5 ms·
> If you are hiring and then firing junior people fast, you are the problem. I'm going to challenge this point of view. It is absolutely, and obviously, expect
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
> If you are hiring and then firing junior people fast, you are the problem.
I'm going to challenge this point of view. It is absolutely, and obviously, expected that junior people have a ton to learn, and they should be given leeway for that learning process. So yes, if you fire a junior person because you're not willing to put in the mentorship necessary, then I agree, you are the problem.
However, junior people really shouldn't have any problem with motivation and drive, and in those cases where I've had to fire people, I've always wished I had done it sooner. More importantly, their peers wished I had fired them sooner, too. A bad or lax attitude can be an absolute killer for team morale if the person in question isn't dealt with quickly and fairly.
- ewjordan 9y agoYou're pointing out an important difference: firing because of experience/performance vs firing because of behavior. Being a bit naive, making mistakes, and needing ramp-up time is to be expected, especially from a junior hire. You absolutely need to give time to correct that sort of thing, and firing fast is not a good move. Some of the best devs I've worked with needed a few months to ramp upbefore they hit full stride. On the other hand if someone is dicking around instead of working, being insubordinate, refusing to try to improve, upsetting coworkers, etc., then you've got behavioral problems on your hands. And those are absolutely good reasons to fire if they persist beyond an initial stern warning.
- tajen 9y agoI just want you to know that I'm a beginner in management (having hired two juniors for my startup), and I'll use this advice (The junior is not productive, but him being reasonably motivated is the reason why I'll keep him).
- noxToken 9y agoConversely, ramp-up time should not be infinite. A junior employee should not be limping along after a year at the company. Either that person just isn't a fit, or there is something terribly wrong at your company.
- j2bax 9y agoAs a step before firing for a junior employee that shows any sign of promise, a 3-6 month performance improvement plan with regular check-ins and measurable progress points could make a world of difference. I currently have multiple juniors on PIP's and they are taking them very seriously and improving less than acceptable behaviors.
- dwaltrip 9y agoAs always, balance is key. Heuristics and rules of thumb are incomplete by definition, and a deep understanding of these dynamics is incredibly difficult to acquire :)
- hluska 9y agoI'm somewhat playing devil's advocate here, but how is your startup's documentation? Sometimes juniors have a hell of a lot of trouble admitting that they don't understand something. Consequently, they won't be productive because they not only don't understand what they're doing, but they don't want to demonstrate their ignorance. If I were in your shoes, I would do a couple of things: 1.) Make improving documentation a big part of their improvement plan. 2.) Make it very clear that you value clarity above all else and actively encourage them to tell you they don't understand something.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nashashmi 9y agoMy first job as an intern, I was afraid and shy and just complete garbage, but the people I worked with were strict yet forgiving. My second internship, I had no clue what I was doing, and probably did not deserve to stay there, but my boss/mentor was a jerk (something I realized later on) and I was fired/laid off. That termination taught me a lesson to: * Only bite what I can chew. * If I am not confident in doing the job, I should not take it. *If I can chew very little, then I focus on expanding to take on more. True Entrepreneurial Spirit followed.
- crpatino 9y agoThe keyword here is that GP never said "if you do fire junior people", but "if you are firing junior people". The later implies a recurrent pattern of behavior and, unless you want to argue that an unknown factor beyond your control has been sending a disproportionate amount of bad apples your way, it is ultimately your problem. Most common causes I can think for this problem are: an indiscriminate hiring process that fails to keep out poor candidates, either defective operations or hostile work environment that results in excesive burn out rates for employees, irrational expectations from management teams (specially founders who struggle to make the transition to later stage startups).
- wtvanhest 9y agoThis is exactly my point. Thanks for the clarification.
- BeetleB 9y ago>However, junior people really shouldn't have any problem with motivation and drive How are you going to determine if that really was the problem? Every time I've heard a colleague say something like this, (s)he is just utilizing a model in his/her mind to explain the behavior, and pretty much never attempts to validate/falsify. Pretty much always post hoc justifications.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoIt's really not that hard. When I have multiple peers of the person coming to me saying that someone is not putting in effort, and they aren't dependable, and they don't follow through, that's a pretty clear signal.
- BeetleB 9y ago>they aren't dependable, and they don't follow through These are all fine and measurable. Jumping from those to "lack of motivation and drive" is a leap.