4 ms·
Forgive my uninformed question but I remember seeing a video many years ago where a (Samsung?) hard-drive had built-in protection from being dropped. The disk w
by dmix 9y ago
Forgive my uninformed question but I remember seeing a video many years ago where a (Samsung?) hard-drive had built-in protection from being dropped. The disk will stop spinning within a millisecond when it detects movement. They could survive a sudden drop onto a floor. I assumed this was a common feature of modern disk based hard-drives.
Could built-in protections like this in harddrives be a sufficient protection in an earthquake? What other moving parts are that at risk here? Assuming the servers themselves are locked in cages, I wouldn't expect them to crash to the floor.
Although the big difference here is it's not a sudden drop but a prolonged forceful shaking.
- AlephGarden 9y agoThat keeps your data safe, but (and I'm guessing here) quite plausibly means filesystem writes may likely start failing, causing services on the affected server to start failing. If you need uptime during an earthquake, then that's not sufficient.
- jacquesm 9y agoWhy guess? From the article on the sensor: "When the computer is stable, the drive operates normally again." So unless you install a drive that has its own motion detection on board the computer will simply quickly 'park' the drive and will allow it to resume operation without any issues when it has landed.
- avh02 9y agoto be fair, AlephGarden did say during an earthquake. Telecoms, Hospitals, etc, perhaps wouldn't be happy with being out for the time taken for an earthquake to blow over. Plus aftershocks when damage control is in progress.
- jacquesm 9y agoThey'd be a lot happier with being out for that time rather than having to replace a bunch of hardware.
- sly010 9y agoA typical accelerometer can detect free falling and the hard drive can spin down before it hits the ground. I guess in that sense being shaken is worse than being dropped "suddenly".
- rzzzt 9y agoSudden motion detection [1] is built into many notebooks, and also allows you to use your MacBook as a lightsaber. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudden_Motion_Sensor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudden_Motion_Sensor
- i336_ 9y agoAnd thinkpads. I used it to add X11 autorotation to an X61 tablet. No spin animation, but it was a cool one-day hack nonetheless. The fun part was that the orientation analyses was done from a shell script, and actually worked 100% of the time (unlike so many phones)! \o/ The insane part was that DRM/KMS on Linux is 1000% crazy and I had to patch the kernel to stop poking the backlight on every. rotation. event, grr. (I had to do it in the kernel - I basically killed DPMS - because X11 libdrm is utterly incomprehensible.)
- giobox 9y agoThese were fun, but if i remember rightly, Apple have largely phased the Sudden Motion Sensor out on all their laptop models that come SSD only, which is increasingly almost all of them. There were some ridiculous examples of using it to sort mail into folders in mail.app as well, by tilting the MacBook left and right.