5 ms·
Wait, you mean everyone cheats? I'm shocked I tell you, shocked! When the VW story first broke and I learned you could readily control the trade-off between pe
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Wait, you mean everyone cheats? I'm shocked I tell you, shocked!
When the VW story first broke and I learned you could readily control the trade-off between performance and emissions using software in the engine controller of a diesel engine, I knew that everyone would do that. They would rationalize it in what ever way they could "Oh the stomping on the accelerator indicates an emergency so we go with maximum performance rather than emission compliance, it's to save lives don't cha know?"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- r00fus 9y agoThe problem with "everyone cheats" is that we don't have proof of that. We're seeing proof that multiple companies have cheated so far... hopefully the punishments are equivalent.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- iamthepieman 9y agothey are all cheating and the punishments won't be equivalent (I assume you mean to the amount of damages and money they made during the cheating period on the cheating vehicles) But you're right, we don't have proof right now. I think the logical proof, that other companies are selling similar vehicles at similar price points that are "passing" the emissions testing is proof but obviously not of the legal variety.
- thinkling 9y agoOnce you have the necessary portable emissions testing equipment, how much work is it to test a vehicle? I've been wondering why the researchers at WVU who found the VW cheating have not gone on to test a larger set of vehicles to see who else is cheating.
- jessaustin 9y agoDo we know the researchers haven't tested other vehicles? If VW were cheating to a greater degree than other manufacturers, that might explain why they were the first to be caught.
- thinkling 9y agoYes, they weren't doing this on their own initiative, they had a contract to test 4 specific vehicles of which 3 were VW TDIs, I think. They didn't initially think they'd found cheating, and it took a year or two for CARB to get interested and things to develop. You'd think someone would fund broader testing...
- ProAm 9y ago"If you're not cheating, you're not trying" and it's easier to ask for forgiveness and to pay the fine after the fact.
- zzleeper 9y agoWell, on the one hand you have emission restrictions and on the other hand you have MPG restrictions. Then you have consumers that want to buy SUVs, so there is no way you are going to meet your quota of zero-emission-vehicles. I'm not taking the blame out of carmakers, but it is very easy to end up with regulations that when taken together are not feasible. Imaginary example: you need a capital/asset ratio of at least 20% (which means capital/liab. of at least that, by definition). But you also require at least 30% of the liabilities to be long-term debt. Another regulation says that 50% of loans must be financed with deposits, and so on. The end effect is that there is little margin for these banks to decide on their liabilities. At the extreme, if we impose unfeasible restrictions, they might just end up skirting some of the rules.
- LordKano 9y agoThen you have consumers that want to buy SUVs, so there is no way you are going to meet your quota of zero-emission-vehicles. It was the emissions restrictions that pushed so many consumers to SUVs in the first place.
- iamthepieman 9y agoI'm not saying that's not true but in my case, it was the need for an 8 passenger vehicle that was not a minivan. It was either a SUV or a commercial commuter van.
- danans 9y agoI'm curious why not a minivan? What does the commercial commuter van offer in terms of functionality that the minivan doesn't?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoShow me a minivan with two rows of benches. AFAIK they all have captains chairs in the first two rows now. If you want two bench seats in the 21st century your options are basically all SUVs
- jcoby 9y ago> Oh the stomping on the accelerator indicates an emergency so we go with maximum performance rather than emission compliance FWIW, that's common on gas engines so there is some precedent. It's called power enrichment and can be adjusted in GM computers. When it kicks in depends on the car/truck it's installed in. But it uses a combination of manifold pressure and throttle position and rpm to decide whether or not to command extra fuel. You can see the params HP Tuners uses to configure the PE circuit here: https://www.hptuners.com/help/vcm_editor_parameters_gm_eng_fuel_pe.htm https://www.hptuners.com/help/vcm_editor_parameters_gm_eng_f...
- rosbrith 9y agoThis replicates the functioning of a carburettor equipped with a mechanical accelerator pump. It squirts some extra fuel into the manifold when the throttle pedal is depressed, the quantity determined by the force applied to the pedal.
- jcoby 9y agoWhat you're describing is called accelerator enrichment and does mirrror the accel pump in a carb. https://www.hptuners.com/help/vcm_editor_parameters_gm_eng_fuel_ae.htm https://www.hptuners.com/help/vcm_editor_parameters_gm_eng_f... Power enrichment is a different function and commands a new afr for peak power (generally around 12.5:1) instead of trying to maintain around stoich.
- phkahler 9y ago... and I learned you could readily control the trade-off between performance and emissions using software in the engine controller... That is THE tradeoff everyone contends with. The regulations on emissions and fuel economy are directly at odds with each other. The things you do to get more efficient often result in incomplete combustion - strange as that sounds.
- subnaught 9y agoThis is fascinating and, like you say, counter-intuitive. Can you expand on this or provide some links?
- phkahler 9y agoAs someone else pointed out, it's not "incomplete combustion" it's production of NOx which is a pollutant. Running really lean also results in a bit of incomplete combustion though.
- problems 9y agoThat definitely sounds wrong - if you're leaving unburnt fuel in your exhaust, that is wasted fuel, you could burn it further and get more energy out of it - they seem exactly in line with eachother as goals. Do you have any source for that statement?
- jpapon 9y agoIt's not that there is unburnt fuel in your exhaust - unburnt fuel, while a pollutant, is not the problem. The issue is that higher temperature combustion, while more efficient, produces much more NOx. So you get more energy per unit fuel at higher temperatures, but you also get more pollutants. Lower temperatures (less oxygen) result in "cleaner" combustion (essentially, more CO2 and N2, less NO and NO2), but produce much less energy per unit fuel.
- labster 9y agoThis is only true in some regions. The creation of Ozone in the troposphere is dependent on availability of NOx, and availablity of hydrocarbons. In the southeast US, forests produce large amounts of volatile hydrocarbons, so the system is NOx-limited. In California's Central Valley, excess NOx from nitrogen fertilizers makes ozone production hydrocarbon-limited (and also basic rain from the NH3). So from a pollution management standpoint, either could be important, but usually only one.
- izend 9y agoWhat I find ironic is the Diesel emission cheating has allowed NOx pollution to skyrocket in Europe which causes terrible localized air pollution but lowers their CO2 emissions (vs using Gasoline engines) and lowers their crude oil import needs. So companies that promote Diesel Engines can claim to be lowering CO2 emissions at the cost of very polluting NOx emissions.
- usrusr 9y agoThis is the key for understanding how those involved in implementation could do it without feeling terribly guilty: instead of "shit, my boss is ordering me to poison the air" they could look at it in the much more cheerful way of "yay, together we can get our planet-saving CO2 reduction features past those annoying regulations that make it so hard for us". If there are two ways to tell a story, people invariably choose the one that puts them in a better light. Inner discourse is no exception.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoIronic? I think you mean tragic. NOx emissions from diesel vehicles cause tens of thousands of deaths a year.
- kbenson 9y agoHave variable performance and emissions is not the problem. The EPA testing should (does?) test multiple types of usage and use an amalgamation of the results for an overall score. The problem isn't that they are changing how they perform depending on circumstance, it's that they've defined a circumstance specifically for "we're being tested" and change how it functions based on that, which means the test no longer has any bearing on reality. That's the difference between a good feature and a defeat device.
- megablast 9y agoCar companies are some of the worst companies in the world, have done immeasurable damage to the world, and have cost us all so much.
- tstegart 9y agoI think that's the point though, to give power when you need power, and fuel efficiency when you don't. So everyone does do it, because its a good thing. I think you're making a mistake about what crime they're accused of. The tradeoff between efficiency and power is ok, but what they did is have software that detected when an emission test was being run and created a fake engine profile that only made fuel efficient tradeoffs, and when the emission test stopped the engine went back to the regular tradeoffs. That was their crime. They hid what settings they were really picking and specifically wrote software to defeat an emissions test.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago> That was their crime. They hid what settings they > were really picking and specifically wrote software > to defeat an emissions test. I actually agree with you on this. That said, I've heard people defend VW and presumably would GM as well with "The law says you must have this level of emissions when your car is tested. And that is exactly what they did, they made sure the car followed the law and emitted what was required of it to emit during the test." It completely side steps the intention of course, and I would certainly not sanction it as an excuse, but it nicely illustrates how sophistry and regulation are an odd match.
- _pmf_ 9y ago> but it nicely illustrates how sophistry and regulation are an odd match Except for the tiny detail that the law explicitly forbids using special emission control modes during stationary test bench usage. At least in the VW case, it was not a relaxed interpretation of the rules.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoYup. It doesn't even require excessive malfeasance. Once you are in the zone of just slightly gaming the system at the edges and then you make the jump to deciding to build that gaming the system into the software you're screwed. Because the problem is that once you start down that path it is actually shockingly easy to create wildly divergent performance and emissions characteristics. Such is the power of software control of an engine. And then you are faced with the problem of what to do next, do you pull it back or do you go for broke to maximize quarterly profits while assuming regulatory agencies won't find out? You can guess which option our current business environment has preferentially selected for.