3 ms·
I guess you've run out of things to say given this cherry-picked tangent. > Leads from Deep Throat as well as other well-protected sources consistently checked
by Chris2048 9y ago
I guess you've run out of things to say given this cherry-picked tangent.
> Leads from Deep Throat as well as other well-protected sources consistently checked out
I admit, I don't know much about water-gate, or if the following DW[0] paragraph is true:
"An anonymous source was not enough during Watergate. Without a second source to confirm, The Washington Post would not publish anything, even if it came from the credible Deep Throat."
Are you saying this is not the case?
[0] http://www.dailywire.com/news/16487/another-another-watergate-trump-leaked-secrets-john-nolte http://www.dailywire.com/news/16487/another-another-watergat...
- foldr 9y agoThe trashy article you link to carefully omits to mention that the additional sources were also anonymous. See e.g. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/watergate/articles/092972-1.htm http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/water... No on the record sources at all.
- Chris2048 9y agoAnonymity is only required when there is one source. If they are multiple independent, unbiased sources, that is different.
- foldr 9y ago>Anonymity is only required when there is one source. Not clear what you mean by this. The WP used multiple anonymous sources for many of its Watergate stories. >If they are multiple independent, unbiased sources, that is different. The current stories about Trump are based on multiple sources. What gives you the idea that they stem from a single source? After all, Trump’s administration is one of the leakiest in living memory.
- Chris2048 9y agoI mean non-anonymity - ie to know the source. > The current stories about Trump are based on multiple sources I don't see evidence of that, but also there were two important conditions: independent and unbiased. The problem here is I also don't trust the press anymore to not misrepresent sources. Eventually, the evidence needs to surface.
- foldr 9y ago>I mean non-anonymity - ie to know the source. Right, but your statement did not make any sense. There is no connection between the number of sources used and whether or not they are anonymous. >but also there were two important conditions: independent and unbiased. What makes you more confident that the Watergate sources were independent and unbiased? You are trusting the judgment of the journalists in both cases. >I don't see evidence of [multiple sources]? Are you kidding? There are, at the very least, people who were in the meeting, and people in the Israeli intelligence community, who clearly weren't.
- Chris2048 9y agoSorry for delay, > There is no connection between the number of sources used and whether or not they are anonymous. there is - If there is only one source it requires more scrutiny. Multiple independent sources might at least be checked for consistency. > What makes you more confident that the Watergate sources were independent and unbiased I don't, as I already stated, I don't know much about WG - you brought it up. > people who were in the meeting, and people in the Israeli intelligence community, who clearly weren't. Depends on what you are trying to prove - If it's "what Trumps said" then people not in the meeting have no reliability on the matter.
- foldr 9y ago>there is - If there is only one source it requires more scrutiny. Multiple independent sources might at least be checked for consistency. And that is so regardless of whether the sources are anonymous. >I don't, as I already stated, I don't know much about WG - you brought it up. If the WP was following your guidelines for the use of sources, it would not have published the Watergate stories. >Depends on what you are trying to prove That Trump shared classified info.