3 ms·
This is the broken window fallacy. Every dollar spent "investing" in military r&d, Is one less dollar that can be invested elsewhere. Why not just invest all
by stale2002 9y ago
This is the broken window fallacy.
Every dollar spent "investing" in military r&d, Is one less dollar that can be invested elsewhere.
Why not just invest all that money directly into the economy instead of doing it in an extremely roundabout way.
Or, I don't know, just pay people to dig holes and fill them back up again, if you believe in the idea of economic "stimulus".
- mickrussom 9y agoSometimes space and military programs will produce technology that later becomes commercially very useful, eg, Raytheon and the microwave oven (First introduced Radarange 1946 - and Amana made a more generally consumable model in 1967). The whole "dig holes and fill them up again" was wonderfully covered in Orwell,1984.. The noble version of this would be Space Exploration, search for unlimited energy (eg, fusion), or cancer cures. The military industrial complex speech given by a sitting US president, Eisenhower, here - http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/eisenhower001.asp http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/eisenhower001.asp - more or less predicted that the 1984-style approach to perpetual state of war will be taken unless big changes were made. "War, it will be seen, accomplishes the necessary destruction, but accomplishes it in a psychologically acceptable way. In principle it would be quite simple to waste the surplus labour of the world by building temples and pyramids, by digging holes and filling them up again, or even by producing vast quantities of goods and then setting fire to them. But this would provide only the economic and not the emotional basis for a hierarchical society. What is concerned here is not the morale of masses, whose attitude is unimportant so long as they are kept steadily at work, but the morale of the Party itself. Even the humblest Party member is expected to be competent, industrious, and even intelligent within narrow limits, but it is also necessary that he should be a credulous and ignorant fanatic whose prevailing moods are fear, hatred, adulation, and orgiastic triumph. In other words it is necessary that he should have the mentality appropriate to a state of war. It does not matter whether the war is actually happening, and, since no decisive victory is possible, it does not matter whether the war is going well or badly. All that is needed is that a state of war should exist. The splitting of the intelligence which the Party requires of its members, and which is more easily achieved in an atmosphere of war, is now almost universal, but the higher up the ranks one goes, the more marked it becomes. It is precisely in the Inner Party that war hysteria and hatred of the enemy are strongest. In his capacity as an administrator, it is often necessary for a member of the Inner Party to know that this or that item of war news is untruthful, and he may often be aware that the entire war is spurious and is either not happening or is being waged for purposes quite other than the declared ones: but such knowledge is easily neutralized by the technique of doublethink. Meanwhile no Inner Party member wavers for an instant in his mystical belief that the war is real, and that it is bound to end victoriously, with Oceania the undisputed master of the entire world. "
- tehlike 9y agoThe military tech is actually useful - many of the things we use today as ubiquitous was an artifact of military. It's definitely not the same thing as digging down holes. However, what i do not know is how much of US military spending is on R&D
- stale2002 9y agoBut why not just invest in those things directly? Example: GPS was invented by the military. But you could have a different government organization work on all the useful stuff that comes out of the military that has nothing to do with blowing people up. You could also argue that if you invest trillions of dollars into digging holes, that might result in useful technology. Taking the example of GPS, maybe you need to very accurately know what your position is, so that you can pinpoint exactly where you want the hole to be built. My hole digging government department could have invented GPS too!
- tehlike 9y agoI think it comes to needs. Military needs a way to position vehicles, you get gps, same goed for arpanet. A good chunk of military inventions are done by civilians on military funding. I think it is the desire in US military to be always on the bleeding edge, and the accountability that it brings. There is also less pressure for profit, I guess. You said digging holes, elon musk is doing that boring job :)
- caseysoftware 9y ago> This is the broken window fallacy. No, it's not. With investment in military R&D, there's no "broken window." Claiming that destruction in one place (aka war) spurs growth is the broken window fallacy. It's possible that investment "directly into the economy" might be more effective except for the fact that you have to take the money out of the economy and put it into a few peoples' hands to direct. The fewer hands means the easier it is to corrupt or hijack the process. I'd rather for "the economy" to invest on its own. As Hayek said, I want "plans by the many not by the few."
- stale2002 9y agoBut with the military, you are already taking that money out of the economy and putting it into a few people's hands directly. I wasn't suggesting redistributing money from one company to another. I was suggesting having some sort of government agency, that spends trillions of dollars a year on doing all those R&D things that the military does that have nothing to do with blowing people up. Literally just "The military, minus the guns, bombs, fighter jets, and everything else that involves killing people". That wouldn't be perfect, but for the purpose of making the economy/world a better place, such a "not killing people military" seems like it would be strictly better than our current military.
- caseysoftware 9y agoTrillions of dollars per year? The entire US Defense Budget for 2016 was $600B while the entire budget was $3.8T.[1] Further, many large scale tech advancements have come from military R&D, originally with the goal of blowing people up, preventing them from getting blown up, or making them recover after the fact. Everything from the Internet to GPS to microwave to many synthetic fabrics to emergency medicine. I agree that investing in things that don't kill people is great and should be encouraged. It's just outside the scope of government. 1 - https://www.nationalpriorities.org/campaigns/military-spending-united-states/ https://www.nationalpriorities.org/campaigns/military-spendi...