3 ms·
Well, I can't speak for anyone else, but - and I've said this before on HN, actually, to no more effect than I expect it to have this time - I voted for Trump p
by throwanem 9y ago
Well, I can't speak for anyone else, but - and I've said this before on HN, actually, to no more effect than I expect it to have this time - I voted for Trump precisely in order to scare the everloving bejesus out of the US progressive left. Because, from where I sit, either that happens, or something a hell of a lot worse.
Because if you guys don't get your shit together and start looking after even those people who don't agree with your politics, and believe things you think are contemptible, and live lives that you don't understand and don't want to - we're going to end up seeing the kind of enormities which will make history forget Hitler's genocide, just as Hitler made history forget what the Turks did to the Armenians.
A nation which once sought to be - which once was - a bastion of hope for a better world, a beacon for downtrodden people the world over, will instead collapse into the kind of ruin that poisons the world for decades to follow, that taints the very ideas in which it originated. Every hope that anyone has ever invested in this nation - uncounted millions of immigrants, including your ancestors and mine - will become worth less than nothing.
Also, you and everyone you care about will almost certainly suffer and die, and just as likely so will I and everyone I care about, and so will more millions than in any such atrocity before, because - as with so many things - every time we go this route of horror, we get that much better at it. So there's that.
Maybe I sound like I'm scared shitless. If so, it's only because I am, all the time now. If you're not, why in God's name aren't you? Because we're both sitting on the same pile of sweating dynamite and gunpowder. If it goes off, I doubt either of us will find much consolation in the fact that the other one's also just been blown sky high. I'm not asking for a bomb squad to swoop in and save us all like something out of the last act of an episode of 24. It's just that I sure think it'd be nice if people would stop playing with all these goddam matches and do something constructive for a change.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I voted for Trump precisely in order to scare the everloving bejesus out of the US progressive left. That much seems to have worked, but... > Because if you guys don't get your shit together and start looking after even those people who don't agree with your politics, and believe things you think are contemptible, and live lives that you don't understand and don't want to - we're going to end up seeing the kind of enormities which will make history forget Hitler's genocide, just as Hitler made history forget what the Turks did to the Armenians. I'd say mutual hatred across the political divide got much worse, not better, as a result of Trump, so on that ground your effort seems to have backfired. I'm not sure why you thought that voting for the leading merchant of that kind of political contempt would mitigate it.
- throwanem 9y ago"Thought" isn't really the word. I hoped that progressives would draw a salutary lesson from such a reverse, instead of doubling down on the rhetoric and behavior that's brought us to such a pretty pass. You're not wrong that it was a rather forlorn hope. It was the best I had in any case, so I went with it. But maybe it hasn't completely failed - we here discuss an article in which one of the long-standing and most highly-respected collective biens-pensants of the left tries, in its characteristically subtle fashion, to convince its audience that such people are human, not mere homunculi - worthy of compassion, not mere contempt. What is that, if not at least tenuous cause for hope? And in any case, it's easy to criticize. Let's see you suggest something constructive of your own - serious question, now: the DNC having ruined Sanders, what have you got that's better?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> In any case, the DNC having ruined Sanders, what have you got that's better? The DNC didn't "ruin" Sanders; he's still the most popular politician in the country, and the faction of the party that looks to him as a major leader is stronger than any time (and the neoliberal faction, while still more powerful, weaker than at any time) since Bill Clinton and his "Third Way" swept the neoliberals to dominance in the 1990s. (It's also weird that you'd target "progressives" for your complaints; even insofar as the problem you complain about exists in the Democratic Party, it's about partisan tribalism which cuts across the ideological divides in the party, and, tomthe extent it ties to ideology at all, typically—particularly in the most recent cycle—morr associated with the strongly partisan members of the neoliberal faction rather than the progressive faction. (In fact, the ignoring a large part of the country has been a key complaint by the progressive faction against the neoliberal faction since the latter became prominent.)
- throwanem 9y agoI complain about progressives because I used to run exclusively in progressive circles because I used to be deeply progressive myself. I know firsthand very well the degree of concern they tend to have for, say, broke hillbillies in a state that hasn't gone blue since 1996 - or, for that matter, broke rednecks in a state that hasn't gone blue for twenty years longer than that. No doubt it would be easy for me not to care, too, had I no loved ones in such places, or were I not of such a place in my own right. But let's run with your thing! Had Clinton won, the neoliberal faction would have been rejuvenated thereby, and need fear no challenge from the left for another two decades. Instead, the opportunity lies open for a new wave of progressive populism that has every potential of bridging the political divide, on the simple basis that few people are so wedded to any ideology, left or right, that they'll cherish it more strongly than the chance to ease the suffering of those whom they love. Whether Trump being in office makes such a resurgence of left populism more likely remains to be seen. Whether Clinton in office would have made it less likely seems beyond reasonable question. So tell me again, how did I make the wrong choice last year? What would you have had me do differently?
- tptacek 9y agoNobody doubts that you're afraid, but many reasonable people, especially after looking at the quantified facts, dispute that you should be. The health and welfare of western civilization is at an all-time high. We live in a society that enjoys safety and stability unthinkable to our grandparents, who threw themselves bodily into machine gun nests and across long fields zeroed by artillery not only because they were called on by their country, but because the preceding several hundred years of history led them to expect that obligation. In contrast, most of us raise children knowing that they'll never be asked to put on a uniform, let alone required to, and send them off to schools in cities experiencing all-time low levels of violent crime. We earn more than our grandparents and enjoy a standard of living that approaches "offensive". But then, something that those of us who have had company exits can attest to: for some people, the more you have, the more afraid you get. That's understandable, but it's no principal on which to build a government!
- throwanem 9y agoI appreciate you taking the time to try to allay my fear! But your comment lends itself to no other conclusion, on my part, save that you have fundamentally misgathered its origin. There's a lot to unpack here, too, and doing so will, I suspect, require considerable time and effort. Unfortunately, at the moment I haven't sufficient of either to spare for such a task. No doubt, too, you have many more demands upon your time than I do on mine, and I'm not inclined to presume upon that precious resource. So: If you're interested in pursuing the matter further, then say as much, and in response I'll put together the reply that I'd have given here had I the time. Otherwise, I'll refrain. (Or maybe I should just start a damned blog, the way some people here have suggested. But it doesn't feel right, not having anyone to talk to. And why should anyone bother to read it?)
- pvg 9y agoI voted for Trump precisely in order to scare the everloving bejesus out of the US progressive left. Because, from where I sit, either that happens, or something a hell of a lot worse The idea of 'heightening the contradictions' has a long and illustrious history in Marxist ideology. How well it worked out, you can decide for yourself but there is a fairly broad consensus that falls in the 'not well at all' to 'unspeakable calamity' range.
- throwanem 9y agoI mean, sure, but this isn't exactly "the worse, the better", is it? If that were what I was after, I'd have been out canvassing for Hillary and doing everything in my power to ensure she got elected - because if we do end up with a revolution in this country, make no mistake: it's the left, not the right, that's going to be getting revolved against. But an outbreak of violent revolution in the United States - regardless of where it originates and whom it targets - is exactly what I don't want; I am too old to any longer love such destructive chaos. I don't think we are yet so far gone that such an outcome is inevitable - no more than one long step away, perhaps, but that's a step we don't have to take. So, with no better option presenting itself, I sought to frighten people into thinking twice about taking that step. Perhaps this was a mistake. Or perhaps not; the jury of history has yet to return a verdict. But in either case I should like to hope that my purpose in so doing was more clearly understood than your prior comment evinces.