4 ms·
> For example to distinguish a religion from a cult, you don't study the bible or some other holy book, instead you look how that abstract believe system has be
by cr0sh 9y ago
> For example to distinguish a religion from a cult, you don't study the bible or some other holy book, instead you look how that abstract believe system has been working so far, e.g. by checking how many generations have been successfully raised with it and how much progress they made.
Note - I am not an expert in any of this, but that said:
“In a cult there is a person at the top who knows it's a scam. In religion that person is dead.” - Anon
Examples:
Mormonism - started by a known documented and convicted con artist
Scientology - started (apocryphally) because of a bet
Both of these new religions, both started within the last 200 years (1830 for Mormonism, 1954 for Scientology), the former having in common only certain general themes with Christianity, and then ret-conning new material in to complete the "history", and the latter making up everything out of whole, bad sci-fi cloth.
One could easily argue that all religions started out as cults; certainly what we know of the historical parts of Christianity makes it a likely candidate. Likely only the very earliest naturalism-based quasi-religions lost to pre-history are among the only ones which could honestly count as "pure".
Not that any of them have led to honest understanding of the world (I will allow for philosophical introspection and discussion, which definitely and ultimately led to our current scientific methods, though those methods too were influenced and pre-empted by earlier non-religious philosophical methods, particularly those by the early Greek societies).
Again - these are my (perhaps flawed) understandings, though I am open to learning more, even if that new knowledge contradicts what I already know...
- jarek-foksa 9y agoAn abstraction layer can be still useful even though its core assumptions don't reflect the reality and could be easily disproven by a scientific experiment. Take classical physics for example. Just to be clear, I was not defending any religious system here, I just meant it's easier to judge their usefulness based on a practical basis because of their complexity.