6 ms·
After Misjudging Market, Bike Maker Vanhawks (YC W16) Has Been Resurrected
- hinkley 9y agoPurchasing a bike is a very tactile experience. How does it feel when you're on it? Anyone whose ever was a bike aficionado should know that. The only people I know who bought one and had it shipped (e.g., Davidson, Serotta, Rodriguez) still went to see one first. How do you know enough about bikes to build one out of carbon fiber but don't get that?
- wmeredith 9y agoYou could say the same thing about shoes (Zappos) or mattresses (Casper). I think you're conflating your preferences with those of the entire market.
- hinkley 9y agoYou know we're talking about a company that already failed with a mail order only business model, right? I buy shoes online when I've already seen them. But have you ever owned a high end bike? The experience is a lot different for buying shoes (although if I were in the habit of buying $2000 shoes I might feel differently). You don't usually buy another one, unless you broke the last one. You buy something new, or different.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoWhen I buy shoes on Zappos, I am trusting an existing brand that I've worn before (I wear the Nike Pegasus running shoes; the 33 model is basically the same as the 31s that I have on my shelf) and I'm happy to buy them from Zappos instead of a retailer. I'd buy bike components online at Nashbar or Performance because I know what I'm getting from Fuji or Shimano. And Nashbar has slowly inserted themselves into that trusted space as well. But Vanhawks? I don't trust that yet.
- hinkley 9y agoIf I'm being completely honest I think this depends a bit on disposable income. The guy I knew who bought a Davidson way, way back, knew a guy who let him borrow one. He had a family and coughing up that much money took some thinking. The confirmed bachelor with many bikes, on the other hand, would try to do his homework but ended up with several he didn't like. He'd just resell them and try again. But biking was his thing. I think his bikes were worth more than his furniture.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoIf your bikes are not worth more than your furniture, you either have too few bikes or your furniture is too expensive.
- hinkley 9y agoI think if you sat down and added up the cost of all of your furniture, you'd be shocked at the total.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Fomite 9y agoIn fairness, when I order from Zappos I order like six pairs and return five of them. Will Vanhawks be down with me doing that with bikes?
- davidvanhawks 9y agoDavid from Vanhawks here - great question. As a long time cyclist myself, I would never want to buy a bike that I didn't get a chance to throw a leg over first - we are completely aware of this and, we will be working with a retail partner in the near future to offer this option. It was important for us to create and refine the product while we found the right partner. In the coming weeks, we'll be starting a purchase program that allows both online and in-shop purchasing in select locations.
- no_flags 9y agoI think the bike market is already in the process of being disrupted by online sales. Many shops are struggling or have already closed. There are several successful online-only brands in the mountain bike world such as Commencal, YT, and Canyon. One difference I see between those companies and Vanhawks is that they clearly offer the best value in their market segment (in terms of price). The Vanhawks bike is not directly comparable to other bikes out there, so it's hard to know if it's a good deal or not. I also wonder how many commuters will want to spend $2k on a bike. The mountain bike brands I mentioned are all aimed at enthusiasts and are able to leverage professional sponsorships and mountain bike specific media outlets to validate their product in the eyes of potential customers.
- Finnucane 9y agoI spent $1400 on mine a few years back. A nice touring bike that is also good for commuting. And on top of that, I've added a dynamo hub, lights, reflective paint, switched out the fenders (twice), and other customizations. But then, I put more miles on the bike than I do on our car, so it's totally worth it for me. On the other hand, I'd never buy this Vanhawk unless I could be certain, for instance, that the electronics would withstand New England winters (I can tell you that ordinary cycle computers do not!). I gave up replacing them because what they tell you is not needed for commuting. I know the route, I know how long it takes, I do it every day. Also, there doesn't seem to be bosses for racks or water bottle holders, which I consider pretty essential.
- Naritai 9y agoI like how the first 2 comments here say that: 1) online sales are destroying in-person bike retail 2) in-person bike retail can never be replaced by online sales.
- jseliger 9y agoYeah. I would guess that over time, bike shops will morph into a) repair shops and b) showrooms that might, for example, get $x from each company for each test ride on one of their bikes (or something along those lines). A person who chooses to buy the bike would then get it shipped to the shop and built; eliminating inventory should also eliminate a lot of cost. As for Vanhawks specifically, I think they have a very cool idea but their bikes are just a little too expensive for me. Which is actually pretty frustrating. I'd like one of their single-speed bikes, but the bike is $1300. Then shipping is $150. Then assembly is ~$50 – $100. Then a rack and fenders are more. Something like a Priority bike is $900: https://www.prioritybicycles.com/products/thecontinuum https://www.prioritybicycles.com/products/thecontinuum and the company often offers free shipping. Fenders and a variable-speed transmission are included. Total cost is a lot lower.
- no_flags 9y agoI didn't mean to imply that I think retail bike shops will completely disappear. I was more trying to make the point that there are already a few successful online-only bike brands. So maybe Vanhawks' issue is their product, not the online sales model.
- underdown 9y agoI think they are still misjudging the market. Im a cyclist - ride about 3k miles per year. I know very little about this bike, however why do I need a connected bike? I have a computer that I can attach to any bike I like. Hell, a smart phone on a mount can be swapped between bikes. Plus, frames break. I would rather have a modular bike that I can swap the pieces I want between. Maybe its just bad copy, but I already have a connected bike - everyone I ride with does. The only features i see that I might not have are blindspot detection (which i can get with a cheap mirror on my helmet if i wanted it), and a carbon fiber belt instead of a chain, which means none of my existing components which I've paid thousands of dollars for will work. The fixie is a little more compelling, but the price point is a little steep.
- kleinsch 9y ago100% agree. I've swapped bike computers 5-6x over the last 5 years. First road bike I ever bought is still compatible with all of them. Presumably the investors saw something I'm missing, but I think the price point ($1300) is really high for a fully integrated system.
- hkmurakami 9y agoI'm in the same market segment as you (i do triathlons). This bike is not meant for the athlete /performance cyclist. It looks like it's trying to target the person who only riders a bike to commute, or perhaps go for a leisurely stroll down a beach boulevard. Which IMO is a fine choice, if they really do know that this segment even wants the product they're making, or if this segment is big enough.
- throwaway51949 9y agoI'm in a different market segment (as far as you can get from athlete/performance cyclist), but also think they're misjudging the market. I bike almost every day for commuting, grocery shopping, and visiting friends. Also occasionally longer overnight trips for fun. I can't understand why anyone needs the features of this bike, and even if they did, how does this $1000+ bike provide those features better than adding a few accessories to any bike of your choice? I found that in real life, I noticed no difference with most of the features that command a premium. When commuting, I'm carrying a laptop, charger, and usually lunch. When riding for fun, I'm usually carrying plenty of water, food, and maybe a tent and sleeping bag. So why would I pay hundreds of dollars to save pounds on my bike with a carbon frame? I do spend plenty on accessories, but they're in the opposite direction than what this bike offers. I bought as nice of a saddle as I could find, with no thought towards price. Same with comfortable hand grips. And a really expensive pannier that converts into a backpack - which is probably my best purchase. Following that high publicity jeep hack, and I'm sure plenty of other car hacks that have followed, I personally consider it a feature that my bike is purely mechanical. This bike falls somewhere between "social network for dogs" and "smart refrigerator with livestream of your egg carton" in terms of why would I want this? For half the price of this bike I got a 1500W mid-drive ebike conversion kit that I added to a $150 BMX bike which is ridiculously fun, with a programming cable allows for more than enough tinkering for my tastes. It's in a completely different class than a human powered bicycle for sure, but IMO many casual bicyclists would be well served owning a cheap e-bike and a cheap bicycle.
- danielhooper 9y ago"a $1,500 USD bike that can be connected to smartphones via bluetooth and track rider statistics, such as route and speed, in real-time." So it's a bike with built in GPS? That connects to my phone, which also has GPS? What the heck. What am I missing that makes this product not such an obviously dumb idea? What can this do that I can't accomplish with a mobile app, or with a smart watch strapped to the handlebars?
- quadrature 9y agotake a look at the site https://www.vanhawks.com/ https://www.vanhawks.com/. It works exactly as you described with a phone app and it also has some hardware to integrate turn by turn directions.
- Finnucane 9y agoThat doesn't really answer the 'why does it need to be built into the bike' question.
- davidvanhawks 9y agoIn the short term, having this platform built in to a bike allows us to offer the turn by turn navigation with less distraction and much more robust data collection. That data collection will be used to improve the navigation based on real world feed back in the future. In the long term, building this platform into a full bike means that we can offer plenty more - imagine being able to locate your bike if it was stolen or, imagine your bike could communicate with other vehicles around you to keep the rider safe. This is not to say that we only offer full bikes in the future. However, having the full bike now is allowing us to perfect the platform and understand the full range of needs for our riders.
- Finnucane 9y agoStill doesn't answer the question. What does it do that some other solution does not already do? I'm certainly not your target market, myself, since I know my way around the place I live and I am old enough to know how to find stuff on a map. If I happen to find myself someplace less familiar--I do sometimes go for long rides not knowing where I am going until I get there--Google/Apple maps are available at the touch of a button. If you are offering bike location--how long before thieves/hackers figure out how to disable it? Will it work when the bike has no power? Will thieves be able to use the tracking signal to find expensive bikes to steal?
- bch 9y ago> “gearing up for 2017.” It's too late for that. 2017 bookings were completed last fall.
- schwarrrtz 9y agoThe article is dated Oct 18th.
- scblock 9y agoI doubt they ran into trouble because of their planned sales model. Fundamentally this is not a product I would expect to be commercially successful. All these weird trends like Kickstarters for "Connected bikes" and Bluetooth "smart locks" are not actually very useful to cyclists. Real improvements to cycling will come from investments in infrastructure, not by throwing technology at bicycles themselves.
- pg_is_a_butt 9y agothe phone it is required to connect to can already measure speed and location on a map. this product is dumb.
- davidvanhawks 9y agoDavid from Vanhawks here - couldn't agree more. That's why our vision isn't just to 'throw technology at bicycles.' What the Valour does allow is for rich data collection so that we can help shape more useful changes in the future.
- overcast 9y agoAnytime someone from a company comes on here using buzzword nonsense, you know it's not going to end well. You're talking to the wrong group of people with that middle manager marketing speak.
- rfdub 9y agoMisjudged is an understatement. There is no appetite for these over-priced "Connected" bikes. They are essentially taking a $1000 Chinese carbon bike and selling it for $1500 with the extra cost attributed to an integrated, non-upgradeable computer and some sensors, all of which can already be found in any given customer's existing smartphone, which can easily be mounted onto whatever bike the customer wants. I don't get why anyone would take a bicycle, something that has a useful lifespan of potentially decades and integrate it with technology that will become obsolete in less than a couple of years. Just because you can put a computer and sensors in something doesn't mean you should or that anyone will pay for it.
- gnopgnip 9y agoThe same is true for juicero, internet connected refrigerators, and almost everything else connected to the internet. Plenty of people will pay more for things because they are internet connected
- aqme28 9y agoI dont think you want Juicero to be your example of a successful IoT startup.
- trhway 9y ago>They are essentially taking a $1000 Chinese carbon bike and selling it for $1500 with the extra cost attributed to an integrated, non-upgradeable computer and some sensors, all of which can already be found in any given customer's existing smartphone, which can easily be mounted onto whatever bike the customer wants. i wonder how such logic would sound in the context of say Microsoft Surface Hub?! well, probably like billion dollar idea :) They sell those $5K TV for $22K like hot cakes. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/12/microsofts-surface-hub-sales-surprisingly-strong-its-a-huge-hardware-hit/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/12/micro...