5 ms·
Probably not 2/3. The BJS collects information about the US prison population: https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/ascii/p15.txt https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/as
by maxerickson 9y ago
Probably not 2/3. The BJS collects information about the US prison population:
https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/ascii/p15.txt https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/ascii/p15.txt
Out of 1.5 million in federal and state prisons, about 700,000 were convicted of violent crimes. And of course the remainder are not exclusively low level drug crimes.
(the population in jails is usually less than 100,000 so it won't tip the balance)
Better drug policy could well impact the levels of violent crime and so impact the future prison population, but forgiving sentences for drug related violent crime is a step further than forgiving sentences for petty drug crimes.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI used to go to a boxing gym near Baltimore where a lot of people came from "bad" neighborhoods. A lot of the young guys had experienced a life where a lot of friends and neighbors had been in jail for drugs. Once you have been in jail its really hard to find a decent job so a lot of them go into drug dealing which often leads to violence. Jailing people for drugs destroys the whole social fabric of a community. I don't think you can separate low-level drug offenses from violent crime. One leads to the other.
- maxerickson 9y agoI thought my last paragraph there addressed this fairly well. If you are talking about reducing the prison population that exists right now, they sort of have to be separate. A murder that is the end result of a chain of events containing a lot of difficult choices is still a murder.
- maxxxxx 9y agoMy point is that the murder may not have happened if the perpetrator had grown up in a better neighborhood.
- maxerickson 9y agoYeah I understand, do you think the last paragraph in my first comment misses that point? My point is that we have people already in prison for past violent crimes, many of them, so even a policy change that has a big future impact still isn't going to quickly reduce the prison population by 2/3.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI didn't read your comment closely enough. Sorry. I agree that there won't be a quick reduction but at least the influx of new prisoners would be reduced and neighborhoods wouldn't get destroyed anymore.
- mgkimsal 9y ago> Once you have been in jail its really hard to find a decent job And that's another aspect that needs addressing, and can be done regardless of legal/political changes. Someone's been in jail/prison? Then they apply for a job with your company when they get out? Categorically denying them employment without regard to their previous offense is silly, although it's definitely policy at some (many?) companies. Helping people get back to a 'normal' life is something we all can take part in in various ways - not closing the door on applicants is another thing we can do.
- mancerayder 9y agoSomeone's been in jail/prison? Then they apply for a job with your company when they get out? Categorically denying them employment without regard to their previous offense is silly, although it's definitely policy at some (many?) companies. Helping people get back to a 'normal' life is something we all can take part in in various ways - not closing the door on applicants is another thing we can do. I agree, and here's the thing. Almost all companies I've worked for in the past decade have done drug testing and background checks on me, so if I had had issues in my youth I wouldn't have been hired. And this is IT, I wasn't applying to be a police officer, lawyer, or crane operator. Pass laws to RESTRICT companies from doing these types of unjustified checks (or have them justify them) instead of unlocking the prisons and letting criminals out. That communities are destroyed is a powerful argument, but I'm sorry, I don't need gangsters running around in my neighborhood. I'd much prefer they serve their time, and be able to work wherever they want (within reason) once they're out. But in the U.S. we feel that businesses should have much 'freedom' as we call it, to hire and fire unimpeded. So there's the impasse.
- Noos 9y agoIt's all unjustified to you until you actually have someone who steals to support their drug addiction, threatens coworkers, commits violence, or worse. So many people here seem to love the idea that drug users are these innocent people wrong by society, but it's usually because they are already insulated from them in their workplaces. All it takes is someone high behind the wheels of a forklift to understand why these policies are in place, or someone in charge of industrial machinery showing up drunk or stoned or worse. Or a nurse who essentially robs the hospital blind to feed an addiction.
- tyingq 9y agoI agree it's not 2/3rds, but it's a significant amount. "249,900 state prisoners (19%) were sentenced to at least 1 year for property offenses. Sixteen percent of state prisoners were serving sentences for drug-related offenses" Note that a fair amount of "property offenses" are really drug offenses. You steal things to feed your habit. And..."Nearly half of federal prisoners incarcerated on September 30, 2015 had been sentenced for drug offenses, the most recent date for which federal offense data were available"