2 ms·
It's difficult to prove things about the world---but maybe it's actually near-impossible? Scientists always hesitate to talk about "proof," since we hold our b
by analog31 9y ago
It's difficult to prove things about the world---but maybe it's actually near-impossible?
Scientists always hesitate to talk about "proof," since we hold our beliefs on a tentative basis. However, some scientific theories have been corroborated to such a degree that they can be regarded as proven for all practical purposes, within broad domains. These include classical mechanics, relativity, gravitation, quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, electromagnetism, and Darwinian evolution. This level of "proof" is trusted on a daily basis in regular lab work, e.g., if an electrical circuit violates Ohm's Law, you don't throw out Ohm's Law. You look for a bad solder joint.
Granted, science is presently dominated by the life sciences. I'm sure the physical sciences have their own problems -- we shouldn't be overconfident -- but they may be qualitatively different problems. In my view, a journalist shouldn't generalize about "science" without showing that they've considered whether the generalization is justified.
Disclosure: My background is in physics, and my day job is in scientific instrumentation. It's a business where people are obsessive about replication. When an instrument goes out the door, it's been put through a stringent set of tests that could be described as replications, and the results of these tests are compared across different designs, models, batches of components, and even competing brands, all around the world.