4 ms·
Interesting idea, but even if there were a protectable right to attention, how would we accommodate differences in distractability? That is, some people are ver
by gnicholas 9y ago
Interesting idea, but even if there were a protectable right to attention, how would we accommodate differences in distractability? That is, some people are very easily distracted by banner ads, and other people do not find them troublesome (though their behavior may still be influenced by having seen ads they did not focus on).
In the American legal system, we have a concept known as the "eggshell plaintiff rule", which addresses heterogeneity among tort victims (i.e., victims of car accidents or other negligent acts) This rule says that if you injure someone and it turns out that they have some peculiar bodily weakness (like a skull as thin as an eggshell, hence the name), you are responsible for whatever injuries result. It doesn't matter that the magnitude of the injuries was totally unforeseeable.
Although this rule offers one way to handle heterogeneity among people, it only kicks in after a recognizable tort has occurred. In the case of attentional heterogeneity, the threshold question of what type of distraction is too distracting is at issue. So it seems like it would be very difficult to figure out a workable standard here.
That said, I'm very interested in the topic, and actually recently released a new feature in my Chrome extension [1] that visually dims distracting elements on the page. I do hope that we can find a way to cut down on distractions — I'm just not sure a new legal right is the most likely path.
1: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/beeline-reader/ifjafammaookpiajfbedmacfldaiamgg/ https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/beeline-reader/ifj...
- anigbrowl 9y agoExcellent arguments, and an interesting extension too. I already use a CSS customizer to clean up the pages I visit most frequently but I'll give this a try as an alternative. My very first impression was that I'd rather have the color text as an available option rather than the default; I've got so much effort invested in navigating blocks of text over the years that this feels like driving over rumble strips. But it's easy to adjust and I appreciate the depth to which you've thought into this problem.
- gnicholas 9y agoThanks for the feedback! You can turn off autocolor, which will flip the default as you suggest. But you might find that after reading with it for a little while, your eyes/brain acclimate to it.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThat's a question I think the article is particularly useful for in that it suggests a model: Privilege, Power, Claim, and Immunity. Within these concepts, I see the emergence of both legal and technical means to address the matter. The concepts of product liability and mitigations, generally addressed through an insurance, that is, risk-pricing system, which moves otherwise uncertain and frequently avoided costs, to the fore, putting a tangible and current price on them, is another model.
- gnicholas 9y agoInteresting — I didn't find the framework to be helpful in this regard. That is, the key question (how to handle differences in distractibility) lives on in the Claim section: A duty on others not to interfere with or hijack your attention, and your capacity to pay attention This will mean very different things for different people. How does the framework handle this?
- dredmorbius 9y agoI'm not settled on whether the model is or isn't useful. But it's one to consider. There's also the point that you can make a ton of advance without considering the extreme edge cases. Or look at other elements of tort, interference, or harm law and see how that's evolved over time.