to like your company job doesn't mean you wouldn't get more done and feel more free in a startup. And just because you would get more done and feel more free in a startup doesn't mean you should quit a company job you are happy at either. It's up to the individual. It's not like we are arguing over religion here. Or are we? It sure sounds like it lately.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- pius 19y agoI agree. I'm embarrassed for the people who are projecting their insecurities on the article.
- pg 19y agoThe situation with reddit is a unique one. I think I'm the only person who both writes a lot and started a news site. Not surprisingly, people who like what I write tended to switch to that news site. The switch was particularly extreme in the case of reddit, because News.YC is in a sense an offshoot of reddit: most people who switched from another site to this one came from there. The result is that practically anyone left on reddit who has an opinion about me has a bad one. At this point, I could write an essay saying 1 + 1 = 2, and the reddit comment thread would be pretty unanimous that I was mistaken, and moreover, an asshole for saying so. Usually this doesn't effect anything much, but I think you're right that it did in this case. I exchanged email with Atwood and it seemed clear he'd been influenced by the tone of the reddit thread. I don't think there's anything one could actually do about this problem. I only mention this because it is so far as I know a novel one.
- xlnt 19y agoOf course there is something you could do. People aren't static. So what if the people who like you came here, and the ones who didn't stayed there? If you say good enough things everyone will like you and it will be a mute point. Sure it's harder because there is some initial negative reaction to overcome from the reddit group. And it may not be the best use of your time. But it could be done with sufficient skill.
- gruseom 19y agoIf you say good enough things everyone will like you Oh my goodness. You're not serious, are you? This is a strategy for obtaining misery and contempt... and deserving it!
- daniel-cussen 19y agoI've wondered if one could arrive at a good decision using no evidence or facts, but only based on how the different sides debate the issue. The idea is you could determine which party is right based solely on how they say things, rather than how strong the evidence is. You look at how different parties debate. You then compare their styles or types of arguments with debates from the past that have since been settled. It's Bayesian spam filtering, applied to debates. I don't know how accurate it would be, or if it would be easy to game, but it seems useful for educating guesses.
- Xichekolas 19y agoI've always held that the person that is the most angry is the one that is least sure of his position. It's not useful as the only predictor, because people's emotional involvement in ideas can vary, but I find it to be useful meta-information.
- raganwald 19y agoCompare and contrast with: "To raise your voice is to confess you have run out of arguments."
- xlnt 19y agoWhat if the other person is just being an idiot? What if you think he's not capable of understanding? What if he's a child? What if you think he's trolling? Is better argument still the way to go?
- raganwald 19y agoI am a parent, so I can answer your question with respect to children: raising your voice does not do anything except escalate the discussion into an emotional melt-down. With respect to people you deem to be idiots and trolls, we have known the answer for a very long time. One of the more amusing bits of advice about the matter came from Mark twain: "Never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference."
- marvin 19y agoEnough already. I don't see why we should waste our time on arguing with a large group of people who don't get it. No matter what you say, if it is not obvious and carries any insight at all, people are going to be insulted. This is their problem, not ours. It only takes 10% of the readers to turn a good story into a flamefest. Personally, I found this essay as insightful and interesting as any of PG's essays, and I'm sure that most of the other people who read it feel the same. All this no-restraint bashing of an interesting article ("you shouldn't have used the 'lions in cages' metaphor! Now I feel terrible! Bghwaaa-waaa-waaa") is really getting on my nerves. Sometimes someone says something that insults you. Get over it. Paul Graham isn't out to get you, and he has explained at length that he didn't actually imply that cubicle workers are losers. With that in mind: people complaining on this scale about "mere" words is usually a sign that there is an unpleasant truth being uncovered. I think everyone who had their feelings hurt should stop and think about that for a while.
- jk4930 19y agoWhy can't we simply admit to the jealous world of corporate wanna-be lions (i.e. pussycats) that we are the creme de la creme and they are not. We are always smarter, faster, stronger, and more sexy. We have more fun and self-esteem. We are on top of the evolutionary and social ladder. We are the gold standard. And we troll them down on their hate-blogs while we compile our next cash cow.
- gruseom 19y agoThe funny thing about Blub was (if I recall correctly), pg introduced the concept explicitly to avoid offending the users of any specific language. When someone is offended by what you're doing to avoid offending them, you've clearly touched a nerve. Personally, I like this whole discussion because, agree or disagree, the frame of the debate is exactly what I'd like it to be: what creative people can do about the soul-destroying culture of most software jobs. Paul Graham's essays have done an amazing job of raising this question. The emotions they've provoked (or more precisely, the emotions people already feel which they believe the essays have provoked) can't and shouldn't be factored out of it.
- xproduct 19y agoI choose to remain emotionally neutral about this article simply because taking it to heart either positively or negatively is counterproductive. I believe others have already pointed this out, but use of the lion metaphor is not unintentional. Lion is widely recognized as being the "King of the Jungle" -- a powerful and virile animal. This is an undue specialization, a form of flattery. If anything, this alone should leave all programmers satisfied, because naturally, not everyone fit this definition or can duly ascribe it to themselves, whether they formed a successful startup or not. A more general "animals in the jungle/zoo" might have equally well served to enrage both camps. In that instance, the onus of deciding which animal is being spoken of would lay on each individual -- some of whom would wind up with rather silly characterizations such as: ape, rat, etc.
- shiranaihito 19y ago> All this no-restraint bashing of an interesting article ("you shouldn't have used the 'lions in cages' metaphor! Now I feel terrible! Bghwaaa-waaa-waaa") is really getting on my nerves. Yes, I think Jeff overreacted too :) Anyone would love to get (really) rich, and founders have a lot better chance of that happening than employees do. So people are upset about not having that chance (at least while they're employees). It's natural to feel like founding a startup is just more than you can handle, and maybe that's what's bothering most people. Knowing that them founding something is very unlikely to happen, they insist that working on cool stuff is way more important anyway. Something like the software equivalent of a cure for cancer can only be deemed more important than founding a startup, that's for sure. But what most people seem to be missing is that being a founder doesn't prevent you from doing something noble later on - rich or not.
- cstejerean 19y agonot everyone would love to get rich. Certain people want to get rich and some of them work in startups. But even within startups not everyone is trying to get rich. I'm pretty sure Paul didn't start FriendFeed just to make even more money, but I could be wrong.
- shiranaihito 19y agoWell, if someone asked you: "Would you like me to transfer 50 million dollars to your account?" - what would you answer? What would the "certain people" answer? "No thanks" ?
- leoc 19y agoThe response to Steve Yegge's writing about software interviewing is very similar too: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/03/truth-about-interviewing.html http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/03/truth-about-intervie...
- xirium 19y agoSometimes it pays to be a contrarian. Sometimes it doesn't. For programming and employment, it pays to be a contrarian and that is the focus of this forum.
- andreyf 19y agoI say we just wait it out. It'll blow over.