4 ms·
Before you start that bank job you should also think about whether what you're doing is moral and right. Whether by doing that job you're contributing to makin
by rwmj 16y ago
Before you start that bank job you should also think about whether what you're doing is moral and right. Whether by doing that job you're contributing to making the world a better place.
- alextp 16y agoI do worry about this, when I consider working a few years at banks after graduating to save up some fuck-you money.
- robryan 16y agoAlso consider that you didn't create the system and are just a part of it, if you don't take the job someone else will. Depends what stage of your life your at, the money could be a primary concern or a secondary one with flexibility, personal interest and creating something valuable higher.
- raganwald 16y ago> you didn't create the system and are just a part of it, if you don't take the job someone else will. Exactly why I moonlight as a crack dealer, with the odd stint pimping adolescents I meet at the bus terminal. Sorry for the lame attempt at the witty reply... I guess the point is that not doing something doesn't mean it won't happen, but it does mean you won't do it, and that matters to some people.
- mattmaroon 16y agoI have far fewer moral qualms about crack dealing than investment banking.
- neilc 16y agoI know you're joking, but I don't see the moral concern about investment banking. You may not be making the world a better place (although that is very debatable), but you're not making it worse, either.
- mkramlich 16y agoAgreed. At worst it seems to be another form of parasitism. But the parasitic drain per host is fairly small. Taxes are arguably a larger drain.
- mattmaroon 16y agoI don't think that's true anymore. The amount of money controlled by the gamblers, and the amount of leverage they use, has gotten to the point where it threatens the fundamentals of our economy. It melted it 2 years ago and nothing substantial has changed since.
- mattmaroon 16y agoAre you kidding? It's been what, 2 years since the market crash they caused? http://articles.latimes.com/2010/apr/27/business/la-fi-goldman-senate-20100427 http://articles.latimes.com/2010/apr/27/business/la-fi-goldm... Investment bankers created and sold the toxic assets (which they knew to be toxic) that caused the financial meltdown. The top commenter explained a few more terribly evil things they do as well. For more examples, read any book ever written about Wall Street.
- ig1 16y agoThat's like saying men are bad because men are responsible for most wars. You can't ignore the benefits created by investment banks. Without them we wouldn't have had the financial meltdown; but neither would we have had the rapid growth of the last century which has largely been fuelled by financial markets enabling huge amounts of investment. Without the investment banking sector you would have no IPOs, no financed takeovers, no VCs, even bank lending to small business would be close to non-existent. If you want to see the impact of financing, have a look at places which have introduced microfinance in recent decades. It has a transformational impact.
- mattmaroon 16y agoOf course they're not all bad. This isn't a movie, nobody is truly evil. But the problem is the industry has fundamentally changed as it's been deregulated from the useful industry of yore that you mention (helping to efficiently allocate capital and provide liquidity, entirely separated from retail banking) into highly leveraged gambling institutions with a small arm that still provides some of those old services. The guys inside the big investment banks who do the things you're talking about are more or less insignificant to the results of the big banks. The traders look at them the way a programmer at Google probably looks at the cooks in the cafeteria. All of the money is on the bond floor, and that's where the damage has been (and will in the future be) done.
- omaranto 16y agoThat's a good point, startups don't usually make the world a better place, but at least they generally don't seem to actively try to make it worse. And even if a startup were bad, it's very unlikely to be powerful enough to do damage on the scale a big financial institution could.
- Kisil 16y agoYour comment reminds me of this story: http://www.astatespacetraveler.com/have-you-ever-wondered-what-value-we-create-here/ http://www.astatespacetraveler.com/have-you-ever-wondered-wh... Broad strokes: Startups directly create new value, which by definition makes the world a better place, at least for someone. In contrast, the finance industry adds value indirectly by optimizing capital allocation. At best, finance increases efficiency, but it's very hard to measure whether it's helping or just exploiting the complex rules to skim off the top. In contrast, startups without a value proposition fail.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOnly consumer product startups create new value, at least in the sense I think you are describing. A B2B startup, much like finance, will only increase efficiency. If I build HRWeb (replace your human resources dept with the internets), all it does is makes a bunch of other companies more efficient.
- Locke1689 16y agoHeh, FYI http://HRWeb http://HRWeb is the name of Microsoft's internal HR resources site.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoA business is two things: an organization that sells something, and a collective of employees. As you say, some B2B startups sell efficiency to the organization. But there is also good money in selling products to the employee collective, even if they decrease efficiency of the organization. For example, you can sell employees a product that gives them job security by making them appear more valuable. You could sell them a tool that will help them get rival employees fired. Both of these would come at a cost of efficiency, but would be excellent B2B products. In the end, it's the employees who sign the purchase orders, not the organization. I have a sneaking suspicion that these make up a much larger portion of B2B products than most people would think.