3 ms·
If it's possible to trisect a line segment (1), why isn't it possible to trisect an angle by drawing an arbitrary line that intersects it, trisecting the segmen
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
If it's possible to trisect a line segment (1), why isn't it possible to trisect an angle by drawing an arbitrary line that intersects it, trisecting the segment thereby generated, and connecting the two points to the angle origin?
(I've had that in mind ever since seeing (1), but haven't actually sat down with a straightedge and compass to try it; job and kid tend to get in the way :/)
(1) http://jwilson.coe.uga.edu/EMT668/EMAT6680.2000/Lehman/emat6690/trisecttri%27s/triseg.html http://jwilson.coe.uga.edu/EMT668/EMAT6680.2000/Lehman/emat6...
edit: someone commented, and then deleted their comment - but this explanation made it super clear as soon as you sketch this on a napkin:
> An easy way to see this is to try with an angle close to 180°
This makes it instantly and visibly clear why this doesn't work. Thanks!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RangerScience 9y agoI suspect this is because the conversion from cartesian to polar coordinates doesn't line up...? (it does line up for the midpoint?) Draw a quarter circle. Draw a line between any two points on the curve. Draw a ray from the center of the circle through the midpoint of the line. The ray also intersects the midpoint of the curve. If you pick any other division of the line (say, 10%) instead of the midpoint, will the ray intersect the curve 10% along it's length? I don't know, but I don't think so.
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago>will the ray intersect the curve 10% along it's length? It can't. The line and the curve are the same percentage of the way through at three points - the midpoint and both ends. Near the midpoint, the line is shorter than the curve per unit of arc, since it's basically parallel to the curve and closer to the center. Near the end, the line is longer per unit arc, since they're the same distance from the center but the line is slanted at an angle. So if you plot out length travelled versus angle, you get two plots. The curve goes straight up-and-to-the-right, while the line will race above to start, peter out, cross over at the midpoint, and then catch back up at the end.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Chinjut 9y agoThis doesn't produce three equal angles. Indeed, the angles it produces are completely dependent upon the orientation of the line you pick to intersect the angle's rays with. But even using a line intersecting both rays of the angle at equal inclination, you still won't get three equal angles by trisecting this line segment and drawing rays from the origin through its new points. The middle angle will be wider than the equal outer two.
- mikeash 9y agoI came up with that technique in middle school geometry. I demonstrated it on paper and it worked! I showed it to my teacher and she thought it was cool, and it didn't go any farther. I don't know if she didn't know it was impossible, or didn't get it, or what, but in any case I don't blame her. Of course my demonstration was with a fairly small angle, so it looked right. Much later I realized that it obviously failed with large angles as you mention.