3 ms·
> HN has a simple but effective system You must be new here :) HN has an obvious problem with favouritism. Posts by some users are getting more upvotes regard
by huhtenberg 16y ago
> HN has a simple but effective system
You must be new here :)
HN has an obvious problem with favouritism. Posts by some users are getting more upvotes regardless of what they post. The same goes for submissions. Blogs not really worthy of any attention are constantly floating on the front page simply because they are darlings of a part of the HN crowd.
Though HN manages the maintain reasonably good comment quality with few simple measures. That's indeed an impressive achievement.
- lotharbot 16y agoeffective =/= perfect > "HN manages the maintain reasonably good comment quality with few simple measures." That's really the point -- the system works to maintain good comment quality. Different sites will require different measures; the key is figuring out which ones you need. The original article's comment on carrots and sticks displayed a surprising lack of understanding of this principle; it seemed to suggest that the lack of one particular type of carrot/stick makes creating a quality online comment system an intractable problem.
- doron 16y agoThe key phrase here is "general-interest" cohesion of the group is harder to achieve when the range of topics is very wide. Most of the sites that maintain a good discourse revolve around specific subjects, often to a specialized degree. HN is a group that discusses technology and its implications, this framework gives the group a cohesive context. The scale is different.