11 ms·
This is nonsense. Genes don't work by some sort of "total weight" principle like pebbles on a balance. And intelligence has noting to do with "right" vs "left"
by snowwrestler 9y ago
This is nonsense. Genes don't work by some sort of "total weight" principle like pebbles on a balance.
And intelligence has noting to do with "right" vs "left". That sort of political framing language is an excellent smell test for bad scientific information.
- astrange 9y agoGenes work in whatever way is easiest for evolution to work, and linear improvements are pretty easy to find this way, so can you rule it out?
- snowwrestler 9y agoYes I can. The definition of a gene is unit of hereditary information that determines a specific characteristic of an organism. Inherent in that definition is that each gene, and the characteristic it encodes, is distinct. So when many genes are expressed simultaneously, you can get complex interactions between these distinct characteristics. But not a straight linear additive effect. If 5 genes all encode the same characteristic, then by definition they are actually just 5 copies of the same gene. Intelligence is not related to genetics through some simple scalar factor. It is far, far more complex than that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- defen 9y ago> But not a straight linear additive effect. It mostly is when you're talking about "why person X has a higher IQ than person Y". It's not when you're asking why or how humans have intelligence at all, obviously. https://arxiv.org/abs/1408.3421 https://arxiv.org/abs/1408.3421