2 ms·
The jargon metaphor was promising, but the bit about authority doesn't work. Soccer rules are intrinsically created by fiat; there is no pre-existing set of soc
by jerf 16y ago
The jargon metaphor was promising, but the bit about authority doesn't work. Soccer rules are intrinsically created by fiat; there is no pre-existing set of soccer rules that we have to discover through a contentious, challenging, and unreliable investigation over the course of decades, they literally are handed to us by an authority. Appeal to authority in such a situation is not a fallacy, it is the only proper basis for argument. I see what the author was getting at, but I think it fails to make the point. Did enjoy the "what's this all mean to the common man?" point, though.