3 ms·
It's a sliding scale. There is a lot of work out there that has some value, but that value is lower than the value the people are willing to do the job for. L
by dagw 9y ago
It's a sliding scale. There is a lot of work out there that has some value, but that value is lower than the value the people are willing to do the job for. Let's say there is a job that is 'worth' $5/hour but it costs $12/hour to hire someone to do it. A reasonable argument could be made that the additional value generated for the government/society to get one person off of actual welfare and into the job market could be worth $7/hour.
- gabemart 9y agoThere's also work where the overall utility generated might be much higher than the cost of the labor, but the utility generated specifically for the business or local government considering the project is lower than the cost of the labor. Planting trees might only be worth $5/hour for the local lumber company, but the existence value of a new forest to the population generally might be many times that. I suspect that the amount of potential work that fits into this category is enormous.
- int_19h 9y agoThis is an orthogonal issue, though - we're just not good at capturing the true benefits (and the true costs, including externalities) for many things. Broadly speaking, though, I agree. This is one other case where we can do better - instead of constructing a "broken window" in the private sector and have the person repair it to keep them busy, directly utilize their labor for a socially productive task that may not be market-efficient. But I'm not sure that there's enough of that kind of useful work (i.e. the kind that actually makes a difference) to keep everyone busy. It also feels like it's mostly easy to automate.
- kwhitefoot 9y ago> But I'm not sure that there's enough of that kind of useful work Perhaps we should not worry about that until all the useful work has in fact been done.
- int_19h 9y agoIf we're retraining people to do it, we absolutely should, because we'd be spending significant resources for something that might prove a very short-sighted investment. It might be better to just invest that money into automation to do that same work instead.
- dagw 9y agoI imagine that most jobs that have a 'value' of ~$5/hour don't require much training. Also we could implement this policy tomorrow if we wanted to while automation is still many years out (at best) for a lot of tasks, so the two policies could be run in parallel.
- int_19h 9y agoI seriously doubt there'd be much work around that has such low value, and that cannot be automated. And if it can be automated, what is the additional value to society to have human perform it instead?