3 ms·
The American Civil War has sometimes been described as the war whose history was written by the losers, as there is a lot of southern revisionism that obscures
by jcranmer 9y ago
The American Civil War has sometimes been described as the war whose history was written by the losers, as there is a lot of southern revisionism that obscures the causes of the civil war.
Chief of the revisions is that the war was not about slavery but states' rights. If you actually go read the CSA's constitution, though, the fallacy becomes clear. The confederate constitution is virtually a carbon copy of the US's constitution (with the amendments inserted into the body of the text). The only major differences are the explicit forbidding of the confederate government from levying tariffs for industrial production and promoting internal improvements, and the very explicit prohibition of the disavowal of slavery. This should be a clear indication of what the states were actually concerned about (especially when you also go read the actual declarations of succession).
While you might take some of the minor changes to be indicative of states' rights concerns, there's equally other minor changes that suggest they didn't actually believe in them. There's no clause granting states the right to nullify federal laws, and the Supremacy Clause remains untouched, for example (perhaps because the southern states were miffed by northern states' attempts to nullify the Fugitive Slave Act). And the preamble states outright that it is promulgated "in order to form a permanent federal government"--which suggests that succession was not in fact permissible in the CSA.
The south seceded and fought the Civil War because of slavery--or, more precisely, because they realized that they lost the political power to force the northern states to accept slavery. So they decided to pack up their toys and leave the sandbox rather than be the minority.