4 ms·
Intelligent people have 'unnatural' preferences and values
- hugh3 16y agoIn the current study, Kanazawa argues that humans are evolutionarily designed to be conservative, caring mostly about their family and friends, and being liberal, caring about an indefinite number of genetically unrelated strangers they never meet or interact with, is evolutionarily novel. So more intelligent children may be more likely to grow up to be liberals. That's a rather unconventional definition of "conservative" and "liberal" they're using there. One might almost suspect an agenda. I'm also unclear on why things which are "evolutionarily novel" should be correlated with higher intelligence.
- mixmax 16y agoPerhaps because one of the things that is evolutionary novel is intelligence. It seems reasonable that there's a correlation between some or all of these things, they're most probably interlinked somehow. For instance: If you're highly intelligent this will impact how you live your life, which decisions you make, etc. whic in turn could easily mean that you'll have subtly different preferences and characteristics than a less intelligent person.
- whatwhatwhat 16y agoThis article lost my respect at.. "So, more intelligent children are more likely to grow up to go against their natural evolutionary tendency to believe in God, and they become atheists." "Young adults who identify themselves as "not at all religious" have an average IQ of 103 during adolescence, while those who identify themselves as "very religious" have an average IQ of 97 during adolescence."
- mixmax 16y agoMay I ask why? I don't think it seems all that unreasonable.
- hugh3 16y agoI assume he meant because the difference turns out to be small enough to be barely significant. (And possibly completely in-.)
- DanHulton 16y agoWow, intelligent kids have an EVOLUTIONARY tendency to believe in something the decries any belief in evolution? Bizarre argument.
- philwelch 16y agoIsn't it pretty clear? Evolution predisposes people to a lot of beliefs and attitudes which served our ancestors well, but are still irrational. Intelligent people have greater ability to figure some of these out.
- 1053r 16y ago<sarcasm>Intelligent people come to non-obvious and novel conclusions! News at 11.</sarcasm>
- BoppreH 16y agoHumans are evolutionarily designed to be paranoid, and they believe in God because they are paranoid So, religion is natural? Although hard to detect, I don't think we have ever perceived any kind of belief in God in any other creature. Including the apes, that are quite similar to us considering the cited "millions of years" timespan. And +1 to "using I.Q. to measure intelligence."
- derefr 16y agoOur nature is necessary, but not sufficient, for religion. Religion wasn't invented by human hunter-gatherers; it only came around after the advent of farming, when we began to think in long timescales (like harvests, or winters) and had static resources (crops, houses) that had to be defended. Thus, we invented prayer to try to change the far future (i.e. long-term weather conditions—due to the large intervening period, it wasn't obvious whether it worked or not in any given instance, so we assumed it did), and commandments to justify our right to static resources, or our reasoning for pillaging them. We also invented the afterlife to explain how our feeling of consciousness would proceed into the far future, and gods to explain capricious phenomena (like lightning, or floods) that our minds instinctively anthropomorphized. Hunter-gatherers had their own "natural" superstitions, such as the belief that opposing tribes and the unliked were capable of "witchcraft", but these were abductive reasoning, seeing effects and guessing at individual, short-timescale past causes, rather than inductive reasoning, seeing events and proposing prinicples that would explain/predict future events.
- hugh3 16y agoI'm not sure I buy your distinction between "natural superstitions" and "religion". Can you go into more detail about why, for instance, the quite elaborate mythologies of the various Australian Aboriginal tribes don't count as religions?
- derefr 16y agoMy distinction is purely between abductive, and inductive reasoning. Mythology is abductive—it looks at things that happen, and then ascribes causes. It cannot be used to predict what will happen. Religion is inductive—you think things like "it appears that people who do X die mysteriously; therefore (through induction) God smites people who do X. Thus (deductively) God will smite me if I do X, so I should not do X." Aboriginals never develop this sort of logic.
- henryw 16y agoHere's an interesting quote: Young adults who identify themselves as "not at all religious" have an average IQ of 103 during adolescence, while those who identify themselves as "very religious" have an average IQ of 97 during adolescence. Their source: Data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health
- westbywest 16y agoThis is perhaps misleading, and not just because IQ tests have known social/cultural biases.The same data will likely show similar disparities in IQ between other complimentary groups, e.g. between children with well-educated and less-educated parents or even between boys and girls.
- hugh3 16y agoe.g. between children with well-educated and less-educated parents Well surely we should expect a genuine difference in intelligence between children of well-educated and less-educated parents? At least under the assumptions: a) Intelligence is at least partly heritable, and b) More intelligent people are likely to get more education
- yosho 16y agoI believe the author confuses correlation with causation in this article. For example, the author suggests that being nocturnal is a trait of intelligent people... but really, it could just be that intelligent people tend to be on the computer more and thus sleep later due to the constant light hitting their eyes and messing with their circadian rhythm.
- sp332 16y agoIt's not just this article, check out some of the other papers he's written: http://www2.lse.ac.uk/researchAndExpertise/Experts/s.kanazawa@lse.ac.uk http://www2.lse.ac.uk/researchAndExpertise/Experts/s.kanazaw... It's like a gallery of spurious correlations.
- axiom 16y agoEvolutionary psychology is a cesspool. Honestly it's as if 95% of the researchers in the field have never even heard of the scientific method, or things like "proof" and "evidence".