4 ms·
What if Uber is actually innocent? I've always just assumed they are guilty and planned this all along.
by Kiro 9y ago
What if Uber is actually innocent? I've always just assumed they are guilty and planned this all along.
- jacquesm 9y ago> What if Uber is actually innocent? If an ex employee of a company making a competing product walked into my office with a large treasure trove of files I would not automatically assume that he had re-created those files in his spare time. Uber being 100% innocent would be highly surprising.
- tyingq 9y ago>Uber being 100% innocent would be highly surprising Should be fun when the due diligence docs come out, and we get Uber's view of how Otto went from a value of zero to $680M in 7 months, with only legitimate IP, 5 Trucks, and 90 employees.
- mikekij 9y agoThis. How is this not the main crux of the argument for Uber's being complicit in the IP theft?
- hluska 9y agoI am not a lawyer, but I wonder if Uber could argue: 1.) At the time of acquisition, Levandowski was one of the world's leading experts on self driving technology. 2.) As one of the world's leading experts, Levandowski was able to recruit an incredible team. 3.) Self driving technology could be worth trillions and, in Uber's particular case, it would remove one of their biggest cost centres, thus making their business instantly profitable.
- Nelson69 9y agoAqui-hire. Google already established Levandowski as a hundred-millon dollar man, didn't they? It's complete BS but that's the reason for the valuation, he can do it, Google already paid him that much and he 'wanted to do his own thing,' it's going to cost you to hire that guy. Can you even spin up and staff a company in that time frame and integrate a lot of the technical parts in to something very meaningful in 9 months? With custom hardware and stuff that seems insanely tight (but there is a lot of money at play, you push hard) Even if there are off the shelf components that do most of the work and they're pre-integrated that seems insanely aggressive. I can only assume Otto didn't have any IP of real value other than a staff.
- tannhauser23 9y agoTo be fair, Uber says that they didn't know about Levandowski (allegedly) downloading the docs from Google. We'll find out once they get through discovery.
- mst 9y agoOtto had existed for long enough at that point that you could, in theory, believe that he'd re-created those over the lifetime of Otto. But even then I'd agree that they're probably guilty of "intentionally not thinking too hard about it", at the very least.
- tedivm 9y agoAccording to various documents that Google has submitted to the courts, Uber was talking with Levandowski before he had even left Google. https://www.axios.com/analysis-uber-gets-bruised-though-not-necessarily-beaten-in-court-2391739849.html https://www.axios.com/analysis-uber-gets-bruised-though-not-...
- openmosix 9y agoOtto went from zero to hero in ~7 months. Assuming that talks of a $800M company acquisition take some time and you don't build a company overnight (hiring and ramping up something like 90 employees), how long was really spent in R&D mode? 3 months? 4? Compared to years of R&D from other companies in the same space seems like a big stretch.
- jacquesm 9y agoFrankly I don't buy it, not even a little bit. I do DD for a living with some regularity and if someone popped up with that much IP in such a short time I would spend a lot of time on the origin story of that IP and I really would like to have a chat with the magical 1000x developers that they employed. It is beyond suspicious, but then again, maybe pigs really can fly.
- djtriptych 9y agoI'm guessing this case falls under strict liability, i.e. it doesn't matter if Uber knew or not. If they used stolen IP, they're liable, period.
- dllthomas 9y agoHave we established that Uber knew about the files?
- jacquesm 9y agoIf you invest in / buy a company for its IP then you normally - especially when the field is 'hot' and the IP is voluminous and created in record time - do some research to verify the origin of the IP is in fact what the company says it is. If you forgo such a check then you open yourself up to two potential problems: - if the IP ends up being stolen then you may not have recourse against the person that sold it to you - if the IP ends up being stolen you might end up being liable yourself because you did not do the minimum verification required to ascertain that the seller indeed had the rights to sell That changes the game from 'we've been had' to 'we were willing participants' and that's a very dumb position to be in.
- dllthomas 9y agoWhile that's all true, it seems entirely unrelated. If Levandowski stole "a large treasure trove of files" but then drew information judiciously from those files in creating Otto's IP, Uber might not have been much able to pick that apart - and in particular, your characterization would be grossly misleading.
- jacquesm 9y agoThere would still be a discrepancy in that they would be moving much faster than they would have if they started from scratch. The difference is usually very easy to tell, you'd have to be extremely good at covering your tracks if you wanted to start from another code base and you copy bit-by-bit. Copying gives a completely different pattern than writing does.
- dllthomas 9y agoThere are ways of using information other than copy-pasting it in. A reference here and there when you get stuck, reading ahead to avoid dead-ends. They would also be moving much faster if they were just very good, and Google was already paying this guy on the understanding that he was the best. Picking that apart could be difficult-to-impossible. Or maybe Uber's just complicit. But you're introducing facts not in evidence based on your assumptions about how this went down.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> What if Uber is actually innocent? Note that "Uber" actually includes Ottomotto LLC, which is a named defendant, and whose assets and liabilities belong to Uber. Constructing a scenario where Levandowski is at fault but both Ottomotto LLC and Uber, excluding Ottomotto, are innocent is tricky.