5 ms·
When I read about stuff like this and also how Uber is losing a lot of money, I have to wonder if maybe there's a fundamental problem with their business model.
by criddell 10y ago
When I read about stuff like this and also how Uber is losing a lot of money, I have to wonder if maybe there's a fundamental problem with their business model.
- mathattack 10y agoTheir value isn't in the driver business, because eventually they'll just have to pay for the marginal cost of damage to the car. If they can optimize pricing between locations better than others, they'll win in the driverless world. (This drives the value, not the spread between what they pay and collect)
- criddell 9y agoThat makes sense. I think that also explains why they started their own driverless car program. Whatever company makes the first viable driverless cars, they may decide that rather than selling the cars, they will own them all and operate a ride-sharing service with them. Uber would be screwed.
- leggomylibro 10y agoThere is; they are hemorrhaging money, and only manage to stay afloat because of the billions of dollars being shoveled into the furnace by investors and nation-states. In a way, venture capital is subsidizing your rides. They're not insane, though. They're buying market share and betting that they can pull self-driving cars into their fleets while they still have the market on lock. Without having to pay drivers or deal with their whiny attempts to enforce employment laws (against an app! Crazy,) they see themselves being able to print money hand over foot. This is how you get away with being a dirtbag, in any situation. Move very quickly, and get to where you're going before anyone manages to claw you back far enough. Possession seems to be 100% of the law, when it comes to companies in this country.
- aetherson 10y agoLet's be clear that "they're buying market share and betting that they can pull self-driving cars into their fleets" thing is revisionist history. Nobody who invested billions in Uber years ago was told, "Our plan is to burn your money and win driverless cars." They didn't even have a driverless car program until about two years ago. Uber thought that they had a viable business model based on human drivers, and that their markets would settle down into profitability once they established market share. They were wrong. They thought that they could successfully expand into a logistics business -- that was a big element of their redesign, which only landed 6 months ago, for god's sake. Now you never hear about logistics (because the only people who might conceivably want Uber-for-packages, Amazon, just went ahead and built the service in-house). So now they're saying that they're a big bet on driverless cars.
- Balgair 10y agoI can't find the post, but there was a 'UBER finance guy' (self-claimed) on HN a few weeks back that 'spilled the beans' and quit on what Uber is actually: a sub-prime auto loan company. Again, this is my recollection, take it with salt. It goes like: Driver (D): I want to drive for Uber! Uber (U): Sure! Do you have a car that is safe and less than 5 years old? (I have no idea what the car reqs. are) D: No U: Ok, well, we can loan you one! Just sign this! D: Great! I signed! What are the loan repayments like? U: Well, you owe us, per the 3 year contract, $100/week (I have no idea what the actual loan terms are like, but 100 is a nice round number so lets use that) D: Ok! That's not bad! U: It gets better! We'll just auto-deduct the money you owe us from your driver's account, after that, all the money is yours! You don't have to worry about any of it, just drive for us, we'll take care of it. D: Cool! What happens when I get sick or something and can't drive? U: Well, then you still owe us the money, plus a 10% fee on that week's loan payment (again, I have no idea what the loan agreement is like, YMMV) that we'll automatically tack on to the next week's loan payment. -A week goes by- D: Oh man, the weather was great this week, not a lot of people needed me to drive them around! I only made $90! U: Ok, well, per the loan agreement, you owe us $10 more then (100-90=10), plus the 10% late fee, making your next week's payment $100 + $10 + (0.1 x $100) = $120. D: Oh man! I better hope that the weather is bad so people want to take an Uber that I am driving! -Another week goes by- D: The weather was really rainy, but even still, I only got notifications to pick up $90 worth of people! Not again! U: Well, now you owe us $120 - $90 = $30 plus the 10% late fee on the $120, making your next week's payment $100 + $30 + (0.1 x $120) = $142. D: Well, darn, I thought a lot of people wanted to take Ubers! All my friends take them! But I don't get enough notifications to pick people up from Uber! U: We know. We are the people that are giving you a loan and simultaneously are the ones that control how much of that loan you can pay back because we are the ones that tell you how many people you pick up and we also set the 'surge' rates and regular rates that we tell you. Also, we have something of a history of acting in morally reprehensible way without shame. D: Wait, what did you say?! U: Nothing! Nothing at all! Get back to driving! That car we bought isn't going to pay itself off, you are!
- omegaworks 10y ago> against an app! Should that in some way magically exempt them from hard won (with blood [1]) labor protections? 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haymarket_affair https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haymarket_affair
- pjmorris 10y agoIt's astounding to me that they can't make it work based on the convenience of the service. I understand the strategy of wanting to buy market share quickly, and to bet on self-driving cars. That they can't compete on the convenience of the service at a fair price and playing by the rules of the districts they operate in is just astonishingly bad management.
- potatolicious 10y agoI'd argue they did - I was around San Francisco when Uber was getting off the ground, and the initial service is exactly that: convenient, high-quality, provided professional drivers with commercial insurance. It was also expensive, and nowadays known as UberBlack, and is a market many times smaller than Uber's ambitions. UberBlack was a great product with unit economics that would allow for a high-quality product that was a win-win for both drivers and Uber. But it was not a big enough product to justify Uber's stratospheric valuation - hence UberX. I think we're running into the fundamental truth here that providing high-quality taxi rides at such cut-rate prices is not possible, at least not when a human is at the wheel. Cutting corners and playing dirty are IMO a manifestation of this fundamental problem.
- dullgiulio 10y agoAbsolutely agree. Another part of the problem is the need to become a unicorn at any cost. Why prefer having a huge valuation (based on thin air) when you can have a more modest but totally profit generating business? This is a question that many in the Valley should answer honestly.
- adultSwim 10y agoThere is. Uber is predicated on brazen lawlessness and squeezing workers.