3 ms·
The really infuriating thing about Fukushima disaster, in my opinion, is how many people died as a result of evacuation. From wikipedia: > A survey computed t
by yongjik 9y ago
The really infuriating thing about Fukushima disaster, in my opinion, is how many people died as a result of evacuation. From wikipedia:
> A survey computed that of some 300,000 evacuees, approximately 1,600 deaths related to the evacuation conditions, such as living in temporary housing and hospital closures that had occurred as of August 2013, a number comparable to the 1,599 deaths directly caused by the earthquake and tsunami in the Prefecture.
Contrast that with the actual death that occurred/will occur due to radiation:
> In 2013, WHO reported that area residents who were evacuated were exposed to so little radiation that radiation induced health impacts were likely to be below detectable levels. (...) According to a linear no-threshold model (LNT model), the accident would most likely cause 130 cancer deaths.
In other words, if the Japanese government had told everyone that this was a minor incident and everyone should stay at home, it's likely that less people would have died as a result. Of course, hindsight is 20/20, and even with perfect information it would have been political suicide anyway.
Such is the danger of nuclear power. The world's second worst nuclear disaster was literally less dangerous than running away from it.
- willj 9y agoQuestion: your second quote says: > residents who evacuated were exposed to so little radiation It does not say anything about residents who did not evacuate. How can we know how many cancer deaths would have happened if nobody had evacuated, and whether that would be less than the amount that died due to poor evacuation procedures?
- yongjik 9y agoGiven the difference of ~130 vs ~1600 in actual deaths, I'm naively assuming that staying at home would not have increased radiation exposure tenfold. (There are ways to limit radiation exposure even if you're in the middle of a lightly contaminated region. I think delivering clean food would have been easier than trying to accommodate 300k additional refugees after tsunami.)