4 ms·
I ask this because I sometimes struggle with over-literal interpretation of someone's words. Do you honestly think that telling someone their child has died is
by DanBC 9y ago
I ask this because I sometimes struggle with over-literal interpretation of someone's words.
Do you honestly think that telling someone their child has died is easy?
Is that an opinion you sincerely, honestly, hold?
- Mathnerd314 9y agoWell, my judgement for "easy" is how hard it is to find video of it. From a quick google, telling someone your father is dead is pretty easy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-y2uX2QI6k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-y2uX2QI6k The problem there is doing it sincerely, which seems a little harder, but still within reach. Again, though, this is just the article's prescription: write the script, follow the script. R.e. your second question, the answer there is no. Generally I don't hold opinions, I hold perspective, generally the perspective of whatever I just read. Trying to hold an opinion is the second-easiest way to be wrong. http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html
- aptwebapps 9y agoPractically speaking, how do you separate perspectives from opinions?
- Mathnerd314 9y agoWell, a perspective contains a position (i.e. an opinion), but it also has sensory information; a perspective sees something, hears something, feels something, etc. Whereas an opinion on its own doesn't have an experience associated with it; it's just a data point. To extend the analogy, a perspective connects the points and makes some sort of smooth line; a perspective has derivatives/directions, and the possibility of movement, whereas opinions don't. Practically, the difference between perspectives and opinions is itself a matter of perspective. E.g., take the sentence "You make my stomach churn". In a figurative sense, it's an opinion on a person and not really generalizable beyond the speaker. But if we take it literally, we can go down from the brain and into the body of the speaker, looking at some medical pages like https://health.clevelandclinic.org/2016/05/stomach-churning-may-gut-stress/ https://health.clevelandclinic.org/2016/05/stomach-churning-..., and get the perspective: adrenaline rush, sore stomach, anxious mind, etc. Particularly with text, you can consider it in two ways: as a performative utterance, the act of a human writing/speaking said text, or as a declarative bit of data, some sequence of bytes generated by a hidden process.