5 ms·
America’s Cities Are Running Out of Room
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI think it ebs and flows. When my parents were my age, it was the biggish cities, and then you had these bustling towns. Then as intown went bad with crime, etc. everyone moved out and created a new "rich" area. Now the rich area is moving back downtown. In decades to come, when the rich own all there is of the town, then people will keep pushing further and further out, until they create new big cities. tl;dr: There's a lot of land out there and living cycles will repeat.
- ghaff 9y agoThere's a current trend among a certain demographic (that tends to align fairly well with the writers for coastal pubs and the readers of sites such as this) to prefer living in the urban cores of a handful of coastal US cities. But the assumption that this represents some inevitable long-term trend seems questionable--including among the same individuals once they have kids they want to send to good, safe schools. Furthermore, look at trends like autonomous vehicles. Personally I think a lot of people are way optimistic on the timeframes, But if you can really go "RoboJames, take us to the opera!" or "Pick up our groceries!" a lot of the attraction of actually living in a crowded noisy location starts to go away.
- jshaqaw 9y agoNYC has plenty of very good very safe public schools. Gone (at least for now) is the need to move to the burbs or pay up private for that.
- closeparen 9y agoThere's nothing inherent in high population density that makes schools bad or unsafe.
- ghaff 9y agoThere are many reasons that families often prefer locations outside of cities (backyards, larger properties, etc.) but, in general, urban public schools in the US are a mixed bag relative to affluent suburbs. Of course, there are good urban schools but quality varies a lot and it can be a lottery to get a child into a particular school.
- malandrew 9y agoNot only do SDCs offer that benefit, they also have the potential of making the city center more accessible from the suburbs. Imagine living in sonoma county and being able to summon an Uber pod that will whisk you to the city at high speeds while you do your own thing in comfort such as read or watch your favorite show.
- kilroy123 9y agoI actually worry a lot about self-driving cars. I think they'll lead to more urban sprawl. Since it won't be a big deal to live out far away. Commuting will be much faster on a freeway filled with autonomous cars moving quickly, and you able to just sit back and enjoy the ride. I think this will ultimately lead to the US becoming far more conservative. Large cities are traditionally much more liberal areas.
- cortesoft 9y agoRight, but I think that has a lot to do with interacting with a large, diverse, group of people in your day to day life. Won't this still be true for people who live in the country but commute to the city every day?
- ghaff 9y agoIn general, a lot of the same politics apply to the suburbs and exurbs of large cities as the downtown cores. (There are differences based on wealth but it's not a clear liberal/conservative split.) I'd also note that a lot of jobs are not actually in cities but in suburban and exurban areas. In the Boston area, for example, I expect the majority of tech jobs are outside of the cities in spite of a significant increase in recent years.
- kcorbitt 9y agoIf I were investing in property today, I'd be buying waterfront property a 45-60 minute drive away from a vibrant coastal city. I agree with you that self-driving cars will increase sprawl -- people will feel less of a need to live in the city center if they can still get there with little expense or fuss. Having views of the water, on the other hand, will be just as attractive as ever, and may replace living downtown as a symbol of wealth.
- ghaff 9y agoBy and large those locations are already pretty expensive. Marin County and Half Moon Bay in California are no bargains. Even further out, nor is Santa Cruz. The North and South Shores of Massachusetts are pretty expensive as well.
- mjevans 9y agoI'm actually quite sick of lots not being built to their potential and a chain of management firms selling properties to each other in schemes to foist the maintenance costs on to someone else. I think it would be in the public's interest to step in and provide baseline competition for the market. Not just at the bottom but at every layer of the stack. A series of non-profit entities should be made to keep competition even with each other, profits should be both limited and surpluses split between 'rainy day' investment funds, expanding the non-profit owned properties, and proper maintenance. Anything leftover should go towards reducing property taxes for everyone in the area. Anyone renting from such an entity should also be a "shareholder" in it, just like with credit unions.
- jopsen 9y agoSee: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_cooperative There are pros and cons. Sometimes buying in is really expensive, sometimes you can't sell your share, sometimes it losses value. Sometimes the share is really cheap it's equivalent to rent apartment. My student housing in Denmark was like this. Buy-in was 10$ or so, and you could never sell. But you get to vote on things like, representatives, higher rent, maintenance, etc :) If I had to rent long-term I would definitely prefer that.
- stevecalifornia 9y agoAn idea: Do like some place in Europe did, property tax based on building footprint-- not in useable sq ft. This encourages growth upwards.
- koolba 9y agoThat'll never fly in the heart of NIMBY country. They won't even let you add an extension, let alone demolish a low rise to build a high rise.
- hypersoar 9y agoA lot of people in cities are trying to fight growth upwards. They are not for want of ways to encourage it.
- cortesoft 9y agoThere are already plenty of incentives to build up, as pointed out in the article; the issue is that existing home owners in the area have a strong incentive to fight against it.
- nwah1 9y agoThis is thinking along the right lines, but the only non-arbitrary solution is a land value tax. The effects are profound. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
- scld 9y agoI've mostly been a free market advocate for housing, alongside sensible zoning that keeps, say, chemical plants away from schools. However, I was recently convinced of one aspect of town infrastructure that really requires thoughtful management of population: The sewer system. My town has historically had bad flooding during heavy storms which has been made worse in the past decade due to a relative population boom. I'm sure this is vast room for improvement in speeding up additional capacity construction, but to me it's the major issue keeping housing from being truly set free.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoThe fundamental issue with zoning is that control is too local. Building in an area fundamentally helps those who want to move in at the expense of those who already live there and enjoy the higher home prices and wages that the restriction on building provides. The increased asset prices for landowners in the Bay Area far from makes up for the extra commuting costs imposed and marginal businesses priced out of the area - but landowners can vote on zoning laws here, and the commuters and those priced out can't.
- blazespin 9y agoNo, the Bay Area can not handle more density until the 101 and commuting is fixed. The real problem though is urbanization. People just want to live in cities as opportunities in rural areas dry up. Honestly, I don't think there is any solution in a free society. The simple fact is in the future status, real status not just gold necklaces and fast cars, will be about where you live. Taking zoning rights away from local voters is a pretty awful idea. We can't be all about freedom and privacy and give up local control.
- closeparen 9y agoPeople who live in skyscrapers a few blocks from their offices don't need 101.
- blazespin 9y agoit's not that simple. People change jobs.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoWhereupon they can move if traffic is bad. Well, they could if there wasn't rampant rent control.
- jshaqaw 9y agoCan't speak to the Bay Area but in NYC we have hit the physical limits of population until there is a serious investment in infrastructure. The subways are bursting at the seams. In Manhattan we are running out of sunlight. These article always bug me a little as we already live in the densest spot in the US and get lectured why we need to crowd in more.
- ChrisLTD 9y agoAgreed on the subway and a lot of Manhattan, but Brooklyn is far less dense and filled with 2 and 3 story buildings that could easily be 5 and 6 stories without shrouding Brooklyn in shadows.
- jshaqaw 9y agoYeah decent point.
- ghaff 9y agoThat's a point that is often missed and it's something that happens over a timeframe of decades. In NYC, the Second Avenue Subway has only been planned for something like a century and is now (very partially) operational. Meanwhile, within the city itself, San Francisco has one stretch of BART more or less along Market.
- JimboOmega 9y agoIn SF we absolutely haven't (especially if you add in the peninsula), but the planning rules are ridiculously restrictive, especially outside the SoMa "core". We're probably who this is aimed at. The Bay area has some of the most bizarre real estate realities - the most expensive commercial real estate in the US, along Sand Hill Road - is mostly ugly 2-3 story suburban office buildings. It costs more than Park Avenue. And residential is worse, especially in the peninsula - rambling, ugly, 70s built single family houses for millions of dollars. No hope of ever building a 5 story apartment building, let alone the high rises the local economy would support. There is a very strong trend towards protecting everything as it was in the 70s, even as ridiculous and exclusionary as that is in practice.
- 9y ago
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoWe are most certainly not running out of space in the Bay Area. There are tons of undeveloped lots scattered throughout, and prosperous areas that have no business being limited 2-3 stories. Of course we all know that this is due to local zoning laws. However, there are many layers that compound this issue, such as infrastructure. Local districts collect the tax revenue that comes with a large employment base, but then make it another city's/county's problem when it comes to infrastructure costs associated with more housing. This in turn leads to a vicious cycle of higher housing costs in areas with more jobs/good schools/good public transportation > Leads to even more NIMBY laws designed to protect that investment > Higher housing costs. Perhaps we need to rethink how we collect and distribute local taxes?
- malandrew 9y agoEven if they aren't building affordable housing, the luxury apartments relieve demand pressure on existing housing stock. How is it that almost everyone who writes on this topic omits this fact. Luxury units may not be as good as apartments at different price points but it's strictly better than not building any housing at all.