4 ms·
It all depends on the context. But yes, we all have to be really careful what we say. Not for fear of being shamed -- for fear of offending someone! Calling so
by nerdponx 10y ago
It all depends on the context.
But yes, we all have to be really careful what we say. Not for fear of being shamed -- for fear of offending someone! Calling someone a "princess" for liking salads could easily be taken as an offense, gender aside.
It's the same reason you don't just go around talking politics in the officf. Keep that kind of dialogue out of the workplace.
- Chris2048 10y ago> Keep that kind of dialogue out of the workplace. Or freely leave until you find a place that's cool.
- d3ad1ysp0rk 10y ago"Cool" for me isn't somewhere that I can say anything I want without concern for how it affects others. Cool is inclusive.
- Chris2048 10y agoBut that's a strawman, since I didn't say that. You talk of vague "inclusivity", and hyperbolic "say anything I want"; but the post specifically referred to "Calling someone a 'princess' for liking salads" - when are we going to be inclusive of differing opinions and forms of expression? Seems a very specific interpretational framework is being mandated here. Using rough language versus running off to HR when offended - I know who I'd prefer working with.
- nerdponx 10y agoThere are so many other/better ways to question someone's taste, even in jest. This is also why I originally said it depends on the context. You can say it to a work buddy who you hang out with after hours. You can't say it to someone from another team who you don't know very well. Use your head.
- Chris2048 9y agobetter according to who? If you retreat when pushed, they'll just keep pushing. The issue here isn't whether you offend someone, it's who should be sided with when it goes to HR.
- watwut 9y agoYeah, but when you make "salad princess" joke, you are the one pushing. And she is the one that has to either retreat or push back - either directly by humiliating you back or less directly through HR. If she pushes back and humiliates you back, would you be cool with it?
- Chris2048 9y ago"Humiliate" in the same sense? Sure! But it's always possible to claim your offense is real. Pushing is using real authority to moderate a person's own language. Interpretation is subjective. HR is neither a nuanced or objective judge of semantics - they aren't even in the same ballpark as a direct response.
- watwut 9y agoI did not meant "humiliate" nor "would you be ok if she responded in playful nuanced way". I meant if she humiliated you back, really. After all, pleasant joking "humiliation" would not make you stop. I meant would you be ok if she really humiliated you. As you said, offense is semantic. Pushing back won't be comfortable to you. If she did that, would the teasing stop or would the group take your side and retaliated?
- Chris2048 9y agoAgain, in the same way, Sure. "humiliated you back" implies it's humiliating in the first place, so I have no idea what standard you are applying. > If she did that, would the teasing stop or would the group take your side and retaliated? false choice. I don't know what you mean retaliate, anymore than I know what you mean "really humiliated". Maybe I'm thick skinned, but what do you imagine a coworker could say?
- nerdponx 10y agoInsulting your coworkers is not "cool".
- auserperson 10y agoThis reeks of privilege. A lot of people leaves until they find a place where they can get a paycheck, do their job, and not be discriminated. If you can choose jobs for their "coolness" factor, you don't seem to have this problem. So you should at least understand that inclusive and professional behavior, even though is "uncool" for you, it's vital for a lot of people.
- Chris2048 9y agoThe 'p' word always seems to come out, as a kind of insult or accusation, I assume since you used it with "reek" (implication of negativity) this is the case here? Yes, in fact anyone living in the west is privileged. Since we are talking in the context of software engineers, we're probably better off than most. Who are you talking about? > get a paycheck, do their job, and not be discriminated What "discrimination"? Being called a princess? or being shamed/fired for calling someone a princess? It doesn't quite fit that someone "just" wants to collect their paycheck, yet rocks the boat on such a minor issue. > inclusive and professional behavior Are just words, without substance. Are tattoos unprofessional? or would discriminating against people with them not be inclusive?
- auserperson 9y ago1- I don't feel like i need to explain the concept of minority to you. 2- no one got fired for calling someone a princess, so that's just deviating the subject to a fake conversation. I wouldn't had approved this. But someone got anonymously given out that made someone else uncomfortable, which is fine. 3- Some people can collect their paychecks without having to be offended, so it just seems just. 4- tattoos can be unprofessional. if they have a fucking swatiska or a pepe the frog on them, and I don't fucking care if people with those get fired.
- Chris2048 9y ago> I don't feel like i need to explain the concept of minority to you. great. I'm not sure I asked your opinion on the matter. > no one got fired for calling someone a princess I said "shamed/fired", and we're talking about HR, who are generally there to protect the company from disrepute, including firing people. The US is well know for liberal and at-will termination. > Some people can collect their paychecks without having to be offended That isn't the point - I'm calling into question your narrative: 'If you can choose jobs for their "coolness" factor', you are suggesting there are people who cannot choose their jobs for 'coolness', because there are more important things they are choosing for that reduce the number of jobs available to them; I am suggesting "being called a princess" is as superficial as "coolness". > if they have a fucking swatiska This is a tangent isn't it? The point is, those words aren't always consistent as attitudes on what is 'professional' change, and have changed, over time. What constitutes 'unprofessional' is a matter of opinion, you are flipping this around to suggest that if something (might be) considered unprofessional,. I should not so it - but if everyone did this nothing would change. TLDR; calling something professional etc is an appeal to (supposed) popular opinion, not an argument.
- anothercomment 10y agoHow do you ever criticize somebody in such a friendly office? I suppose the need just never arises, because HR only hires flawless, swell people to begin with? So that if ever somebody takes a disliking to somebody else, it must be because of racism or sexism?
- watwut 9y agoYou criticize what the person did and state you reasons. You avoid making allusions on sterile cyclists if that person happens to cycle to work. It is easier to criticize people if you did not picked up on them nor mocked nor humiliated them previously. Because a.) they will have more trust to what you say b.) they will not assume you are not just humiliating them again c.) they will not be predispose to see you as a jerk.