2 ms·
This is a good topic -- I mean, in the sense that I believe the appeal of social media is firmly rooted in our desire for social connection and validation. But
by danso 9y ago
This is a good topic -- I mean, in the sense that I believe the appeal of social media is firmly rooted in our desire for social connection and validation. But that doesn't mean that the design of buttons and interaction-loops can't meaningfully add to the addictive nature. That said, I thought the OP's examples were a little flimsy without citing evidence (that the "few moments to load updates" is deliberately designed around psychology of intermittent variable rewards. I mean, sure, but the time to refresh for updates is not non-existent, even with high speed internet).
Examining the simplification of choices to binary is a nice example, IMO, of how to make social media feel less "work":
> Following the introduction of Facebook's like button in 2009, YouTube moved to a binary like/dislike format in 2010. Instagram launched that same year and came ready-made with a Like function shaped as a heart. Twitter adopted this same heart-shaped system in 2015, while, in the years since, Silicon Valley has come up with a multitude of new ways to gamify our need for social validation.
I've never really liked FB's multiple emotions, though that is partly because of the interface design in which it just takes longer to register one of the other non-Like emotions. Netflix's move from stars to thumbs-up/thumbs-down felt controversial, but I'm pretty sure I've "thumbed" more things in the past month than I had made star ratings in the past year, simply because it was easier. And the data that Netflix provides me in terms of potential movie appeal -- a likelihood described as a percentage, versus a five-star scale -- feels more straightforward, and doesn't seem to significantly differ in accuracy from what I remember of what Netflix used to recommend for me. Roger Ebert's print reviews used a 4-star scale, but his Thumbs-Up/Down with Gene Siskel was still very popular and widely influential.
On the topic of social media engagement design, I would love to hear more about the recent Facebook feature that prepends my name before every notification. e.g. "Dan, you have 32 new notifications and 3 pokes today." versus "You have 32 new notifications and 3 pokes today." It's such an easy an obvious feature to implement, I wonder how long it was in the making? e.g. A/B testing, psychology studies, etc. Can't say it's really worked on me except to make notifications feel more of a nag but I'm likely an outlier in that I generally rarely visit FB.
- graphitezepp 9y agoOn the topic of "few moments to load updates" while I also could not find anyone claiming to have solid evidence on this practice, FB having a history of being intentionally being anti user with it's android app is pretty well accepted. I wouldn't put it past them, though I suspect it is obfuscated in the form of javascript bloat. Anticipation plays a big role in addiction.