4 ms·
Oh this again. Free speech is an idea, not an amendment. If you censor opposing political views, you are antithetical to the concept and idea of free speech
by stale2002 9y ago
Oh this again.
Free speech is an idea, not an amendment.
If you censor opposing political views, you are antithetical to the concept and idea of free speech and you should be condemned.
- jacquesm 9y agoIf you operate a private platform that very explicitly does not censor opposing political views even if you could do so within the law then you are very much not against free speech.
- kelnos 9y agoWhat about censoring hate speech? Racist speech? Sexist speech? Xenophobic speech? Outright lies? False information? Trump has tweeted all of the above from time to time. What value does that sort of speech have? You might find the first three to be subjective, and I wouldn't entirely disagree with that, so how about the lies and false information? Should a person in a position of power be permitted to lie to people to sway their opinion? I would have no problem if Twitter were to fact-check Trump's (or anyone else wielding such power) tweets and delete or somehow diminish those that are outright lies, assuming there were checks on such a thing to avoid politicization of that fact checking.
- ManlyBread 9y agoWho gets to decide whether someone's option falls under these categories? Anyone who is put in charge of classifying such things will have a lot of power that can easily be mismanaged. Furthermore, for what reason would you trust such a person? If you already distrust Trump will you trust him more if some nameless moderator will decide which posts are okay and which aren't? Besides, he's the POTUS and he has a lot of money, if twitter will start messing with his posts he can easily set up a service on his own.
- scruple 9y ago> Who gets to decide whether someone's option falls under these categories? Anyone who is put in charge of classifying such things will have a lot of power that can easily be mismanaged. And will also be selectively enforced, as we've seen on basically every single social media platform today.
- stale2002 9y ago"Should a person in a position of power be permitted to lie to people to sway their opinion?" Yes. If you don't like it, then you can counter the speech that you disagree with, using speech of your own. Let the marketplace of ideas sort it out. I can read the facts and read competing opinions and then come to a conclusion on my own about who I agree with. I do not need some gatekeeper deciding for me what I should believe. The value of allowing "lies", is that you don't have gatekeepers or censors deciding for you about what you should believe.