4 ms·
> So a Ghost in the shell for us westerns is kind of obvious; a robot has nothing, it is a shell by default, and you can add a human consciousness. I don't thi
by taneq 9y ago
> So a Ghost in the shell for us westerns is kind of obvious; a robot has nothing, it is a shell by default, and you can add a human consciousness.
I don't think it's obvious at all. If you can add a human consciousness to a(n entirely non-human-biological) robot, then that "human consciousness" is no different in nature to the robot's software. A difference in degree, certainly, but not of kind. Yet most westerners would claim a difference in kind between software and a "person".
Point taken, though, about the way the film's interpretation changes depending on the cultural mindset of the watcher. I'll do some reading. :)
- franciscop 9y agoAh sorry, I was trying to make emphasis on the part that the robot is an empty shell for us and not specially on human consciousness being easy to swap/just software (for which I agree with you). Edit: After thinking and reading about it, I think that is actually the opposite in the other direction. What might shock us is the concept of the spirit being transfered, while for Shintoism that is not such a shocking concept since they are not so concerned with the afterlife and their spirit will just join nature: "The afterlife, and belief, are not major concerns in Shinto; the emphasis is on fitting into this world instead of preparing for the next, and on ritual and observance rather than on faith." - interesting read: https://www.japanspecialist.co.uk/travel-tips/shinto-buddhism/ https://www.japanspecialist.co.uk/travel-tips/shinto-buddhis...
- hashhar 9y agoThis reminds me of the conclusion of the game SOMA. You can find some interesting discussion here. https://www.reddit.com/r/soma/comments/3pa4fu/philosophy_in_soma/ https://www.reddit.com/r/soma/comments/3pa4fu/philosophy_in_...