4 ms·
> This is because if, when finally screwing the parts together, the screw has to thread its way through, then the gaps between the parts won’t tighten when you
by throwanem 9y ago
> This is because if, when finally screwing the parts together, the screw has to thread its way through, then the gaps between the parts won’t tighten when you tighten the screw, because there’s no travel between them.
That's why wood screws are only threaded partway up their length. Since these screws are self-tapping, they need to account for the problem you correctly identify here, where the screw can't clamp the parts together properly because they cannot move relative to one another as the screw is tightened into place. Ending the thread partway up the screw solves this by permitting the part nearer the screw head to move freely along the shaft, so the fastener can clamp them together properly as it's tightened.
The machine screws you're using, conversely, are threaded all the way up to the head because they are not designed for self-tapping, but rather to be used in holes which have had threads tapped into them. That's why they are giving you the trouble they are. Happily, there are a few different ways to make that trouble go away!
Making the entire screw path wide enough that the screw doesn't have to tap any threads, and securing it with a nut, is one option, and as you've seen, it can work. On the other hand, you lose something in clamping force, because there's less bearing surface, and you also have to choose between machining (or designing) a nut pocket into the part, or having the nut and the end of the bolt stick out past the profile of the case.
Another option, which replicates the benefit provided by the design of self-tapping screws, is to make the screw hole wider, but only in the part nearer the head, and leave the far part's hole narrow enough that the screw will tap threads into it on the first insertion. This way, you have the part near the head free to tighten, which solves the problem you saw with your first designs, and you get the maximum clamping force possible from the screw without having to tap threads for a machine screw - and, with a carefully chosen (or trimmed) length of screw, you can also have the path end in a blind hole in the far part, so that the only part of the screw visible in the finished item is its head. (If you care, of course.)
And a third option, naturally, would be to actually tap threads into your screw holes - but you need a tap set for that, and I'm not sure there's much point. You need taps to cut threads into metal, because metal is pretty hard, and you need something very hard to cut it cleanly so that your screws, which are only pretty hard themselves, aren't ruined when you try to use them. Plastic, on the other hand, is very soft, so you're not actually hurting anything by letting your screws self-tap. You just need to adjust your design to account for it.
Hope this helps!
- StavrosK 9y agoAh, damnit, yes, this was the second thing I wanted to mention in the post (having the last part be tighter so the screw threads its way through) but forgot to write it up in the end. Thanks for the reminder, that's exactly how these designs should work, you're spot on.
- throwanem 9y agoOh, any time. In any case, I'm sure there's someone here who won't have run across it yet, and for whom it'll come in handy. On a related note - is it just me, or does the nigh monomaniacal focus lately on high-capital-investment tools like 3D printers and laser cutters seem like it might come at the cost of a lot that's of value? Like, for example, any interest at all in how to encourage and support kids coming up in places and families where a 3D printer, or a laser cutter, is about as likely of attainment as a nice little house on the far side of the moon? I don't know, I kind of feel that way, but maybe I'm the only one.
- StavrosK 9y agoWell, I got my printer for $250 new, and the print quality is fantastic, on par with some I've seen that cost $1000+. I'm not sure if you consider that high-capital, but I've definitely seen single tools (e.g. saws, and, hell, phones) cost more than that. I definitely don't think this is moon-house territory, the technology is very accessible, price-wise, especially if you consider that these tools are easily cheap enough for libraries and other communal spaces to buy and make available to the public.
- throwanem 9y agoFair point. But how much effort went into getting that print quality out of a machine at that price point? I'm still uncertain that the heavy emphasis is of net value, but I'll need to spend some time considering why I feel that way before I can make a coherent argument.
- 9y ago