3 ms·
So take the argument as 'if you agree with me that an inconsistent machine is not a good representation of the mind', then the rest of my argument must follow.
by empath75 9y ago
So take the argument as 'if you agree with me that an inconsistent machine is not a good representation of the mind', then the rest of my argument must follow.
Think of it as analogous to all of the mathematical quasi-proofs that assume certain conjectures are true. They can often be valuable steps to an actual proof, as we saw with Fermat's theorem.
- mannykannot 9y agoThanks - that seems to be the idea I was groping for. In this particular case, though, it seems close to circularity - if the primary purpose of the argument is to refute the computational theory of mind, then ruling out a whole class of machines a priori looks to me like begging a chunk of the question - though I appreciate that it leads to a better-defined question.