3 ms·
It is undeniably true that HR departments exist for the benefit of the company, not its employees, but I've never quite understood why that leads to the bad out
by vec 9y ago
It is undeniably true that HR departments exist for the benefit of the company, not its employees, but I've never quite understood why that leads to the bad outcomes it does.
If an employee complains to HR of harassment, it seems like the most coldly rational, protect-the-company reaction they could have would be to do everything in their power to prevent the complaint from going public and creating a PR nightmare. Taking the complaint seriously is in their power, usually make the complainant go away peacefully, and makes you the "good guy" in the court of public opinion if it comes to that.
Furthermore, given a situation where one of your staff is abusing their position in any way, I would think most companies would rather find that out from their HR department than from the local newspaper or the district attorney.
So why isn't that the default strategy for HR departments? I understand that not every HR director is necessarily competent, and that large enough power discrepancies can overcome a lot of good intentions, but it seems like best-practice HR procedure is to essentially sweep problems under the rug and hope they go away instead of making an effort to honestly address them. That can't possibly be a good long-term strategy, can it?
- GVIrish 9y agoA lot of the reason HR departments behave the way they do, is because of who they report to. The people in the C-suite set the tone and if they create a culture of sweeping things under the rug or otherwise excusing bad behavior, HR will do that too. The other thing is that people bring their bias with them and an organization's culture can make it worse. If someone is a bit biased against victims of harassment, in HR they'll tend to side with the harasser. If the culture of the company already tends towards hostile/indifferent/unsupportive, it only makes HR's behavior worse.
- jpttsn 9y agoEstimate the cost of the PR nightmare. Estimate the risk of this complaint causing the PR nightmare. Estimate how many points HR can decrease this risk. Maybe HR is still the best ROI, but I think the equation could go either way.