3 ms·
Anonymity is only required when there is one source. If they are multiple independent, unbiased sources, that is different.
by Chris2048 9y ago
Anonymity is only required when there is one source.
If they are multiple independent, unbiased sources, that is different.
- foldr 9y ago>Anonymity is only required when there is one source. Not clear what you mean by this. The WP used multiple anonymous sources for many of its Watergate stories. >If they are multiple independent, unbiased sources, that is different. The current stories about Trump are based on multiple sources. What gives you the idea that they stem from a single source? After all, Trump’s administration is one of the leakiest in living memory.
- Chris2048 9y agoI mean non-anonymity - ie to know the source. > The current stories about Trump are based on multiple sources I don't see evidence of that, but also there were two important conditions: independent and unbiased. The problem here is I also don't trust the press anymore to not misrepresent sources. Eventually, the evidence needs to surface.
- foldr 9y ago>I mean non-anonymity - ie to know the source. Right, but your statement did not make any sense. There is no connection between the number of sources used and whether or not they are anonymous. >but also there were two important conditions: independent and unbiased. What makes you more confident that the Watergate sources were independent and unbiased? You are trusting the judgment of the journalists in both cases. >I don't see evidence of [multiple sources]? Are you kidding? There are, at the very least, people who were in the meeting, and people in the Israeli intelligence community, who clearly weren't.
- Chris2048 9y agoSorry for delay, > There is no connection between the number of sources used and whether or not they are anonymous. there is - If there is only one source it requires more scrutiny. Multiple independent sources might at least be checked for consistency. > What makes you more confident that the Watergate sources were independent and unbiased I don't, as I already stated, I don't know much about WG - you brought it up. > people who were in the meeting, and people in the Israeli intelligence community, who clearly weren't. Depends on what you are trying to prove - If it's "what Trumps said" then people not in the meeting have no reliability on the matter.
- foldr 9y ago>there is - If there is only one source it requires more scrutiny. Multiple independent sources might at least be checked for consistency. And that is so regardless of whether the sources are anonymous. >I don't, as I already stated, I don't know much about WG - you brought it up. If the WP was following your guidelines for the use of sources, it would not have published the Watergate stories. >Depends on what you are trying to prove That Trump shared classified info.