4 ms·
Managers generally solve no problems. Not engineering ones anyway. They are responsible only for applying the proper resources to get problems solved.
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
Managers generally solve no problems. Not engineering ones anyway. They are responsible only for applying the proper resources to get problems solved.
- SmellTheGlove 9y agoThat's gross oversimplification. In some models, some managers are pure resource managers as you're describing. A lot of us are functional managers, though. I own the outcome. It's become really common in engineering, particularly in orgs doing agile, to split resource and functional management. I don't care for that. I spent a long time as a product owner and wondered quite often why I couldn't just absorb the resource manager's responsibilities as well, since the only thing I wasn't doing was writing reviews. Every other problem rolled up to me, since I was accountable for the outcome.
- PaulRobinson 9y agoThat's an absurd generalisation, and you should probably stop thinking Dilbert is a useful guide to most workplaces. Some companies work that way, but they are bad companies to work for, IME. Other companies, managers have got where they are because they know more than anybody else and have the personal skills to marshal a team into solving bigger problems than what is on the board for this sprint alone. Source: ex-CTO, now Senior Engineer again, done every level of management you can think of, choose to be where I am for a reason, but do not think managers are idiots.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoA manager that is doing the job right, is managing. Resources, people, time. Not doing Engineering. Call yourself an idiot if you like (I don't think I said that anywhere?) Managing is a difficult task that requires knowledge and skills. But not Engineering ones. There's another name for when a Manager is telling his Engineers how to solve problems: micro-managing
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]