3 ms·
4-6 hours is still half to two-thirds of a business day. If I'm actively employed, I have to schedule a vacation day for that or lose precious work/life balance
by WorldMaker 9y ago
4-6 hours is still half to two-thirds of a business day. If I'm actively employed, I have to schedule a vacation day for that or lose precious work/life balance time. Even if I'm not actively employed at the time, I know the ancient wisdom is to spend your job search as if it were a full time job, but that isn't advice meant to mandate individual candidate employers independently force you into an unpaid, overworked internship of an endless stream of variations of building useless applications.
- geofft 9y agoSuch a company is also selecting for the sort of candidates who have 4-6 hours free, either those who have no responsibilities at home and are willing to spend an evening or weekend on it, or those who have enough ability to take a vacation day and tell their boss "I'm going to be at home doing nothing." You basically need to do that for the in-person anyway, and there's a limit on how often you can do that. How many candidates with small children do you think these companies are hiring?
- wglb 9y agoThis works very well. We use it throughout the company, more so in some places. I have done this with security engineers, and to my pleasant surprise, with compliance candidates as well. It has exceeded my expectations.
- tptacek 9y agoThis works --- really well! --- when the homework meaningfully offsets both the in-person interview and phone screens. When it doesn't, and is just a ceremony the hiring team performs on most (it's never all in these cases), it's abusive. The problem is that a lot of the teams assigning these projects don't really believe in the projects and haven't put the effort in to deriving a rubric they can use to reliably condense candidate responses into hiring signals. Without that work, and without a process built in good faith to use that work, this is just cargo cult management.