7 ms·
> ...and maybe thousands of unsung GRU agents, relentlessly stealing Western military tech. :) That's kinda really insulting to a lot of excellent engineers an
by izacus 9y ago
> ...and maybe thousands of unsung GRU agents, relentlessly stealing Western military tech. :)
That's kinda really insulting to a lot of excellent engineers and scientist that worked on technology in USSR.
Isn't Cold War far enough behind that we can slowly stop with the western propaganda and deliberate attempts to downplay all eastern achievements?
- nek28 9y agoWhich is not really an argument as to the veracity of what he said.
- izacus 9y agoNeither does it confirm it (or give a source). I mean yes, technology was "stolen" all the time - from BOTH sides. F-117 stealth technology is based on research done in USSR. In 80ties, the US people happily took a ride in the first MiG-29s delivered to us in the 1980s and "stole" technology from there. And yet, we don't go running around claiming that all USA flight technology achievements are based on CIA agents stealing tech and thus diminishing everything people Lockheed etc. did. If you actually look at declassified primary sources you'll see that a huge amount of effort went into eastern designs as well and the impact of "stolen" technology is actually rather limited due to the differences in approaches of R&D teams.
- dimitar 9y agoThere a lot of sources for the GRU stealing military technology. That they were in the Manhattan project is very well known. Enjoy this chapter from a book on the subject of GRU: http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov8/04.html http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov8/04.html
- izacus 9y agoYes (which is what I said), did you also read the rest of my post. For example for your Manhattan project thing is the classic example of how misleading such simplified outlook on the world can be. GRU stole the information about US atomic bomb, but then the info wasn't really used (because it wasn't trusted) and the USSR bombs ended up being developed independently. See this post for more: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/21zc0v/how_did_the_soviet_union_manage_to_acquire_atomic/cgib6am/?st=j35macia&sh=d82d250d https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/21zc0v/how_d... This is actually a rather common occurence - even in things like USSR copying the US bomber design it showed that the technology and approaches to it were suffciently different that stolen plans weren't really that useful for plain copying. They did provide invaluable direction for R&D of course. Let me be clear - I'm not even remotely claiming that USSR didn't attempt to copy technology or attempt to benefit it. I'm just a bit annoyed at the amount of Americans that reflexively try to erase contributions and hard work of a lot of USSR's engineers and scientists with this naive and simple dismissal. I understand that it's driven by what's effectively 50 years of propagands (from both sides!), but in 2017 we should do better. We have declassified sources now.
- mmjaa 9y agoAmerican supremacy depends on American hubris. Without one you can't have the other.
- PerfectDlite 9y ago> F-117 stealth technology is based on research done in USSR That's like saying that all Soviet technology is based on research done in UK and France. You know: Newton, Lavoisier, Pascal, Boyle, Joule... > happily took a ride in the first MiG-29s delivered to us in the 1980s and "stole" technology from there Take a ride == stole technology? Are you serious?
- dimitar 9y agoWell, it is true. The Soviet Union leadership in the highest levels believed that reverse-engineering existing technology is better than recreating it. Obviously, the USSR wasn't going to pay licensing and patent fees to the capitalist West, right? If this is insulting, blame the Politburo and the Central Military Commission. In fact, not reinventing the wheel allowed for the great scientific and engineering achievements that the Soviet Union did have.
- izacus 9y agoWould you mind providing independent sources for that? :)
- vetinari 9y agoOf course, that's why Soviets did put the first man into the space, they did the Venus exploration or they had the first orbital station. Must be due to GRU spying. /s
- PerfectDlite 9y agoFor stealing Western tech? Look at glorious Soviet cars, for example. Now look at glorious Soviet massframe computers.
- stickfigure 9y agoThat espionage was a major factor in the soviet bomb program seems uncontroversial. Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_atomic_bomb_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_atomic_bomb_project Richard Rhodes is probably the definitive source for this history in The Making Of The Atomic Bomb and Dark Sun. Both excellent reads. I don't say this to discount the abilities of the Soviet scientists working on the problem; it's an incredible achievement even with the extra "stolen" knowledge. But keep in mind that the US pursued four totally separate technologies for uranium separation and built massively expensive plants for each because they didn't know which was going to work out. The Soviets benefitted by avoiding a lot of very expensive and time-consuming dead ends.
- 9y ago
- PerfectDlite 9y ago> a lot of excellent engineers and scientist that worked on technology in USSR. Name me THREE scientific achievements "made in USSR" which ordinary people still use in their daily lives. No, AK machine gun will not do. And sputnik is no go as well - nobody listens to radio beeps nowadays. Can you? Just three of them? Surely, 70 years of scientific achievements will do wonders, right?
- gm-conspiracy 9y agoSoft contact lenses? Synthetic diamonds? That's two off the top of my head.
- PerfectDlite 9y agoSoft contact lenses were invented by Czech scientists. Synthetic diamonds were created by French chemist in 19th century.
- avmich 9y agoAnd of course Russians perfected rocket technology way in XIX century, using solid rockets as a weapon. What are you trying to prove? That inventions aren't done in vacuum and everybody stands on the shoulders of giants coming before him? Or you literally believe that USA had a half century Cold War with opponent who can't invent a thing?
- PerfectDlite 9y ago> And of course Russians perfected rocket technology way in XIX century, using solid rockets as a weapon. Russians? Not Chinese or British or Americans, but Russians? I'm amazed on number of Russian myths here.
- Robotbeat 9y agoYet another lame comment. GPS launched on Atlas V nowadays, which uses the insanely good LOx-rich combustion Soviet engine tech. Until the fall of the Iron Curtain, American engineers believed such technology was basically impossible. It was Soviet metallurgy that made it possible. Everyone's smartphone listens to radio beeps to geolocate.
- superlopuh 9y agoThat's kinda really insulting to a lot of really talented spies that risked their lives in the States :)