18 ms·
Too many prisons make people worse
- gtirloni 9y agoA few weeks ago, running the subway in a major North American city, I kept admiring how people were polite and waited for other people to leave the trains before entering, how many times I saw someone give up their seats for the elderly (not that they really needed, there were a lot of empty seats elsewhere). That got me thinking if those same people would be as polite if they were in the same train but with 20x more people around. I think extreme situations are a great equalizer in crowded situations and it's my feeling they would behave the same: not wait for anyone, not give up seats, etc. My point is, what works for Norway (population: 5.2m, prison population: 3874 or 0.0745% [0]) is never going to work for Brazil (population: 207m, prison population: 659020 or 0.31% [1]). I like the idea of these idyllic prisons but inmates that will fit those are the exception here. Nevertheless, the system should offer them and help good inmates to be removed from the terrible traditional prisons so they don't become worse. It's often said that prisons are like college for criminals. I don't know if this system could handle things like this: http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/01/60-killed-beheaded-grisly-brazil-prison-riot-170102185216472.html http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/01/60-killed-beheaded-gri... In summary, I love the idea but let's not pretend that by just having those prisons that things will change drastically. It's a complex situation and there are problems everywhere (bad laws, slow courts, poverty, etc). 0 - http://www.prisonstudies.org/country/norway http://www.prisonstudies.org/country/norway 1 - http://www.prisonstudies.org/country/brazil http://www.prisonstudies.org/country/brazil
- matt4077 9y ago"You can judge a society by how well it treats its prisoners", was actually said by a Russian–he knew what he was talking about. The US could start by no longer jailing drug consumers or first-time low-level street dealers. It just really really doesn't work anyway. That would reduce the prison population by what? 2/3? Suddenly you have 3x the budget and space, which should allow for quite a few improvements. But what really needs to be done with it the basic idea of prison as some sort of moral retribution. Come up with a formula to quantify and compare the outcomes of the criminal justice system, then start maximising. The US could easily study the effects of prison and other punishments (as well as social programs, medial intervention etc) in every detail imaginary. (Also I don't quite get your analogy. Are you saying Americans tend to be violent because there are too many of them for one country? FWIW the US is No 182 in terms of population density, barely ahead of Norway at No. 202. Far far ahead are Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan, and most of Europe, all of which have only a fraction of the violent crime of the US)
- maxerickson 9y agoProbably not 2/3. The BJS collects information about the US prison population: https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/ascii/p15.txt https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/ascii/p15.txt Out of 1.5 million in federal and state prisons, about 700,000 were convicted of violent crimes. And of course the remainder are not exclusively low level drug crimes. (the population in jails is usually less than 100,000 so it won't tip the balance) Better drug policy could well impact the levels of violent crime and so impact the future prison population, but forgiving sentences for drug related violent crime is a step further than forgiving sentences for petty drug crimes.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI used to go to a boxing gym near Baltimore where a lot of people came from "bad" neighborhoods. A lot of the young guys had experienced a life where a lot of friends and neighbors had been in jail for drugs. Once you have been in jail its really hard to find a decent job so a lot of them go into drug dealing which often leads to violence. Jailing people for drugs destroys the whole social fabric of a community. I don't think you can separate low-level drug offenses from violent crime. One leads to the other.
- maxerickson 9y agoI thought my last paragraph there addressed this fairly well. If you are talking about reducing the prison population that exists right now, they sort of have to be separate. A murder that is the end result of a chain of events containing a lot of difficult choices is still a murder.
- maxxxxx 9y agoMy point is that the murder may not have happened if the perpetrator had grown up in a better neighborhood.
- maxerickson 9y ago
- Retric 9y agoIt's prison population / N prisons. So, each prison could have equivalent populations. Further, the costs don't drop with overcrowding etc, your just taking out a loan with interest. Underpay now, and you will overpay in the future.
- gtirloni 9y agoThat's a good point and I failed to match my argument with more information about the context. Brazil is a failed state (both politically and financially), so with more inmates and less money (for more prisons and rehabilitation projects), that creates quite the situation.
- sampo 9y ago> My point is, what works for Norway (population: 5.2m, prison population: 3874 or 0.0745% [0]) is never going to work for Brazil (population: 207m, prison population: 659020 or 0.31% [1]). Actually the population density of Brazil is just 1.5 times that of Norway. Not a great difference.
- cam_l 9y agoYeah, I have come to understand the whole population scale argument is just an example of American (or in this case Brazilian) exceptionalism. Basically just a right wing taking point that denied the reasons in favour of a blanket 'this well not work here' fallacious argument.
- joshjje 9y agoWhile I dont really agree with the original argument, while what you say is true, I dont think population density was the point. Prison population as a percentage of the total was. Brazil has ~4.2 times higher prison population compared to total. You could argue that compounds with the 1.5 times population density though which would come out to ~6.4 times prison population density. Though 659k vs 3.9k prisoners is a pretty significant difference if you look at it that way.
- cgriswald 9y agoIf you were to place New York City on Mars, you could have its population density be any value you want simply by expanding its political borders. When comparing countries, it's the distribution that matters. If I have 50 people spread throughout my house, or 50 people shoved into a single room in my house, my house will have the same population density, but in the latter case I'll have 50 pretty irritable people. The same is true for a country. Take Canada: It's population density is quite low, but that doesn't paint a very accurate picture of living conditions, since the vast majority of the population lives within a much smaller region along the US border. In any case, I agree with the sibling that population density is not the statistic the GP is using in support of his position. He is using prisoner per capita, which is 3x higher for Brazil than Norway and surely has at least some effect on the ability of Brazil to treat its prisoners in the same way.
- tormeh 9y ago> I don't know if this system could handle things like this: http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/01/60-killed-beheaded-gri.. http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/01/60-killed-beheaded-gri.... The simple answer is that it's not a relevant question. It doesn't happen in Norway because there's no reason for anyone to join a drug gang the like of which there are in Brazil. If you were to be cynical about it, you could say that the Norwegian welfare state is so generous it will pay people to sit on their ass and do no harm. Anyone who joins a drug gang in Norway does so out of lifestyle problems, not economic problems. The gangs are correspondingly small. All that said, Norway has very unenlightened drug policies, and drug related deaths are very common compared to other European countries. There's a small but nasty subculture of bad criminals and bad police that will make life hard for you if you enter it. But at least money doesn't force you to.
- vivekd 9y agoWell even in Norway, the prison in the article is not the norm, it is the exception. >Inmates do not start their sentences at Bastoy. They must do time in a conventional lockup and apply to be transferred, having convinced the authorities that they wish to reform. I work with a lot of criminals. In my experience, many times, the ones that go to jail go there because they really are bad people and have no wish to reform. It would be very difficult to change and reform these people just with outside intervention. However, for the ones with a genuine wish to reform, it would be nice to get them into a facility like this. I guess the real problem is there is no real easy solution for how to deal with bad people. I think there needs to be a mixed solution that takes into account the individual and their wish to reform. And really from that perspective, we do have many similar institutions in the West, like half way houses and various criminal rehabilitation programs.
- jackmott 9y agoI wonder if the "but that would.never work in america" people ever think about the old head and shoulders commercials ...they probably didn't get the joke.
- ajmurmann 9y agoI'm not sure if size is an excuse. Isn't density a much larger problem. The US certainly had the space to properly house it's inmates. Is it larger proportion of the population that's in prison that's the problem? Why is that the case? The US being large doesn't seem like it should cause that.
- sumedh 9y ago> I kept admiring how people were polite and waited for other people to leave the trains before entering Well that happens in Mumbai local trains as well during peak hours, it has nothing to do with politeness.
- rectang 9y agoThis doesn't apply in the USA, since for our citizens the purpose of our prison system is not to rehabilitate, but to inflict savage vengeance.
- psyc 9y agoPerhaps it's a reflection of Christianity. It's the will of God that evildoers go to hell, to be tormented by other demons like themselves.
- cgriswald 9y agoChristianity? That is a stretch. Christians believe in divine forgiveness and some sects even believe man does not have the right to punish man; that doing so is doing God's job. Punishment as retribution is way, way older than Christianity. Are we hanging onto it in the United States as a relic of our (specifically) Puritan origins? Possibly.
- camus2 9y ago> Perhaps it's a reflection of Christianity. It's a reflection of Puritanism, not Christianity as a whole.
- psyc 9y agoWhat I meant is that it could be a manifestation of an archetype in the Christian imagination - the 5th circle of hell. I did not have any conscious implementation of a doctrine for dealing with punishment in mind.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoThe American system of justice is not to rehabilitate, but to humiliate, punish, and torture. Worse, we outsource this to the private prison system which has an incentive to keep people in prison. You go to prison in America you will be brutally tortured, humiliated, and will emerge far worse than when you went in. That is the fault of every American citizen - not the politicians - but the people. Because it is the citizenry who punishes the politician that appears even remotely soft on prisoners, or supports prison reform. America is a vengeful society, overflowing with righteous indignation.
- tormeh 9y ago> overflowing with righteous indignation As a non-American, I have to say this is the most puzzling thing about the US: The abundance of anger and indignation in public debate. I guess it's a natural consequence of a winner-takes-all voting system in combination with a vast and heterogeneous population.
- sotojuan 9y agoIt's a combination of that and our Puritan background. There aren't many societies more bent on shaming and excluding than 17th century Puritans.
- mikekchar 9y agoOn the contrary. <rapidly fashions tinfoil hat> The US is a representative democracy with only 2 credible political parties. In such a system, if you are one of the incumbents, it pays to polarise every issue: that way no third part can emerge. At the very worst, you are out of power for 8-12 years, but you always come back into power. If you manage to get you hooks into the media, then you can encourage them to polarise every issue too. They'll love it, because confirmation bias is a powerful force. It leads to rabid followers of the various institutions -- who deride the followers of the other institutions. Hmmm... tin foil hats are comfy. I think I'll wear this one for a while...
- tormeh 9y ago
- dmh2000 9y agoThe US has minimum security prisons also and just like this one, you have to qualify one way or the other. https://www.forbes.com/2009/07/13/best-prisons-cushiest-madoff-personal-finance-lockups_slide_2.html?thisspeed=25000 https://www.forbes.com/2009/07/13/best-prisons-cushiest-mado...
- refurb 9y agoYeah, this article is a bit confusing. The US has prisons just like this. Prisoners who commit less severe crimes or prisoners who have a good record are eligible. Do journalists think every US prison is like Pelican Bay? Do they think Shawshank Redemption is representative of the norm in the US?
- ams6110 9y agoLike any other commercial media, the main goal of The Economist is to get readers/subscribers. Slanted, inflammatory stories do a better job at that than objective, well-researched pieces that present a fuller picture.
- adrianlmm 9y agoWho wrote that article? I can't find the source anywhere.
- ahiknsr 9y agoarticles are often the work of The Economist's hive mind, rather than of a single author[1] . [1]http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/09/economist-explains-itself-1 http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/09/ec...
- Symmetry 9y ago"The Economist is 160+ years old, and back then anonymity was the norm. Then the industry went on a slightly disturbing path toward writer celebrity, and we simply chose not to participate." https://andreaskluth.org/2008/11/20/why-the-economist-has-no-bylines/ https://andreaskluth.org/2008/11/20/why-the-economist-has-no...
- hnaparst 9y agoA discussion about disenfranchisement conducted by the least disenfranchised people on earth. Pretty funny.
- tormeh 9y agoWould a prison dichotomy be a good idea? That is, the reformable criminals go to rehabilitation, and the ones for which there is no hope go in for life (or at least until old age)?
- rectang 9y agoWhat are you trying to optimize for? The American system exists to satiate our citizenry's craving for cruelty (and to express hatred for minorities), and in that capacity it is a resounding success.
- Unbeliever69 9y ago"so long will they be a little people, a silly people, greedy, barbarous, and cruel"
- fjdlwlv 9y agoSo, in practice, white people in rehab, black people in prison? That's what we do now. See the Reagan era disparity in cocaine vs crack punishment
- tormeh 9y agoWhy is it a problem for the free public that people get worse in prison if they never get out? Obviously there's something wrong here. While your caricature reflects an underlying truth, it's certainly way too exaggerated.
- rectang 9y agoThe systemic voter suppression of minority populations through felony disenfranchisement and disparities in enforcement are at odds with what Americans profess as an ideal, that "all men are created equal".
- crucini 9y agoBut we sort of have that already. First offences tend to get lesser sanctions, including probation, which is an attempt to curb bad behavior without imprisonment. In California at least, the three strikes law means that three convictions above a certain threshold result in a life sentence. This sometimes makes the news when the third conviction is relatively minor, like shoplifting. California also has lifetime confinement for dangerous child molestors after completion of sentence.
- carsongross 9y agoOne advantage the Norwegian prison system has is that it is filled with Norwegians, I would be careful generalizing conclusions from it. That being said, one concept I rarely see discussed is the use of basic income as an incentive against crime, particularly violent crime: if you lost your citizens dividend after conviction and slowly earned it back every year upon release that would act as a powerful and immediate incentive to avoid violence.
- jackmott 9y agois there any evidence that incentives like that work for violent crime? we know that harshness of punishment has no impact on deterrence.
- anarazel 9y agoWouldn't it increase the likelihood of further crime, due to lack of income?
- posterboy 9y agoThat's ignoring that much crime happens out of greed, monetary or honourary, basic income doesn't satisfy either, by definition.
- Shivetya 9y agoprisons are just the beginning. when you get out you can find yourself prevented from obtaining a job, a residence, and even assistance, because of local, state, and federal laws. The Renew Act of 2017 is trying to expand the age limits for expungement of records of first time offenders.[1] its a start but there are more opportunities to fix the system post prison too. you don't even have to go to prison to have a record that prevents you from being productive in society. one of favorite examples are the volunteers for smoke jumping, putting out forest fires. there are states where its illegal for a person who did this job in prison to obtain the same outside. if we keep up the barriers where do we truly expect people to go? [1] http://dailysignal.com/2017/05/24/heres-smart-modest-increase-second-chances-deserving-ex-offenders/ http://dailysignal.com/2017/05/24/heres-smart-modest-increas...
- m3kw9 9y agoAmerican prison is actuall not a system but a culture. Think of how hard it is to change a culture, you probably need new leadership with enough power like a CEO at Microsoft to do something drastic in a reasonable amount of time, say 10 year frame.
- hackermailman 9y agoUnsurprisingly people who have done long stretches of time in Norway's prison system disagree with this article. Only a few prisoners enjoy the freedom of this island, which is equivalent to a trustee camp in a US min security prison. The rest who were given 10+ year sentences are in complete isolation in what the media loves to refer to as hotel prisons. In these cells everything is provided for you including your own shower, therefore there's no reasons for the guards to ever let you out and you stay in there 23hrs per day. Because the media calls them hotels, it prevents any prisoner from being able to complain and be taken seriously, so often these guys will either light their cells on fire and hopefully get transferred to one of the older style jails so they can talk to other inmates, or they just kill themselves.
- pilsetnieks 9y agoIsn't that basically solitary confinement, which is deemed a violation of the UN convention against torture? I was under the impression from the numerous articles that there are plenty of common rooms, kitchens, workshops, and other activities for inmates in those prisons. Also, could you please provide a source for your statement that "Unsurprisingly people who have done long stretches of time in Norway's prison system disagree with this article?"
- tokai 9y agoSolitary is very popular in the Scandinavian prison systems. It is even used extensively pretrial, for long periods of time. This is often forgotten when talking about the lenient Scandinavian prisons. https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/42150580/PSS_Scandinavian_Exceptionalism_2012.pdf?AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1495906998&Signature=u%2BVxt2EDzOacnowYANSTAmQ3RxY%3D&response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DA_critical_look_at_Scandinavian_exceptio.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/42150580/PSS...
- mistercow 9y agoDo you have a source where we can read more? Everything I'm finding is an article gushing about how humane Norway's prisons are. I keep finding headlines like "Twice as many suicides in Norwegian prisons" from The Norway Post, but their site won't actually load for me, and the Google cache on those results looks like it's probably their homepage. I wasn't able to find a lot, but I did find this: https://www.kriminalvarden.se/globalassets/publikationer/forskningsrapporter/prison-suicide-in-12-countriespdf https://www.kriminalvarden.se/globalassets/publikationer/for... That claims that the suicide rate per 100k in norway is 127. According to this: https://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=tp&tid=194 https://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=tp&tid=194 The US had around 20 in the same timeframe. Apparently local jails are worse, at around 40-50: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/08/04/why-jails-have-more-suicides-than-prisons#.sabBFJ6CE https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/08/04/why-jails-have... So what I've found so far seems to back you up: We're looking at Norway being something like an order of magnitude worse when it comes to prisons. But I'd like to find better data.
- hl5 9y agoThe better way is to reduce poverty. You can build whatever "rehibilitation" program you want, but if the future holds no promise, why follow the rules?
- lerie 9y agoThe USA has "boys homes" that do this. As a child, I attended one such place where we all had to grow our own vegetables, to this day I can grow vegetables. Privatized prisons (in the USA) are money makers, holding mostly low to medium risk offenders, you can even buy shares on the stock market. With more police on patrol there will be less crime. Spend less money on prisons and more money on local police force.
- ZephyrP 9y agoI did a stint in a state-operated group home for boys in 2006 and we definitely did not 'grow our own vegetables'.
- OliverJones 9y agoThe author wrote: "In America some prisoners are released after long sentences with little more than clothes and a bus fare." Rubbish. In the county where I live, Essex in MA, inmates are given the clothes they were wearing when arrested and a ride to the courthouse where they were convicted, and turned loose. Pity the guy arrested in May who gets out in January. They shoplift at the local Marshalls on their way home. I wonder why?
- cubano 9y agoThis is definately not rubbish. I have been released twice from the Florida DOC, both times from a panhandle camp (Gulf C.I) that was approximately 9 hours from my home. They definitely DO NOT give you the clothes "you were arrested in" as long ago those clothes were thrown away (at the "reception center" along with your cell phone, which was almost certainly stolen by the COs and/or convicts, and all other property you may have had) My first time through, in 2004, my ex-wife actually sent me a beautiful set of clothes to be released in. They were of course "lost". She was so upset when she came to pick me up the assholes in release were actually threatening to lock her and/or me up because she was making such a stink about me having no clothes for release. I ended up getting very ill fitting cheap-ass pants and a white t-shirt, and back then, a $100 dollar bill. That's it. Thankfully, I had her to pick me up and drive me home. The second time through I wasn't so lucky. In 2014 I was given the same shit clothes, only $50 this time as they changed the release policy, and a bus ticket. That is it. No cell phone, no wallet...nothing. It sounds like you are talking about jail, not prison.
- OliverJones 9y agoYes, correct, I'm talking about the Essex County Jail.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tuna-piano 9y agoWhy are we looking at Norway? Because it is doing something right, or because it fits the authors preplanned narrative? Singapore has much lower crime stats than Norway and the USA [1,2]. Let's take a look at how Singapore treats its prisoners. The punishment for even minor crimes (like graffiti) includes caning[3]. They stick you in a prison cell for months, and on some random morning, they will wake you up and give you the sentenced number of hard beatings to your backside. The beating is done by someone with specialized training to inflict maximum pain (while remaining safe). So for months, every day you are scared, never sleeping soundly, as you don't know if this will be the night of your beating. -Would the graffiti rate in the USA go up or down if the USA imposed the same penalties as Singapore? -Would reducing recidivism rates by 20-50%, as the article claims possible, really be enough to lower crime in the USA to a OECD average level [4]? -Norway and Singapore each have ~5M people. Singapore has 130 rapes a year, Norway has 1,000. How do you justify leaving the Norway justice system in place to the additional 800 rape victims in Norway, when a better system for reducing crime has been invented?[5] Maybe the US is stuck in middle-no-mans land that leads to bad outcomes. To address this, they could either make prisons into hotels/universities (Norway) or impose stricter penalties (Singapore). But if someone did something terrible to one of my family members, I know which system I'd prefer. [1] http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Norway/Singapore/Crime http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Norway/Sing... [2] http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Singapore/United-States/Crime http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Singapore/U... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention... [5] Of course, it's never fully accurate to measure systems by comparing numbers across different cultures/measurement systems. The main point remains though.
- Svip 9y agoPerhaps it's also a cultural difference? Notice how Japan has the same rate of homicides as Singapore? Perhaps it's a cultural thing more so than a policy thing working out in Asia. Comparing countries with corporal punishment with their intentional homicide rate leads to no conclusion. The United States have tried harsher punishments for decades now, and it's not working out. Perhaps a different method is devised? Besides, you may approve of legal corporal punishment, but I am not sure everyone in the West does.
- crucini 9y agoThis article is a fine example of IYI - "intellectual yet idiot" as Taleb terms it. Verbal cleverness + plausible statistics + apples/oranges comparison = what? Equals: "We have the answer to everything, but sadly the rulers and electorate aren't as wise/clever/compassionate as us." Others in this thread have pointed out specific fallacies in this article - for example there are prisoners in the US using chainsaws and axes; there are prisoners in Norway in solitary confinement who would be in general population in a US prison. But let's zoom up to the bigger syndrome. Notice the author quotes at least one offender, but doesn't bother talking to any corrections officers. Did it occur to him that someone who worked in a prison for 20 years might know a little bit more about corrections than someone who read a bunch of studies and statistics? Symptomatic of a broader problem - the chattering classes, who consume and generate information, are increasingly cut off from the real world, and increasingly influential. Of course it's easy to have opinions about how something "should" work when you have no experience and no skin in the game.
- ouid 9y ago20 years of individual experience does not give you nearly as much data as "a bunch of studies and statistics". Being glib about the scientific method doesn't make you better than it.
- crucini 9y agoAdam just raised seed funding to build the next great mobile app. He needs a high performance back end which will support rapid iteration. He looks at two candidates for tech lead: Bob has 20 years experience in server software development and led the back-end development at a previous mobile startup. Charlie is an econ PHD from Yale and has many statistics at his fingertips about software development. He has never written any software. Who should Adam hire?
- ouid 9y agoThese scenarios are not analogous.
- 9y ago
- renegadesensei 9y agoIs it possible to punish and rehabilitate at the same time? I ask partly because I have small kids. When they do bad things, I try to focus on educating them and not punishing. Then again, most of the bad things they do (making a mess, being too loud, etc.) are relatively benign. If they were to do something really horrible and victimize some other kid, I would probably punish them, but at the same time I would hope I could teach them never to do such a thing again. I think that's the moral dilemma with prison systems. It's easy in abstract to say that we should just focus on rehabilitation and take this utilitarian argument about what's best for society. But I know that if, for example, someone were to harm my children, I would have trouble being convinced that that person needs free college and housing (partly paid for by me). Even if that statistically led to a better outcome for society, it would not seem like justice; rather it would seem that person is being rewarded for harming my family. This I think is a general problem with utilitarianism - that when we just focus on group outcomes, we sometimes lose sight of things like individual rights and justice, messy moral concepts that don't always create optimal group results. Maybe there is some way to do both things or differentiate between types of criminals. I don't really have a solution. Just posing the conundrum.
- blazespin 9y agoThe whole point of the criminal legal system is not about individual justice. It's a crime against the state. You are thinking civil law.
- BugsJustFindMe 9y ago> The whole point of the criminal legal system is not about individual justice. It's a crime against the state. I'm sorry, that's ridiculous. You can call murder a crime against the state all you want, but I'll be damned if there isn't a very long history of inviting the family of the victim to witness state-sanctioned executions. Criminal punishment definitely incorporates individual justice.
- derefr 9y agoWhen you hear "state" for laws old enough to be common-law, think more of "community." A murderer makes random strangers in town mad on the victim's behalf, so they go kill the murderer. They aren't killing them to get justice for the victim; they're killing them because the victim was someone they knew as a member of the community and they feel pain at their loss. This pain, in aggregate, is the pain the "state" feels in response to an act, and lashes out in response to. It's the reason that terrorism is a bigger deal than plain treason: both affect the government itself in some sense, but terrorism inflicts pain on the people in aggregate, and so the people-in-aggregate, in their roles as "legislature" and "jury", seek to punish it more strongly.
- MarkMc 9y agoFrom a related Economist article [0]: "Oregon, which insists that programmes to reform felons are measured for effectiveness, has a recidivism rate less than half as high as California’s." Assuming it's not a statistical blip, I wonder why Oregon is so different to California. Seems to me that a politician who promises to reduce the recidivism rate and thereby save taxpayer dollars would get more votes. [0] http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21722642-lot-known-about-how-reform-prisoners-far-too-little-done-americas-prisons-are http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21722642-lot-known-abo...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cubano 9y agoPrisons not only make the convicts inside them worse, but from my experience and POV, it makes the people observing and interacting with them worse as well. I say this because while I seem to observe this prison-is-terrible-the-convicts-need-compassion, not one person here has offered to help me in any meaningful way, even though I have documented my trials and tribulations over and over [0][1][2]. I have a 30 year history of software development, with 14 or so with the LAMP-stack. No one reading this is willing to even talk about some side project or prove-yourself 2 week gig? Ok right I get it...this isn't a help wanted or job board fine that's cool. But still, I'm not getting it anymore...is everyone just into some sort of bullshit social signalling exercise or, perhaps worse, are willing to try to help ex-cons as long as they are funneled into low paying exploitative back-breaking jobs with no future that almost surely will lead 95% back into crime? If so, can we start being honest about that's what all this discussion is about..."boy someone should sure do something about how screwed these people are but hell no it won't be me." Yeah, so I'm frustrated and scared and broke and all that, so try to forgive my rant...I'm sure I'll come to regret it as I do so much else in my life. [0] https://postmoderncoder.svbtle.com/fear-and-jaywalking-in-las-vegas https://postmoderncoder.svbtle.com/fear-and-jaywalking-in-la... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14394324 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14394324 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14302656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14302656
- sprafa 9y agoHave you tried freelancing remote? What do you need?
- Mz 9y agoEh, they do the same thing to homeless people. (Or women.) In my experience, it helps to focus on the "I need a job" part (or other specific, constructive assistance) and not so much on the "my life is a shit show" part. I have some sites I can link you to that might be useful to you. Gig Works: http://gigworks.blogspot.com/ http://gigworks.blogspot.com/ Write Pay: http://writepay.blogspot.com/ http://writepay.blogspot.com/ San Diego Homeless Survival Guide: http://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/ http://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/ Sorry, I can't do more for you. I do sympathize, but I'm basically broke at the moment myself and I absolutely am not in some kind of position to hire anyone. I just scrape by myself every month, but I do write and try to put out useful information for people in need. Best.
- darpa_escapee 9y agoIt should be well known that the public, and often the judicial system, see prison as punishment and not rehabilitation. Another portion sees at as constitutionally-granted slave labor or an opportunity for profit.
- chrshawkes 9y agoSo what is the solution keep criminals in society?
- ygaf 9y agoOne takeaway from the article (if nothing else) was to give them responsibility. I like that. Demanding something from prisoners is more likely to change them than punishment and waiting.
- jorgec 9y agoA bullet is cheaper.
- jlebrech 9y agoMaybe some convicts need exile not incarceration. And petty criminals need to be reeducated.