4 ms·
From the article: "I want a future where someone can go to a junkyard and yank a motor from a Tesla Model H (you know, the one with the T-top) and plan to pop i
by squarefoot 9y ago
From the article: "I want a future where someone can go to a junkyard and yank a motor from a Tesla Model H (you know, the one with the T-top) and plan to pop it into their Reatta EV knowing that the connections will fit. "
Good luck with that, and it has nothing to do with safety since even safety can be standardized: there are no chances one can stick a HP cartridge into an Epson printer; cars are no different.
The tap based economics we live in is based exactly on the opposite: find a potential source of revenue, then once you have got/patented/bought it, close it behind a faucet and start asking money to open it. Openness would destroy that practice, and the legal system in every "western" country fights to enforce this exact behaviour.
Also, being called a communist after decades of well crafted negative propaganda doesn't help.
- Animats 9y ago"I want a future where someone can go to a junkyard and yank a motor from a Tesla Model H (you know, the one with the T-top) and plan to pop it into their Reatta EV knowing that the connections will fit." There's no market for that capability in cars. Some heavy trucks do have it; you can buy some heavy trucks and put in a Cummins or Caterpillar Diesel engine. But for smaller cars, it's not worth the headaches. Powertrain switches are not impossible. A routine student exercise in serious automotive schools is to put an engine and transmission from one car into another car, making the necessary parts. Stanford and Renovo put an electric powertrain into a DeLorean and made it capable of autonomous drifting.[1] Even in PCs, there's no market for that. 80% of desktop PCs are never opened during their operating life, and the fraction for laptops is probably lower. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WNIDcT0Zdj4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WNIDcT0Zdj4
- LeifCarrotson 9y ago> there are no chances one can stick a HP cartridge into an Epson printer This is true, but printers are among the most poorly standardized items of PC hardware. There is a very good chance that you can remove a motherboard, processor, RAM stick, hard drive, graphics card, power supply, fan, or case from one computer manufacturer and use it with another. And while I agree that our economic system isn't helping in several ways, IBM PC standardization happened much closer in time to the red scare than anything EV related.
- devoply 9y agoYeah this sort of thing has much to do with a chosen paradigm than some blatant truth. If you instead changed the system to force manufacturers to play this game then they would do it and the system would still function. It would simply be a different set of economic moves. And there would be a lot less trash and probably the prices for many things would drop as well... and the system would become more efficient and that's exactly what shareholders don't want.