4 ms·
From what I’ve seen, USB-C is a disaster. The ports and cables all have to support specific profiles, which are just getting more and more complicated, for spec
by chrismorgan 9y ago
From what I’ve seen, USB-C is a disaster. The ports and cables all have to support specific profiles, which are just getting more and more complicated, for specific features to work, and there is no visual indication at all of this. If you got a cheap cable (which people will do), you may suddenly find that maybe charging doesn’t work. Or maybe it melts. Or maybe it doesn’t transfer data. Or maybe using it for a video signal doesn’t work. There is no way of telling without trying it.
USB-C just isn’t popular enough yet to have crashed and burned (though even after that it’ll still be popular for ages for want of an alternative).
I have a Surface Book (the hardware was good enough to get me to switch from Linux, without ever actually having seen one), and the Surface cable is marvellous. Magnets are awesome, and the Surface Book is probably the most carefully magnetically-designed computer hardware. At work I have a Dock and I pretty much just put the Book on the desk by the connector and it jumps into place and my external monitors connect. And removing it, really easy and it can’t go wrong. The whole thing is really, really nice.
- nrki 9y agoSure...except you have to buy a $200 dock to connect it to anything. Why can't I buy a $40 (or Chinese equivalent for $20) adapter to connect it to things? Why isn't there a pin-out or open standard? I know the magnetic factor would be a problem for this use-case - it would often be too "heavy" for the magnets.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI got my dock for about $70. Presumably if you shop around a bit, you can manage to do something similar. I haven't seen a full dock, but I have seen off-brand SurfaceConnect chargers.
- apapli 9y agoI bought a Kensington dock, I think it is the model I linked to below, but I paid way less for it on amazon. Works great. https://www.kensington.com/au/au/4491/33972/sd3500v-universal-usb-30-dual-docking-station https://www.kensington.com/au/au/4491/33972/sd3500v-universa...
- FireBeyond 9y agoIf it's anything like the Kensington sd3600p I had, not so great. Buried far below anything else was the not so little detail that if you plugged in a 4K display, USB3 ports on the dock would downshift to USB2, and GigE to 100mbps (why bother?).
- izacus 9y agoUSB-C works just fine on most laptops that have it and it's incredibly convenient when you figure out you only need to drag a single charger with you to charge your laptop, phone and tablet. Also HDMI/DP adapters worked without issues across my MacBook Pro, Samsung's Chromebook and another Dell laptop which is also hugely convenient.
- _pmf_ 9y ago> The ports and cables all have to support specific profiles, which are just getting more and more complicated, for specific features to work, and there is no visual indication at all of this. If you got a cheap cable (which people will do), you may suddenly find that maybe charging doesn’t work. Or maybe it melts. Ah, but then you should be incentivized to buy an Apple® Certified Cable™ (made 100% from organically grown coppers and hand-milled by crafty Chinese masters from a solid plastic core). Not that I would dare to suggest that the chaos is create on purpose or anything like that.
- zghst 9y agoIt's a disaster until it isn't. Until Microsoft implements it while it's competitors will have had it for ages.
- lmm 9y agoThat's often how reality works though. I remember the Apple fans mocking computers shipping with floppy disk drives, but floppy disks were useful at the time. Migrations take time, not everyone can afford to just rush out and buy all-new accessories. For a device that you buy today and will use for say 3 years, USB-A and a dongle for compatibility with -C is probably better for most users than the reverse.
- zghst 9y agoThat's the truth. But our society will only move as fast as we say to. All of this, economy, technological advance, social issues all exist in our mind. Surely a giant such as Microsoft could be dedicated to being at the forefront of a wave of events
- lmm 9y agoThese things are ultimately tools, means to an end. I'm glad MS is thinking of their users rather than adopting new for the sake of new.
- franciscop 9y agoYeah, but I prefer to program with a modern laptop than punching cards, even though so many users still know how to use the cards.
- lmm 9y agoUm what? Very few people know how to use the cards. Most people have much more experience with keyboards and prefer to use them.
- digi_owl 9y agoPretty much. What we like to think of as USB-C are actually 3 individual parts that an be swapped around as the OEMs feel like. there is the 3.1 bus speed, that can be swapped for older and slower speeds. There is the Power Delivery spec, that can be replaced with older or omitted entirely. And then there is the C plug itself, that can be replace with an A or B plug when mixed with any of the above. The only thing that the C plug offer on its own is hte aux pins that can be used to carry Displayport, HDMI or Thunderbolt signals. But again this depends on the OEM. It is a downright combinatorial explosion, that is just waiting to set fire to something. Hell, a while back there was a story about someone getting their phone drained because the C port allows bi-directional power delivery. And their powerpack used the C port for both charging itself and charging other devices. This, in combo with a phone that could charge other devices as an emergency option, allowed the two devices to ping pong a charge between them until both were run dry. Frankly the C plug and related specs are overdesigned, trying to be all things to all people.