4 ms·
It's a lot of money but keep in mind that everyone is getting some portion of it back again. You need to look at the net amount, which (assuming it's funded by
by skybrian 9y ago
It's a lot of money but keep in mind that everyone is getting some portion of it back again. You need to look at the net amount, which (assuming it's funded by a progressive income tax) will depend on income. Another question would be whether it's on top of social security or (more reasonably) social security is lowered so there is no net change.
So the questions to ask are: (1) at what income do you break even? And (2) at what income does the tax increase become significant? It will depend on the details.
- dyarosla 9y agoI already consider this. Math still doesnt add up
- bryanlarsen 9y agoHere's a spreadsheet with the math. Bottom right column is the net cost. Input is two numbers: incremental tax rate R and tax threshold T. Your net UBI is (I-T)*R. Let's tweak the spreadsheet to get a payment of $12K per household if income is 0. One way to get that is T=30K and R=20%. (The average size of a low-income household is ~2) With those two numbers, the net cost is approximately 0. But the whole point of UBI is that it can replace welfare, so if you can find $1T in savings, UBI can work with T=60K and R=10%. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1plUkyt9PuZ_WaLC_BaHgZQ6ekM7DRIOhV6CFudb75g8/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1plUkyt9PuZ_WaLC_BaHg...
- dyarosla 9y agoThank you!