3 ms·
Currently HTTPS sends domain in clear-text before establishing a connection. It allows to host (and block) website by domain, not by IP. May be HTTPS should hav
by vbezhenar 9y ago
Currently HTTPS sends domain in clear-text before establishing a connection. It allows to host (and block) website by domain, not by IP. May be HTTPS should have optional extension to send URI in clear-text before establishing a connection. This way, if censors decide to block Wikipedia, users can opt-in into this behaviour and have unblocked Wikipedia except few selected articles.
- avaer 9y agoTwo problems: - Unlike the host, URIs are a property of the request, not the connection, so sending it as part of the connection handshake doesn't really make sense. - Unlike the host, there is a very long history of putting secret things into the URI. Even if the extension is built with this in mind, the number of security breaches that will result is greater than zero, with probability one. That's probably not the correct price to pay for convenient censorship infrastructure.
- knome 9y agoAbsolutely not. The response to censorship should not be to make things easier for the censor. Anyway, the idea is unworkable as the user's client could simply lie about what URI it's going to send after the encrypted connection is setup.
- vbezhenar 9y ago> Absolutely not. The response to censorship should not be to make things easier for the censor. It's not about making things easier for the censor. It's already easy. It's about making life easier for people who have to live with censorship (pretty much the entire world, I guess?). > Anyway, the idea is unworkable as the user's client could simply lie about what URI it's going to send after the encrypted connection is setup. Good server should response with error, I guess.
- thriftwy 9y agoPeople should be fighting for their rights and freedoms, not make their slave life easier.
- unscaled 9y agoAnd how would you make sure Wikipedia honors that clear-text URI (instead of a different encrypted URI inside the request)? Even when using SNI (the optional extension that sends the domain name in cleartext), the web server fully entitled to ignore it.