6 ms·
Is 2017 the beginning of the end for the app economy?
- majewsky 9y agoThese stats may be "scary", but they sure ain't surprising. > The number of app store applications is down significantly in 2017, averaging only 500 per day since the turn of the year. Well, duh. Everyone and their dog already has their own app, so of course the number of new applications goes down at some point. It's called market saturation. Look it up some time. > ComScore data suggests that half of U.S. smartphone users download zero apps each month Well, duh. At this point I've figured out the set of 5-10 apps that I actually use, so it's entirely realistic that I will go for another few months before installing the next app. I actually find it surprising that every second customer downloads a new app each month. > If you Can get users to hit download, according to Flurry Analytics, only 36 percent of apps are retained after one month and only 11 percent for a year. Well, duh. A lot of app downloads are for one-off usages, like "I need to scan this one QR code" or "I will use this Wifi analyzer to check which Wifi channels are overcrowded and choose the best channel for my router". > Even worse, says Andrew Chen, the average app loses 77 percent of its daily mobile users (DAU) within the first three days, and 95 percent of apps aren’t used regularly after 90 days. You can tell that something's very very wrong with the app industry when they consider it a bad thing that they can't get you addicted to their product. EDIT: One more thing: > [Pinterest] leveraged massive incoming traffic to their website and then used that as an opportunity to get users to download and install the app, a platform where in Pinterest’s case they could engage with the user even more deeply. Why does every website ever want me to download and install their app, when the web is just as powerful an application platform for 90% of use cases? When they say "engage with the user even more deeply", the only two things that spring to my mind are annoying notifications and always-on tracking.
- kbart 9y ago"Why does every website ever want me to download and install their app, when the web is just as powerful an application platform for 90% of use cases?" Yeah, that's annoying as hell. It's like an old "best viewed with IE" all over again. A wast regression from functional and vendor neutral web.
- qznc 9y ago> You can tell that something's very very wrong with the app industry when they consider it a bad thing that they can't get you addicted to their product. I guess the problem is that the 0–1$ people paid for the app is not enough. The real goal is attention and upselling. If people had paid 10-20$ it would be fine if they ditch the app, because the creator already got paid enough.
- ge0rg 9y agoWhy does every website ever want me to download and install their app, when the web is just as powerful an application platform for 90% of use cases? Especially if the app is a really badly made bloated webview wrapper that doesn't work when you are offline and only provides a subset of the website's functionality.
- erikpukinskis 9y ago> Why does every website ever want me to download and install their app, when the web is just as powerful an application platform for 90% of use cases? Because the web is fundamentally more accessible for users, and web sites are easier to build, their web site was where they actually... you know... operated their business. Because of that, the business pushed the web site as far as it could go... embedded advertising widgets, third party integrations, one off marketing pages, random features for this user or that internal department. The thing grew because it was being used. Meanwhile the programmers programmed as fast as their little hands could type, and drove complexity right off the complexity cliff, because there is no Complexity Cliff sign... at some point you just realize you already went off it and you're headed for the ground. At that point, the programmers subconsciously realize they need a new codebase, that time-to-feature is increasing superlinearly, but they don't want to admit their code is fundamentally flawed, but what if there was an excuse to start over.... Oh wait, an App! We can use Everything We Learned to try again with a Better Architecture, and really get The Design right and even add a couple New Features we've been cooking up! It's so much easier now to write an app than it was five years ago when I looked into it and it Seemed Hard, let's hire some iOS developers we'll have a V2 app in no time, and it's the Age Of Apps so most of our users will switch anyway. Especially since our web site is having... issues. Flash forward plannedAppDevelopmentCycle * 3 and oh wait... our app takes 7 clicks and 97 seconds longer to get into than our web site. And only 38% of our visitors have a compatible device. And coding it is not easier. And damnit why are all of these users still using that crappy old feature don't they realize the app is cleaner and the animations are smoother and that makes up for any missing features? And oh wait, complexity in our app is growing. And this new UI V2 concept our designer said would solve all our sign up flow problems isn't actually improving metrics. And jeez... Our web site is looking really old in the tooth now that we just spent 18 months prioritizing app development. And what about Android? Huh. Wait, how much is our runwa...
- maxsavin 9y agoThe more honest explanation here is that our industry is producing apps that are junk. Everybody enjoyed downloading apps because they got a kick out of them. Now the industry is mostly pumping decaf.
- Nr7 9y agoIt's a similar phenomenon as the video game crash of the early 80s. Companies flooded the market with hastily made shoddy games just to get a quick buck but it resulted in nobody wanting to buy games anymore because most of them were garbage.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- erikpukinskis 9y agoStill waiting for that one to rebound. The vast majority of game developers seem to be just remaking old games with new "content" in tired old genres. Oh another game where you bleep an angry creature til they bloop and you get a point. Great. Oh, I can upgrade my bleeper? Wow. I think it's because the industry attracts people who are, for whatever reason, avoiding meatspace activities. They get immersed in game industry memes and then that's all they know. I see a game about farming and it's like... Do you even understand what farming is like or why it's fun? But they don't... They just re-make MineCraft with farming graphics because they don't actually go out into the world and, like, farm. Do stuff. Understand what the world is like. Because the people who like the world never left it, never escaped to video games. At this point I don't even play games any more, I just watch YouTube reviews of them and spend my time designing games on my own. I think it's a huge missed opportunity though, and when people realize it there will be a gold rush on games that are actually about something.
- sidegrid 9y agoRebound? There are more games made in a year with diverse mechanics than could possibly be played in a year. Itch.io, Kongregate, Steam, "IO games" like agar.io, game jams, VR games... There's a lot of shitty games being made but there's not a lack of good ones.
- martinald 9y agoWhat would equivalent stats be for web sites? I bet very similar.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rusk 9y agoMy take on this is that there are two factors contributing to this, and they neatly fall upon the boundaries of the two major app ecosystems. I think these issues are fixable, and I think big inroads have been made in the second. Firstly, the Apple ecosystem, or the iOS ecosystem really - putting aside the Mac Appstore for now - is fraught with overhead and bureaucracy. Bootstrapping as a developer is relatively expensive given you need to have a modern mac of some sort and you have to pay a subscription which I think cuts off some of the hobbyists. Then once you're rolling, the amount of red tape involved in testing, releasing, updating etc really is shocking. I'm involved in a project where we support an App for both Android and iOS and really, 90% of the work on the Apple end is managing all this bureaucracy. This is massively expensive, and when asked for recommendations on another project I said "develop for Android first and then hire an agency to port it to iOS". The amount of messing involved really makes this a specialist competency like Solicitors' conveyancing or something and it really doesn't make sense having your innovation team waste their effort on it. Secondly then is the lack of quality control in the Android ecosystem. Aside from a few established titles, the Play-store really is a crap-shoot in terms of whether you'll get a good app in a specialist area or somebody just chancing their arm. Like I say this has come along a good bit, but in my Android devices I often just skip on Apps entirely because I really can't be sure whether I'm installing something dodgy or not. I do appreciate the irony that each ecosystem's strengths derive from the what I pose as its weaknesses i.e. bureaucracy => better quality app store; open submission process => lack of quality control. As both a producer and a consumer however, I am just highlighting what I see as the key issues that are limiting growth. It must be said I see ongoing improvements in the second area though, but increasing impediments in the first.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoThen once you're rolling, the amount of red tape involved in testing, releasing, updating etc really is shocking. I've been doing iOS dev for seven years, and have launched dozens of apps for organizations large and small, many of which had Android versions too. I have no idea what you're talking about here. Yes, you have to submit updates for approval, but it's quick and easy, and I can count on one hand the number of rejections I've ever gotten, all of which were easily fixed. 95% of my updates are approved in 1-2 days. On the testing side, TestFlight and other tools make testing pretty quick and easy. So what is the "bureaucracy" you're talking about? The biggest issues with iOS are the 30% cut Apple takes, and discoverability on the store. The dev experience is actually pretty good, and the user experience is much better than Android. Apple's balance here is FAR superior to Android's.
- taylodl 9y agoIt's not the end of the app economy, it's just the app economy is in the long tail mode now. Every obvious app that's going to have wide appeal has already been created. Now it's about filling in the niches. Though there's fewer users in the market for a niche app I'd wager they'd be much more willing to pay for it - so paradoxically there may be more money to be had in these niche apps. For example, I'm a musician and I'll drop $10 on a niche app without batting an eye.
- ethbro 9y ago> Pinterest understands this well, creating a dynamic dialogue between its website and app worlds to improve the ‘stickiness’ of both. Stopped reading. Seriously, fuck Pinterest. Hit a random link here: https://www.pinterest.com/explore/wall-colors/ https://www.pinterest.com/explore/wall-colors/ Try and interact with the web version. Then tell me that's a UX we're lauding?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- LoonyBalloony 9y agoI'm not a app making professional, but it is my understanding that web versions are deliberately sabotaged to coerce people into downloading the app. (so they can steal more data? Dunno)
- ethbro 9y agoThat absolutely seems to be the case. Which is why I have such a problem with this article discussing the benefits of creating quality app and web experiences, then holding up one of the worst web-to-force-app-installs as a paragon of good design.
- shandor 9y agoThis is so stupid. I mean, I don't need the apps, so any kind of coercion is pretty much doomed to fail. I don't usually need LinkedIn, and I definitely don't "need" Pinterest, ever. Making their websites suck more to encourage me to install some never-used app just means I use their whole product less, making it almost impossible that I'd ever get invested enough in it to install an app for it. Conversely, if their websites were awesome, it might make me use them more, which would only increase the likelihood of me wanting to go the extra mile to even install an app.
- ethbro 9y agoI would guess that we see this because the folks with their hands on the levers aren't measuring failure: their metrics are all targeted at success (app conversions). So anything they do is calibrated to move that needle without awareness of (or caring) how many users they're losing. ... Or at least, that's the best explanation I can come up with for why some companies seem so deadset on shooting themselves in the foot.
- monochromatic 9y agoApp developers: what percentage of apps provide no more functionality than just going to your website, but exist only to make it easier for you to collect data about me?
- potatolicious 9y agoApp developer here: there are two answers to that question, and one myth to dispel. First the myth: apps do not necessarily collect more data about you. In fact as far as sketchy advertisement tracking goes, the web is far more pernicious and gives away much more of your data than native apps. For one thing, on websites ad networks track not only what you do on that website, but can track you across sites. This is banned in native-land on pain of Apple swinging a very large banhammer on you. App developers are largely only collecting analytics on your actions in-app, and not feeding it into a larger ad network. Even web views from inside the app (which are often used to show ads) do not have access to the cookies in your standard browser, making cross-app tracking considerably more difficult. Anyways, to answer your question: 1 - On a strict numerical basis, most apps (70%+?) provide no significant improvement over visiting the website and are largely pointless. 2 - When weighted by installations or usage, most apps provide dramatic improvements over visiting the website and users would significantly suffer if forced into a website-only option. Which is I guess the obfuscated way of saying: most apps are pointless, but nobody installs them anyway, they just languish in the far corners of the App Store. The apps people tend to give a shit about (see: Facebook, Google Maps, Spotify, etc) tend to have a significant amount of functionality that is only possible (or only practical) in a native app, and would be significantly worse as a website.
- monochromatic 9y agoInteresting. What sort of functionality is possible in, say, the Facebook app as compared to the mobile website?
- potatolicious 9y agoHmm, where to even start? Some off the top of my head: - Web doesn't have access to the camera. Uploading a photo to Facebook is easy because you can launch the camera directly in-app, without having to use a separate camera app, save the image to disk locally, and then picking it for upload. Importantly also is the rise of photo filters, which would be impossible to live preview on a website. - Importantly also, there is an increase in live streaming, which would be impossible from a mobile site. - Uploading photos/videos is also easy because you can leave the app as soon as the upload begins, the upload will be finished in the background. This is flat-out impossible via a mobile website. With a mobile site you'd at least have to keep the app around and be unable to do anything else with your phone until any uploads are complete. - Offline/semi-offline interactions are actually possible in a native app. The nature of phones is that it can be out of connectivity, or be in areas with unreliable connectivity, and should still function. With a native app actions performed while offline/marginally online (posting, commenting, liking, etc) can be cached and performed in the background once the phone has better connectivity. A website cannot do this. - On the consumption side, there are many advantages to the native app: - The incremental page loads that FB does (and Twitter, and Instagram, and everone else) bog down a browser quickly. Laying out the entire DOM is extremely resource intensive and a major source of poor scrolling performance. Even on modern desktops, try scrolling down a bunch of pages in your FB feed (or Twitter feed), and watch the performance tank quickly until scrolling is like pulling teeth. The native apps are immune to this kind of limitation, since there is no DOM and only what's on screen is actively being laid out (all off-screen content has no impact on render performance). - No whole-DOM layout also means that the app is more responsive on launch. In app dev we have a concept known as the "cold start time" - which is the latency between tapping on an app's icon and having the app be fully interactive and ready for the user. Webapps do a lot worse in this regard for many reasons: needing to transmit the entire DOM, JS performance issues, layout CPU consumption, etc, that native apps are less susceptible to, or fully immune to. - In bandwidth constrained situations (which is, well, a lot of the world), a native app passing purely semantic data consumes a lot less data than a webapp that needs to transmit semantic and presentational data. A JSON or Protobuf payload is a lot smaller than a HTML/JS/CSS payload. - Media is more effectively fetched in native, which is aware of cell vs. wifi, and can customize the resolution/size of content fetched based on network conditions. The browser provides no access to the primitives that it would take to implement this. - Videos can be inlined in the stream, which is impossible on most mobile browsers, allowing users to quickly preview video content before deciding whether or not to watch it.
- ThomPete 9y agoThere was never really an app economy in the sense of a thriving economy for apps on the app store. It's always been a small fraction of apps that made it and the rest not making any money. They could however go on for ever because the cost of keeping them up is close to zero so it always looked like it was way more successful and lucrative than it really was. There is a much more successful app economy that's been around since the inception of the personal computer which is doing ok. Some are SAAS apps others are little tool apps like my own, even others are open source apps and yet others are shareware. In other words. As long as you don't define app economy only as what happens on the mac app store then the app economy is doing ok and we haven't seen the end of it. However if you only think in terms of apple app store then I would say it's never been there to begin with. There are some larger trends I believe that renders the idea of apps as products useless but that's for another topic.
- increment_i 9y ago>> There are some larger trends I believe that renders the idea of apps as products useless but that's for another topic. I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts on this point. May as well expound on it right here.
- potatolicious 9y agoNot the OP, but I've been developing apps for years and agree with the sentiment. A few thoughts: There are, in my mind, 4 broad categories of apps: - 1: Games with microtransactions, think Clash of Clans, Candy Crush, Pokemon Go, etc. - 2: Games without microtransactions (sold full-price), I honestly can't name any right now. - 3: Apps tied to some kind of service not exclusively on the phone, think Uber, Grubhub, Amazon, Gmail, Facebook. These are apps who are - 4: Apps that primarily provide value only on the phone, sold for money. Think Dark Sky... and not many others that are still alive. Categories #1 and #3 are alive and well, and I think will continue to be for the foreseeable future. Categories #2 and #4 are dead. The article says it's the "beginning of the end", but I'd argue it's very close to the end of the end. The trend I've been seeing is that apps in category #4 are not only failing commercially, but also increasingly being pulled into the greater ecosystems of apps in Category #3. Instead of buying a standalone flight-tracking app, it's now integrated into a travel company's app - think Expedia or Kayak. Instead of buying a standalone weather app, it's now table stakes in either the OS itself, or integrated into larger apps like Google. Instead of buying a standalone package/delivery tracking app, it's now integrated into a retail app, like Amazon or Wal-Mart. etc etc, that's the trend I'm seeing. Apps-sold-as-standalone-products is generally speaking dead, their ultimate fate is that their feature sets are absorbed into apps/services that make Actual Money(tm).
- Noseshine 9y agoHere is why the startup I write code for wants an app first and browser code second. We actually would prefer the browser by leaps and bounds, cutting the need for central servers and decentralization is a core idea, you should remain in control of all your data. The problem: The only viable way to store a significant amount of data in the browser is IndexedDB. Which allows you only some storage of the total available - and, much much worse, the browser can wipe the data at any time without warning. It simply is not possible to provide our data-storage related system without either a central server backing up the browser "app" - or writing an app for iOS and Android.
- wcummings 9y agoI sure hope so. We need to improve the web experience on mobile, not foist dozens of mediocre apps onto users. Its telling that HN has one of the best mobile experiences of all the sites I regularly visit on my phone. I frequently find myself jabbing at the screen in frustration when operating more "complex" sites.
- kristianc 9y agoWorth bearing in mind that this is a piece of PR / thought leadership for a media conglomerate that mainly plays in Sub Saharan African countries and India, where data is more of an issue, and people are more choosy about what they keep on their phones. Not immediately obvious on a first read unless you can spot the signs of such a piece. If you look at this argument through a developed market lens there are obvious weaknesses, for instance the complete failure to address WeChat.
- dominotw 9y ago>data is more of an issue For me the issues are , Too many apps asking for too many permissions. What are they doing with my photos? Yea no. Are they running in the background sucking the life out of my phone? Steve Jobs had the correct idea of not letting third party apps background.