3 ms·
Fast money: the battle against the high frequency traders (2014)
- brudgers 10y agoArticle is from 2014. Probably should be noted in the title.
- tutufan 10y agoThe boring truth is that average Joes, who interact with the markets only via their retirement index funds, are better off with HFTs. Not necessarily a lot better off, but that's because HFTs really don't affect them much at all. Certainly some Wall Street firms have been displaced by HFTs. But really, who cares?
- murbard2 10y agoThe average Joe who interacts with the market by picking stocks or day trading (which he shouldn't do) is substantially better off with HFT (though he still shouldn't do it).
- mac01021 10y agoWhy substantially better off?
- jshaqaw 10y agoBecause hft means the bid ask spread on most transactions has shrunk to trvial/nonexistent (I am a professional investor but not hft...I'm very lft).
- murbard2 10y agoIn fact the retail investor can get an even better deal than the bid ask spread through internalization of the flow, but that comes in the form of paying no commissions. The marginal cost of a retail trade for a broker is negative (but acquiring the customer is still expensive).
- mac01021 10y agoDoesn't that just mean that all the really attractive offers have been snatched up by the high-frequency traders? Wouldn't those lucrative, high-spread opportunities otherwise be available to a regular day trader?
- mjfl 10y agoNo... because regular day traders aren't market makers, they are market takers. HFTs are bad for other market makers, because they are basically competition. HFTs are good for market takers, because you get a good price.
- MRSallee 10y agoDisclosure: I know almost literally nothing about trading stocks. (The following will likely prove it.) Seems to me that automation should be a massive benefit to everyone in stock trading, except for the folks whose jobs are directly displaced by it. The relatively small number of people in this profession command massive salaries, largely because of their position as a bottleneck for financial dealings. They are gate keepers, highly educated gate keepers, and their relative scarcity means that the management of money is really, really expensive. If algorithms can do the job, well, it's much easier to duplicate an algorithm. Shouldn't automation increase competition, the expertise and leverage of a relatively small and powerful employment sector duplicated and spread out, to the point that the cost of trading stocks becomes essentially zero? So while my 401k may be run by a human hedge fund manager who's competing against automation, and is likely to lose this "battle against the high frequency traders," shouldn't I hope that my hedge fund manager is replaced by automation, rather than finds a way to beat it (or make it illegal)?
- shaftway 10y agoThe point isn't that an algorithm is doing it. It's that algorithms are actively poisoning the system with orders that couldn't possibly trade. By stuffing the pipe with these orders, timely information to other traders is delayed; the article states that the delay can be on the order of 30 seconds. If I'm spending a half billion to colocate in an exchange's data center because it'll trim a few microseconds off my data transit time, I'd be pretty pissed if I was suddenly delayed by 30 seconds.
- tutufan 10y agoIndeed you would. Which is why this sort of illegal behavior rarely happens. (Keep in mind that none of this is anonymous or forgotten--the exchanges and SEC know exactly who did what when.)