4 ms·
Whoa, that chart seems really misleading. There are 3x more CS majors than math majors and 2x more than physics. The chart is showing derivatives, not absolutes
by dahart 9y ago
Whoa, that chart seems really misleading. There are 3x more CS majors than math majors and 2x more than physics. The chart is showing derivatives, not absolutes. That basically undermines the title of the article.
Looking at the graph, it's also super important to see the context before 2005 -- that start date adds significantly to the misleading impression this graph is giving.
Math had more majors in 1970 than it does today. Physics has only grown by 50% in the last 40 years, and both have had huge dips just like CS had.
I was coming up with some explanations myself, but now I think I reject the premise, and feel like the right question is: why are so many people majoring in CS and so few in math and physics. More math and physics people can code than ever before, it seems like they'd be able to score coding jobs and be more prepared than a lot of CS grads.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoYeah, exactly. He writes "What deters them from studying this exciting, high-wage profession? Why do they go into math, physics, or engineering in higher numbers instead?", but students absolutely do not go into math or physics in higher numbers. I'm not very surprised by that: not very many people are smart enough to do math or physics, while computer science is much easier. Meanwhile, the fields that are larger than CS are the engineering and biomedical ones. I feel this is a bit vulnerable to how you slice it though, e.g. the number of CS graduates are presumably more numerous than any particular type of engineering (mechanical engineering etc). It's a bit of an accident that all those fields are grouped together and computer science is not. (This could have been otherwise, e.g. in Sweden you can study both of an MEng in "software engineering" or a BA in computer science, and the content is quite similar.)
- sien 9y agoFine comment. I'd upvote multiple times if possible.
- dahart 9y agoI missed my edit window, but here's the absolute plot: https://www.dropbox.com/s/8uhphbrpgygcpgy/majors.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/8uhphbrpgygcpgy/majors.png?dl=0 Contrary to the worry that not enough people are majoring in CS, what this shows is that CS is growing out of the relatively small math/physics group and into the larger mass appeal groups. And maybe what this shows best of all is that Biomed is through the roof. On the whole, CS has grown slightly more than 3x since 1980 and biomed has grown slightly less than 3x since 1980, but those are the top two sciences. EDIT: If I divide 2014 numbers by 1970 numbers, here's the "overall" growth chart for all majors in the data that Dan Wang linked to. Sliced this way, CS is the fastest growing major in the sciences by a long, long way. That is somewhat unfair since CS is the newest, the number is big because the field was tiny in 1970. But, this is a more fair a way to look at this than the article, IMO. 30.67139364 Homeland security, law enforcement, and firefighting 30.23195558 Parks, recreation, leisure, and fitness studies 24.9501675 Computer and information sciences 10.74267782 Communications technologies 8.78051143 Communication, journalism, and related programs 8.572651945 Health professions and related programs 8.110091743 Legal professions and studies 7.519924099 Multi/interdisciplinary studies 6.286681303 Public administration and social services 5.83438043 Liberal arts and sciences, general studies, and humanities 3.348484848 Engineering technologies 3.152990722 Visual and performing arts 3.152613609 Business 3.078456019 Psychology 3.077888251 Biological and biomedical sciences 3.017448623 Area, ethnic, cultural, gender, and group studies 2.862768308 Agriculture and natural resources 2.609677419 Theology and religious vocations. 2.201486523 Family and consumer sciences/human sciences 2.172980415 Engineering 1.631956912 Architecture and related services 1.402989257 Physical sciences and science technologies 1.358694318 Philosophy and religious studies.. 1.074811362 Social sciences and history 0.92876882 Foreign languages, literatures, and linguistics 0.881133825 Mathematics and statistics 0.773109244 Military technologies and applied sciences 0.717323278 English language and literature/letters 0.519678742 Education 0.097729516 Library science The total number of majors grew by 2.26x between 1970 and 2014, so majors over that are actually growing, and under that are shrinking relative to other majors. Everything above Theology is improving, everything in Family and consumer sciences is shrinking. Oh, wait, this is actually the biggest revelation to me so far: Engineering has actually shrunk a little, and Math & Physics have shrunk a lot. CS is growing, not shrinking. Here's a plot of the sciences as a percentage of total majors, this is more indicative of the growth of each field relative to other fields than either the absolute numbers or the delta plots in the article: https://www.dropbox.com/s/xuxithrti6nyljm/majorsSciencesPercent.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/xuxithrti6nyljm/majorsSciencesPerc... And compared to more majors: https://www.dropbox.com/s/wkronio6arxsrjs/majorsPercent.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/wkronio6arxsrjs/majorsPercent.png?...
- sien 9y agoThese figures would make a good medium article. Showing the longer term change is really cool.
- neutralid 9y agoBased on % total majors, interesting how biomed has been inversely related to engineering (and most of CS) except in the last decade where they're all growing at a higher rate than math + physics. Would be interesting to relate this to: - the perception of U.S. manufacturing (affects engineering) '80s: http://www.epi.org/publication/manufacturing-job-loss-trade-not-productivity-is-the-culprit/ http://www.epi.org/publication/manufacturing-job-loss-trade-... - perception of CS (dot-com & bust: '94-'01): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dot-com_bubble https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dot-com_bubble