6 ms·
It's like the transition from physical models to CGI in space SF - I don't think we've lost anything in the process, and certainly the quality of visuals we can
by throwanem 9y ago
It's like the transition from physical models to CGI in space SF - I don't think we've lost anything in the process, and certainly the quality of visuals we can produce now so far outstrips the pre-digital days that a meaningful comparison is hard to make, but all the same, there was a kind of physical, manual craftsmanship in the old model shops that we rarely see any more, and I'd love to know if there's anywhere that such techniques still survive outside hobbyist and artistic pursuits.
- learc83 9y agoThere's still a lot of physical model making in movies for props, and costumes. Also there are companies that make costumes, animatronics, and physical models as publicity for movies and games. http://www.legacyefx.com/ http://www.legacyefx.com/ http://wetaworkshop.com/ http://wetaworkshop.com/ And then there are the model makers who make prototypes for game pieces, toys etc... Many of them still start with physical models.
- Animats 9y agoI visited Kerner Optical some years ago, which did that kind of work. They were originally a part of Lucasfilm, and were spun off to sink or swim on their own. They sank. Here's some of those guys at work, on the first "Pirates of the Caribbean" film.[1] They were 10-20 year veterans of physical effects. Someone who'd been there five years was the new guy. Tippett Studios was one of the big model work studios. Phil Tippett saw the writing on the wall when Jurassic Park went digital. The original plan for Jurassic Park was to use models of various sizes. Now Tippett is a digital effects house. Not that being a digital effects house means job security. That's become a grind of a business, outsourced and offshored. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urvcYSpiwQA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urvcYSpiwQA
- org3432 9y agoMinor clarification, Kerner Optical was the unofficial codename for ILM, the model shop that build physical props was spun off and they decided to name themselves Kerner Optical.
- mavhc 9y agoDo you mean the new Jurassic Park film, because the old ones were mostly models, https://youtu.be/DzCID0HinMg?t=460 https://youtu.be/DzCID0HinMg?t=460
- Animats 9y agoIn the original Jurassic Park, dinosaurs moving in the open are full CG.[1] Close-ups where the actors were directly interacting with the dinosaurs were model work. That was the first major film with photorealistic CG creatures. It's still difficult to do close interaction between humans and CG-animated characters, although, with enough money and a huge team, it can be done. See "Guardians of the Galaxy" to see that done very well. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/how-cgi-works-in-jurassic-park-2014-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-cgi-works-in-jurassic-par...
- mavhc 9y agoRight, but there were only 7 mins of cgi dinosaurs in Jurassic Park 1
- mikestew 9y agoIt's like the transition from physical models to CGI in space SF - I don't think we've lost anything in the process I would argue that it depends on the money spent. Cheap CGI looks just as bad as the physical models of a 70s Godzilla movie, IMO. And the comparison to movies about everyone's favorite fire-breathing lizard is apt because Godzilla's model were cheap, too. But no one watches Japanese mutant monster movies for the attention to detail in the model work. OTOH, if you're going to argue that CGI bests the model work in 2001: A Space Odyssey, then we're just going to have to agree to disagree.
- throwanem 9y agoI won't argue that CGI can outdo 2001's practical effects. But those practical effects were the achievement of their century. Matching them in quality, in our century, has become nigh routine.
- GuiA 9y agoThe main takeaway seems to be that master artists can produce amazing things regardless of the medium they use.
- 13of40 9y agoI remember a sci-fi show that was on in the early 80s (Buck Rogers?) that had a zooming-through-stars clip in the credits. It was pretty decent for the time until my dad pointed out it was just someone dumping ping-pong balls on a camera that was pointed straight up.
- femto 9y agoWind tunnels. The workshop attached to DSTO's wind tunnel used to be a model maker's (and foreign order) paradise. I'd imagine that wind tunnels are gradually being supplanted by simulation, but that there is still a demand for the physical test and the associated modeling. I think the biggest thing we've lost in the transition from physical modeling to simulation is the widespread ability to manipulate materials. The process of model making has an inherent value, whose payoff is the ability to imagine what is possible in the physical world and to make it happen.