4 ms·
I'm a little surprised that Ginsburg dissented here, and also dissented from Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley: naively, she's "liberal", and (at least in my bubble) bein
by geofft 9y ago
I'm a little surprised that Ginsburg dissented here, and also dissented from Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley: naively, she's "liberal", and (at least in my bubble) being "liberal" is associated with wanting less strong IP protection.
But I see also that she wrote the majority opinion in Eldred v. Ashcroft, saying that the 28-year extension to copyright terms was constitutional.
What's the right way to understand her legal thinking here?
Is she known as an IP maximalist? Or are there other principles she's using to reach these conclusions? (I don't completely follow her logic that, because US patent law doesn't provide any protection in other countries, US patent rights are preserved across a sale in some other country.)
- schoen 9y agoJustice Ginsburg is definitely known as an IP maximalist. Some people have wondered if she's been influenced by her daughter's views on IP, since Jane Ginsburg (a colleague of Eben Moglen's at Columbia!) is one of the most influential copyright law professors and has taken a maximalist view in many copyright controversies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Ginsburg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Ginsburg > (at least in my bubble) being "liberal" is associated with wanting less strong IP protection And that's also much less true in regions with major media industries, like New York and Los Angeles.
- ab5tract 9y agoI wish I could go back in time to ensure that Americans never started using "liberal" to mean anything other than "one who advocates for liberalization of trade and economics". This is what it means in Europe. It took me a good long time after moving to start hearing it with its international meaning, but now I find the Americanized form absurd in its conflation. In other words, liberals--in the international sense of the word--absolutely 100% endorse IP maximalization and indeed all forms of corporate ownership, rent, and public infrastructure transfer.
- ckozlowski 9y agoI think she's trying to say specifically that patent rights are preserved in the U.S., because that's where U.S. patent law applies. Her dissent is brief and only partial; and so I think she's only calling attention to a minor point that nonetheless has legal ramifications. Remember that the court's can also be to clarify the laws, and in this case, it seems to me that she took the opportunity to point out a gray area that might come up in the future. I see this "dissent" (if it can really be called that) as a footnote of sorts. "Watch out for these situations here", she's saying. It's not a political stance, but rather pointing out a technicality.
- bhritchie 9y agoActually it is a genuine dissent because the majority decision did specifically address that scenario as well: > Applying patent exhaustion to foreign sales is just as straightforward. Patent exhaustion, too, has its roots in the antipathy toward restraints on alienation, and nothing in the Patent Act shows that Congress intended to confine that principle to domestic sales.
- ckozlowski 9y agoAh, missed that bit. Thanks for clarifying.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> she's "liberal", and (at least in my bubble) being "liberal" is associated with wanting less strong IP protection Hollywood is pretty well known for being liberal.
- tooltalk 9y agowhile I agree with @ckozlowski that Gingsburg's dissent is based on technicality than politics, yes, who can forget the likes of the weasel Christopher Dodd and his long dealing with the wall street and now Hollywood.
- maxxxxx 9y ago"she's "liberal", and (at least in my bubble) being "liberal" is associated with wanting less strong IP protection." I may not agree with her opinion but I am happy about anybody who goes against the expected behavior because they are "liberal/conservative". It's time that the people in power think for themselves instead of going by party/ideology line. I don't know much about IPO law but this seems to be a good thing for consumers and also the "market". I honestly thought that this court would just decide in whatever way corporations want them to deice.
- apendleton 9y agoSibling responses here are good overviews of her views in this decision, but more generally, the liberal-vs-conservative view of the court is at least to some extent a media invention. 5-4 decisions tend to be big, juicy, mainstream-accessible politically oriented cases, so they get the most press, which leads to the perception that most cases are decided 5-4 along "political" lines. This is not true, though: unanimous decisions are the single most common outcome, and decisions that are not 5-4, or are 5-4 along some other axis, happen all the time, with justices predictably agreeing or disagreeing on certain issues in a way that's not aligned with the popular conception (e.g., Thomas and Scalia typically disagreed on fourth amendment jurisprudence despite being on the same "side").
- stale2002 9y agoI don't think that liberals would want less IP laws. IP laws are a government restriction on citizens. Conservatives generally want strict limits on government regulations and liberals want more government regulations.