3 ms·
"Give them brand new still-in-the-box iPhone 4’s and HTC Evos. Now ask them to make a video call to one another. With the iPhone 4, they’re going to be able to
by kenjackson 16y ago
"Give them brand new still-in-the-box iPhone 4’s and HTC Evos. Now ask them to make a video call to one another. With the iPhone 4, they’re going to be able to do it. "
How can the person with the iPhone make a video call to the person with the Evo, yet only one succeeds? Isn't it the case that for a call to be successfull, both parties need to be able to communicate?
- tvon 16y agoThe idea is they'd be making iPhone -> iPhone and Evo -> Evo calls, not calls to each other.
- kenjackson 16y agoThank you. I guess I'm one of those people that needs an iPhone. :-)
- tvon 16y agoGranted, with FaceTime being an upcoming "open standard", I suspect someone will make an Android app...
- ZeroGravitas 16y agocorrection: iPhone 4 -> iPhone 4 For no obvious reason people buying Apples 3GS over the next year will not be able to receive such calls, nor make them with their back mounted camera. Since you can't even call to the vast majority of other iPhones, you can guess how this competition would go if you had to show pictures of your newborn to your parents who only had a laptop computer. So a big hurrah for Apple's sudden embrace of "open standards", as now maybe a 3rd party will bring this to us. Shame 3rd party software is by definition not as good as Apple stuff but I guess we'll just have to cope.
- masklinn 16y ago> For no obvious reason people Lack of front camera sounds like a pretty obvious reason for lack of video chat. > So a big hurrah for Apple's sudden embrace of "open standards" Sudden? Are you joking?
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoWhy would the lack of a camera prevent you from wanting to receive a video call and see your newborn grandchild? Why, when switching between the two cameras is highlighted as a useful feature for videoing your child playing, would only having one of them kill the deal completely. Am I missing something here? I did explicitly spell these reasons for why you don't need a front facing camera for video chat out in my previous comment but you appear to have missed it. On open standards, are you really telling me that section of the keynote didn't seem odd? Did you consider that it perhaps was a shot across the bow of Google introducing an actual open standard using an actual open standard video codec rather than H.264? And that its implicit message didn't clash horribly with the fact that it won't work even with some iphones or any macs, even those bought after the introduction of the feature?
- masklinn 16y ago> Why would the lack of a camera prevent you from wanting to see your newborn grandchild? Nothing, but then again it's already perfectly possible to collect and send videos using the current 3GS. What is not possible is video chat, because there is no frontal camera making chat not video. You might want to notice that Fring has support for video calls on the iPhone yet it's one-way only due to lack of front camera... > Why, when switching between the two cameras is highlighted as a useful feature for videoing your grandchild playing, would only having one of them kill the deal completely. Am I missing something here? That the main point of video chat is to see each other? The ability to switch to the back camera is a feature to temporarily show something to your correspondant. It's a nice feature to complement voice chat, but on its own it's pretty damn pointless and building a video chat application for a back camera makes no sense. > On open standards, are you really telling me that section of the keynote didn't seem odd? No. > Did you consider that it perhaps was a shot across the bow of Google introducing an actual open standard using an open standard video codec rather than H.264? h.264 is an open standard. And it's in fact part of the open standards used for facetime. > And that its implicit message didn't clash horribly with the fact that it won't work even with other some iphones or any macs bought in future? No and no. First one, because older iPhones do not have frontal camera making video chat not an option. Second one, because it piggybacks on the 3G network for the establishment of the connection, macs don't have builtin 3G access so how could they have facetime? Second one, would it be nice if iOS4 also had a regular iChat A/V client? Definitely, shame it doesn't. But it will likely get one, and there will more than likely be a Skype or Fring update using the front camera soon, but it's quite a far cry from the seamlessness apple demonstrated (and probably wanted to build) with facetime.
- bradhe 16y agoMore importantly, how does he know what the user experience on iPhone 4 is like without using iPhone 4?
- stevejohnson 16y agoHe got his hands on one after the WWDC keynote.
- Anechoic 16y agoHe attended WWDC: http://daringfireball.net/2010/06/iphone_4 http://daringfireball.net/2010/06/iphone_4