2 ms·
"Thought" isn't really the word. I hoped that progressives would draw a salutary lesson from such a reverse, instead of doubling down on the rhetoric and behavi
by throwanem 9y ago
"Thought" isn't really the word. I hoped that progressives would draw a salutary lesson from such a reverse, instead of doubling down on the rhetoric and behavior that's brought us to such a pretty pass.
You're not wrong that it was a rather forlorn hope. It was the best I had in any case, so I went with it. But maybe it hasn't completely failed - we here discuss an article in which one of the long-standing and most highly-respected collective biens-pensants of the left tries, in its characteristically subtle fashion, to convince its audience that such people are human, not mere homunculi - worthy of compassion, not mere contempt. What is that, if not at least tenuous cause for hope?
And in any case, it's easy to criticize. Let's see you suggest something constructive of your own - serious question, now: the DNC having ruined Sanders, what have you got that's better?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> In any case, the DNC having ruined Sanders, what have you got that's better? The DNC didn't "ruin" Sanders; he's still the most popular politician in the country, and the faction of the party that looks to him as a major leader is stronger than any time (and the neoliberal faction, while still more powerful, weaker than at any time) since Bill Clinton and his "Third Way" swept the neoliberals to dominance in the 1990s. (It's also weird that you'd target "progressives" for your complaints; even insofar as the problem you complain about exists in the Democratic Party, it's about partisan tribalism which cuts across the ideological divides in the party, and, tomthe extent it ties to ideology at all, typically—particularly in the most recent cycle—morr associated with the strongly partisan members of the neoliberal faction rather than the progressive faction. (In fact, the ignoring a large part of the country has been a key complaint by the progressive faction against the neoliberal faction since the latter became prominent.)
- throwanem 9y agoI complain about progressives because I used to run exclusively in progressive circles because I used to be deeply progressive myself. I know firsthand very well the degree of concern they tend to have for, say, broke hillbillies in a state that hasn't gone blue since 1996 - or, for that matter, broke rednecks in a state that hasn't gone blue for twenty years longer than that. No doubt it would be easy for me not to care, too, had I no loved ones in such places, or were I not of such a place in my own right. But let's run with your thing! Had Clinton won, the neoliberal faction would have been rejuvenated thereby, and need fear no challenge from the left for another two decades. Instead, the opportunity lies open for a new wave of progressive populism that has every potential of bridging the political divide, on the simple basis that few people are so wedded to any ideology, left or right, that they'll cherish it more strongly than the chance to ease the suffering of those whom they love. Whether Trump being in office makes such a resurgence of left populism more likely remains to be seen. Whether Clinton in office would have made it less likely seems beyond reasonable question. So tell me again, how did I make the wrong choice last year? What would you have had me do differently?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Had Clinton won, the neoliberal faction would have been rejuvenated thereby Probably not; the neoliberal faction has been losing strength for more than a decade, through both of Obama's elections, even though Obama himself is a neoliberal. Clinton herself arced more progressive in outward stands over the years, because if nothing else she's a decent enough intraparty weathervane. > Instead, the opportunity lies open for a new wave of progressive populism that has every potential of bridging the political divide More like, instead the strategic appeal of trying pick of seats by adopting traditional moderate conservative ideals and picking up disaffected Republicans is tronger than ever. > few people are so wedded to any ideology, left or right, that they'll cherish it more strongly than the chance to ease the suffering of those whom they love. The problem with this idea is it makes the mistake of assuming that people view ideology as a separate question from what eases the suffering (or enhances the enjoyment) of those they care about—people believe in an ideology because, in their view of how the world works, it is the thing that, implemented correctly, will do that. Increasing suffering thus hardens, rather than softens, ideology because it makes it more urgent that the correct one is adopted. > So tell me again, how did I make the wrong choice last year? By contributing to the normalization of Trump. > What would you have had me do differently? Literally anything else. If you wanted to take a stand against blind tribal contempt in politics, probably the most powerful act independent of it's affect on the electoral college result would be voting for either of the major right-leaning alternatives (McMullin or Johnson).
- throwanem 9y agoIt's been a long while since I paid daily attention to internecine conflicts within the DNC. But I have a hard time taking seriously the idea that Clinton would lean more toward the progressive faction than Obama did. That she was an intraparty weathervane, I grant you. But once you get to be the president, intraparty factionalism ceases to be your major concern. You need to get the other guys on board, too. And I think it's much more optimistic than realistic to imagine she'd govern one whit further to the left than the most ideologically right-wing coalition in Congress would be willing to put up with. And if in the first place the progressive faction, who seem to have been behind Sanders all the way, were stronger than the neoliberal faction behind Clinton, then why did the DNC show such blatant favoritism toward the latter, at the expense of the former? As for Trump, I'm not sure "normalization" is the word. His utter failure to even pretend to stand by his word has him shedding supporters in every direction; he has the respect of no one and the support only of those who stand to lose in a serious way when he goes down; he's looking more and more likely every day to be impeached before the midterms, rather than after. I fail to see how this qualifies as "normalization", rather than, say, the construction of Trump from both sides as a frightening and dangerous aberration of the US system which must be prevented from recurring whether that can be comfortably done within "politics as usual" or not - after all, Trump getting elected in the first place puts us pretty well beyond the realm of politics as usual all by itself. To your argument about ideology taking precedence over practicality, I should think that the groundswell of support for Sanders, frustrated or otherwise, puts paid pretty well to that all by itself. Conventional conservative ideology would regard more or less his entire platform as anathema, and yet states generally regarded to be as conventionally conservative as they come swung heavily enough in Sanders' favor that it's quite difficult to construct a counterfactual in which he stood opposite Trump and still lost. A candidate we both agree was And - honestly, McMullin or Johnson? Whatever power I have in this world, whatever influence I can exercise toward those political outcomes I consider most beneficial, I have only to the extent that I'm able to persuade and compel via argument and discussion - even if I'd otherwise like to imagine that my vote for Trump somehow contributed to his victory, my state's electors went to Clinton. But when I say "I voted for Trump, but...", it catches people's interest - it makes them want to listen, not least because I live in a city and a state where that's the sort of thing people keep quiet about. If I were instead to say "I voted for Johnson, and...", it would only make people laugh and crack Aleppo jokes, and if I were to say "I voted for McMullin, but...", the answer I'd get would be "Who?" When people laugh at me or stare with blank incomprehension, I am helpless; to be otherwise, I need people not to dismiss me outright, but remain engaged enough for discussion to be possible. (Buying them beer doesn't hurt, either. But I need to be taken more seriously than "humor the nutbag who's paying for our drinks", too.) On top of that, with the general perception that a third-party vote is a wasted vote and that people who do so regardless are so politically naïve as to be not worth taking seriously, well...put it this way: I'm not sure in what world you live that a vote for Johnson or McMullin would improve, rather than impair, my chances of starting a potentially worthwhile conversation. But whichever world that is, it doesn't contain the bars I go to.