12 ms·
Apple Monitoring Blood Glucose
- Xoros 9y agoI think the term "consumer base" is not heartless but in fact pretty accurate. Why not spending the probably huge amount of money in a cure instead of monitoring devices ? Well, because why kill the Golden Egg Goose ? Millions of people who have to take pills every day are good recurent money. If you cure them, no more cash. (Well it's the middle of the night, I can't sleep and fill a little bit bitter...) One more thing. I'm a bit scared with all the private companies collecting personal medical datas. But maybe I've read too much science fiction.
- qzervaas 9y agoAgreed about private companies and collecting of data, but in the case of Apple, none of your HealthKit data is transmitted (it's all stored on your iPhone and/or Apple Watch). Any app that reads/writes HealthKit data is required to provide a privacy policy before it passes App Store approval. Additionally, apps can only access that data after a full-screen permissions screen is displayed, and the user manually toggles on the categories of Health data that the app can access. In my experience, the bar for getting apps that use HealthKit is at least slightly higher than for non-HealthKit apps.
- Xoros 9y agoDidn't knew about that. If true (and I trust you on this one) that's a little relief.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI think this idea is pretty odd. If someone had a cure for diabetes, you'd bet they'd charge an arm and a leg for it. The patents alone would be incredibly valuable. From a non-monetary standpoint, dehumanizing companies is always a bit frustrating. They consist of people, like you and me. Most people aren't sociopaths and the idea that business leaders are entirely sociopathic is worth challenging. I don't think most people would want to withhold a cure for recurring revenue. Charge for it, yes, but not withhold it.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoAlso, withholding cure for a big disease is not necessarily a stable equilibrium on the market - the first company to release such a cure would mop the floor with their competitors.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThis is only true if a one-off sale of the cure is significantly more profitable than a reliable income stream from products that help manage the disease without curing it. For that to be true the cure would have to be more expensive than management by at least an order of magnitude - assuming monthly refills for management and an annual reporting cycle - but still not so expensive that it became unaffordable.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoCan someone provide links to examples of companies withholding cures in exchange for profit? If not, the idea of this is nothing but conspiratorial. If it's true, though, it's worth knowing.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoI wasn't being conspiratorial, so much as adding some detail to a market-based model. As in the other post below, I don't believe magic bullet cures are possible for most diseases. Following that economic logic further, it's much cheaper and easier to produce a not-very-effective but marketable palliative than it is to aim for a Nobel-winning medical moonshot. I don't know of any suppressed super-cures, but evidence confirming the limited effectiveness of (e.g.) SSRIs is easy to find and hard to argue with. Similarly questionable outcomes have been noted in other fields. E.g. novel anticoagulants: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dabigatran https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dabigatran
- Xoros 9y agoMy original statement was about how much money goes in treatment research vs in cure research. Not about some conspiracy :-)
- ekianjo 9y ago> If you cure them, no more cash This is pretty shortsighted. Because: - it's not like you would cure everyone at once anyway - there are always people who will develop the disease eventually so you can always make money in the long run - if you are the only effective treatment you can pretty much make the price you want, and collect massive profits that can be invested in the develop of other drugs or solutions. Never heard of vaccine companies going bankrupt, for example.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoI've never heard of successful vaccine companies going bankrupt. But vaccines are an exception in medicine. Serious conditions rarely have magic bullet cures. E.g. "cancer" isn't one condition, it's a set of loosely related problems. It's very unlikely indeed there will ever be "a cure for cancer", but not at all unlikely that specific cancers will become much more treatable. That doesn't stop companies promising to develop magic bullet cures - or magic bullet anything - and getting huge interest from investors. (See also Theranos, etc.)
- akg_67 9y agoYou might want to look into Gensym (sp?) and their Hepatitis cure. The company got a big boost when they released the cure but now they are being pummeled by the market and analysts as the need for their cure is declining (fewer cases). There is no money in cure, money is in turning medical issues into chronic diseases. US pharma research is focused on chronic management and not cure. When was the last time a cure originated from US based research?
- ekianjo 9y ago> There is no money in cure That's also because state put caps as to how much vaccines are supposed to cost, which makes them less profitable than they should be. However if you were to consider the cost of a one-time vaccine versus treating some illness for the rest of your life, it's expected consumers would go for the vaccine unless it's prohibitively expensive.
- _ph_ 9y agoFirst, these things are not easily exchangeable. Yes, it is important researching for cures as well as for treatments in the absence of "cures". But with diseases, which are caused by bad habits mainly, a device like the Apple Watch can be part of the cure, if it helps preventing the disease. And, of course, as long as we don't know how to cure, we should at least optimize the treatments.
- highd 9y agoResearch labs have been trying this for years with every spectroscopy known to man - the signal is just too weak. I don't see any reason to think Apple has figured something out that labs of optics experts can't do on the benchtop.
- harigov 9y agoI think machine learning coupled with increase in sensitivity of the signals could make a difference.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoWhy would machine learning be able to overcome a lack of statistical power?
- cperciva 9y agoIt's not clear whether there's actually a lack of statistical power, or simply a lack of sufficient modelling of the noise.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIt wouldn't, but maybe there is enough statistical power, but it's just tricky to process?
- harigov 9y agoDid you miss the part about sensitive sensors? A single sensor may not be enough to classify accurately but multiple sensors measuring different things can sometimes work. Such sensor fusion has worked incredibly well for IMU's and also in self-driving cars.
- lj3 9y agoThat's how the Glucotrack claims to work. From their site: GlucoTrack uses ultrasonic, electromagnetic and thermal technologies to non-invasively measure glucose levels in the blood. GlucoTrack is intended for use by Type 2 and pre-diabetics. GlucoTrack combines the following technologies: Ultrasound (speed of sound change within the tissue); Electromagnetic (conductivity of the tissue); Thermal (heat capacity of the tissue). It's not approved by the FDA, but it appears to be selling in Australia, New Zealand, Spain, China, Korea, Italy and some others.
- templaedhel 9y agoAs a type 1 diabetic I'm super excited to see apple working in this space, even if they're focusing it on type 2 to start (a logical move, considering there is something like 30x more type 2 diabetics in the US). I think making it easier to track glucose levels in real time is the number one thing that can be done to improve quality of life for both types of diabetics. The "CGM" (continuous glucose monitor) has really come into it's own over the last 10 or so years, and I would encourage all diabetics (but especially type 1) to use one. Currently the only 2 real options on the market are: - http://www.dexcom.com/ http://www.dexcom.com/ - Connects directly to your phone using bluetooth and will send glucose warnings etc as notifications. - https://www.medtronicdiabetes.com/products/enlite-sensor https://www.medtronicdiabetes.com/products/enlite-sensor - Designed to work with Medtronic (who is a market leader) insulin pumps. Both these options are expensive (even with insurance for many), invasive, and not really tailored towards "casual" glucose monitoring. I think if Apple enters the space with a non-invasive tool it'll be a huge boon for causal glucose monitoring. I also think it could be a more accessible option for people who are interested using a CGM to treat their diabetes but can't/won't use one of the existing options due to cost or inconvenience. This seems like a win win and I'm excited to see where it goes.
- pimeys 9y agoHere in Germany the Dexcom G4 system with Animas Vibe insulin pump became fully covered by the health insurance last November and a couple of weeks ago I got my system working. It is a pretty amazing improvement to my life: both the pump and CGM. The G4 transmitter has a 2.4 GHz radio and I built an extra device with Wixel and Bluetooth to transfer the data so my Android phone so xDrip+ and my Android watch can display the glucose values real time. It works so great that my A1c levels been going down from over 7% to 5-6%. If you are in Europe and have a Type 1 Diabetes, you should ask your doctor about your options.
- templaedhel 9y agoIf you have an insulin pump (best if it's an older one, since newer ones are harder to hack) you should look into OpenAPS (open artificial pancreas system) https://openaps.org/ https://openaps.org/. People have code/schematics available to build a closed loop system between CGM<>insulin pump which automatically adjusts the dosage based on glucose levels and keeps you in range better than even the best attempts at manual dosages. Seems like you've already done half the work, which is connecting the CGM to a device you can run custom code on. Medtronic just came out with their first closed loop system (https://www.medtronicdiabetes.com/products/minimed-670g-insulin-pump-system https://www.medtronicdiabetes.com/products/minimed-670g-insu...), but OpenAPS has been around for years, and not sure how Medtronic will go about getting the 670 approved in Germany.
- umeshunni 9y agoOne of the linked articles has some more technical details on how non-invasive blood sugar measurement works (for the GlucoWise device currently in development): The glucose levels are extracted by a non-invasive technique which transmits low-power radio waves through a section of the human body, such as the area between the thumb and forefinger or the earlobe. These areas have adequate blood supply and are thin enough for waves to pass through the tissue. These signals are then received by a sensor on the opposite side of the GlucoWise device, where the data about the characteristics of the blood within the flesh are collected and analysed. The other non-invasive technique that has received a lot of press is, of course, Google/Novartis' contact lens. That device measures blood sugar from tears. Most other blood sugar measurement systems require either blood draws from a pin prick or a sensor attached to your body that measures sugar content in the subcutaneous fluid as a proxy for blood sugar.
- cperciva 9y agoApple appears to be working on blood glucose monitoring as a way to address Type 2 Diabetes. Either the article is very wrong, or Apple is doing something very cute here. Type 2 diabetics do check their blood glucose -- occasionally. For non-insulin-using diabetics (aka. most type 2s) medical plans typically cover less than one test per day, because the evidence is that testing more frequently doesn't accomplish anything. (Blood glucose testing in T2D basically answers the question "is the treatment working, or do I need to talk to my endocrinologist", while blood glucose testing in T1D is essential for answering the question "how much insulin should I inject right now".) So the idea of a continuous glucose monitoring system for type 2 diabetics is pretty much nonsense from a medical perspective; sure, they'll get pretty graphs, but those graphs won't provide any medically actionable information. So my first instinct was to think that the article was very wrong. But maybe Apple is being very cute. The reason we don't have any non-invasive blood glucose tests is that nobody has managed to make them accurate enough to meet FDA requirements for tests to be used for diagnostic and treatment purposes. But if Apple markets this as being for type 2 diabetics... well, they can perfectly reasonably put a sticker on the box saying "for entertainment purposes only", since that's the only thing type 2 diabetics would be using a continuous glucose monitor for anyway! FDA requirements circumvented -- and once Apple gets a large installed used base, they get a huge pile of data which they can use to help them develop a later version which is accurate enough.
- gabrielgoh 9y agomaybe this could be a qualitative way of understanding the body's insulin response to a meal, and to adjust one's diet accordingly (more meals, lower GI foods, etc)?
- emdowling 9y agoI think your use of the word "cute" is a bit disingenuous and at odds with the conclusion you draw. "Cute" implies misleading, whereas the scenario you outline isn't misleading at all. It makes total sense to start where they are starting; they'll get teams of data in a very short space of time (from diabetics and non-diabetics alike) and be able to iterate quite quickly from there. As a non-diabetic, I want this so much. The impact of sugar and insulin on health is finally getting the attention it needs and I think this could be the innovation that makes health trackers actually useful.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- MeteOzturk 9y agoCross pollination between life sciences and consumer electronics will deliver amazing opportunities for chronic disease patients. Non-Invasive blood analysis can deliver new treatment opportunities for diabetes patients. This is an amazing field to innovate in indeed. My startup enigma.bio is working on low power laser spectroscopy blood analysis techniques inside the tympanic canal for the last 3 years. Seeing interest in the field from large players is exciting.
- nabla9 9y ago> I'm excited to see where it goes. BREAKING NEWS FROM THE FUTURE (Reuters): Hundreds of thousands Apple users die within hours after IoT glucose measurement + insulin pump device overdoses insulin during WannaDie cyberattack. Apple urges all surviving users to update the system immediately. Surviving users and family members of deceased will get 10 year full Apple subscription and special $20,000 memorial gift card after signing settlement agreement online. update: WaPo reports that CIA has been aware of the vulnerability for 5 years.
- Angostura 9y agoThank goodness, specialist embedded systems are immune from Malware.
- Tepix 9y agoTogether with self-driving cars that have also perfected data protection.
- nabla9 9y agoThank goodness. Pacemakers and Implantable Cardiac Defibrillators: Software Radio Attacks and Zero-Power Defenses https://spqr.eecs.umich.edu/papers/icd-study.pdf https://spqr.eecs.umich.edu/papers/icd-study.pdf >Our study analyzes the security and privacy properties of an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD). Introduced to the U.S. market in 2003, this model of ICD includes pacemaker technology and is designed to communicate wirelessly with a nearby external programmer in the 175 kHz frequency range. After partially reverse-engineering the ICD's communications protocol with an oscilloscope and a software radio, we implemented several software radio-based attacks that could compromise patient safety and patient privacy....
- skummetmaelk 9y agoI honestly cannot tell if this is sarcasm.
- Angostura 9y ago
- jlebrech 9y agoI can imagine wearing bracelets for each metric you want to monitor, it'll be a sign of health and wealth and be as popular as those snag bands you kids used to wear in the playground.
- michaelt 9y agoYou think visible medical equipment is a sign of good health?
- criddell 9y agoIt depends on the equipment. There's a spectrum from things like oxygen tanks one on end to fitness trackers on the other end. I think a glucose measuring Apple watch would be clearly on the fitness tracker end of things.
- tomelders 9y agoI really can see an ever increasing shelf in Apple stores that stocks medical monitoring devices, compatible with the Apple Watch and iPhone. And if I'm to be almost offensively practical, this is a huge business opportunity. We're all hypochondriacs to some degree, and it's a market that's currently being served by some pretty dodgy outfits, offering magic bullet solutions. And the incumbents are making a ton of money. It's probably not a good idea to give people tools to self diagnose themselves on a daily basis. But it's inevitable, and a logical path for the consumer electronics industry to follow.
- aedron 9y agoApple's recent obsession with health monitoring is weird from a branding standpoint. Losing appeal with young people is the nightmare of any technology company, becoming known as that gadget for geriatrics is another level of dejection. I read that this focus is particularly driven by Tim Cook's fascination with the space. It sort of confirms my idea of him as not a very image conscious CEO, especially in contrast with Jobs who was a legend at imbuing Apple with coolness and desirability.
- proyb2 9y agoI don't think you could say for the general young generation. Google, Apple and Samsung have been vie for these feature in 2014. It is not uncommon to focus on health space when the technology is mature, we can't live and worry about our health. What is the point if you have the greatest smartphone watch and still lead unhealthy lifestyle?
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoGenerally speaking, if you're leading an unhealthy lifestyle, buying a new gadget will not change that. I'm sure there's plenty of anecdata to counter this, though.
- swsieber 9y agoIf I had a device that let me know the health impact (from an insulin sensitivity standpoint) of a food I ate without invasive stuff, I'd use it in a heartbeat, and I'd listen (except for cheese - if it said cheese would bad, I'd ignore that bit).
- GordonS 9y agoThe good news is that almost all cheeses have not effect on blood glucose levels!
- proyb2 9y agoI disagree, most people tend to unknowing overwork or having excessive intake. There are situations when someone tried to add artificial sweetness, the gadget are there to inform you in time rather than months. Hostpitals has been participating in health research because they want to make these accessible for you 24 hours.
- dwighttk 9y agoThis is all well and good, but is it accurate? Don't Theranos us Apple.
- Shivetya 9y agoThat is key. I don't see how. At first I thought maybe a sweat related method? Perhaps some odd electronic field trick no on has tried? Unlike heart rate I doubt a camera and bright light would suffice. I do know I would buy them for my parents immediately once they are shown to work. Would not even pause. Blood sugar is spooky and you are toast if it goes low and no one is around to help anecdotal section : My mother has been taking insulin since the 80s, she uses a pump currently. The real danger in blood sugar is when levels get low. She has caught her self in the low 40s but if it had happened at night she would be in real trouble. You just simply go to sleep and never wake from it. High numbers while dangerous are sustainable and your conscious throughout. She has had a few episodes where it went out of control (600+) that took a hospital visit days to get under control with a drip. Same routine, you go in and tell them your level. They don't believe you. They test three times then freak out. You are in heart ward and even then they cannot get it back and turn from blaming your diet to going "We don't know". The point is, even highly regulated/monitored things happen and doctors don't know all the whys.
- crb002 9y agoAstro Teller of Google X used to do that sort of thing at BodyMedia. It wouldn't surprise me if Google also has some projects in the works.
- QuercusMax 9y agoVerily (formerly Google X Life Sciences) has several projects they are working on in this space, including miniaturized CGMs and glucose sensing contact lenses. https://verily.com/projects/ https://verily.com/projects/ Disclaimer: I work for Verily, but I know nothing about these projects.
- mtw 9y agoI have a Garmin right now. The heart rate monitor gives more reliable readings, the battery is better etc. If apple makes an Apple Watch 3 with an optional blood glucose monitoring band, I'd switch back though!
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoAre there any uses for this information for "normals", people with no particular danger of diabetes? For example, I am interested in calorie tracking, but the various apps out there mostly seem to cover franchise food. They can't accurately say anything about the sandwich I made in my kitchen.
- dna_polymerase 9y agoWell yes. You might not know it but these days there is sugar (in any variation) in almost all our food. Increased blood sugar levels over long time lead to diabetes, tracking might help people to understand the risk their diets might impose.
- digitalneal 9y agoLoyal to Dexcom for the night and day changes their product made to the quality of life for my mother. But very glad to see Apple putting a foot into these waters.
- david_brush 9y agoAs a type II diabetic I would love it if Apple got in the continuous monitoring field; namely because it will help the field as a whole get better. It is largely dominated by one company with an invasive method. As an aside to the article Type II is caused by diverse reasons; not just weight. Weight is deffinately a factor; but there are other genetic and physiological factors that contribute to how well your body uses/produces insulin. The article doesn't help mitigate this by referring to Type II as a "Lifestyle" i.e. Shaming disease. Diabetics have a enough to deal with then to be rudely told it's their fault and they simply have to 'exercise'. A little compassion goes a long way.
- guiomie 9y agoIf this device is covered by insurances, this could become a potential cash cow.
- criddell 9y agoEven if it isn't, I think it would still be a cash cow. I've never owned an Apple watch before, but if they got this working, I'd buy one in a heartbeat (assuming it's less than $1500). FWIW, I'm not diabetic, I just want the data.
- justforFranz 9y agoI'm sure it's helpful for diabetics, but it won't be long at all before Apple is selling that data to your health insurer - who will f you.
- ldrndll 9y agoAny reason to believe they'd actually do this? Apple are one of the few companies that seem to genuinely value customer privacy[1]; They make their money selling your products, not selling your personal information after all. If this were a Google or Facebook product on the other hand... [1] I could point to numerous examples of this (removing APIs used to track individual iOS devices, fighting the government on proposed encryption backdoors, etc), but I think the onus is on you to rather provide evidence to suggest this is something they would do :)
- JeremyBanks 9y agoThis is an ridiculous suggestion. Apple's products have had minimal data reporting and a focus on privacy. They even conceded awkward UI and bugs around messaging for the sake of keeping it secure. Their advertising project failed partially because of their unwillingness to track users. They famously took the US government to court and won in order to prevent them from being forced to unlock a phone, for fear of the precedent it would set. What possible reason could you have to assume that they would sell health data, for which all of the same reasoning applies as well as it being more heavily regulated by the government?
- korethr 9y agoThis article talks about type 2 diabetes, but I'm wondering why a non-invasive continuous blood glucose monitor would not be just as useful and desirable for type 1s as well. A friend of mine has type 1, and more than once, she's expressed hopeful anticipation for a future combined non-invasive blood glucose monitor and insulin pump -- effectively an external artificial pancreas to take over the functionality of her broken natural one.
- charlesism 9y agoIt would be very desirable, but all of the many companies who have tried to get accurate results non-invasively have failed. With Apple's resources, perhaps they'll lick the problem, but I wouldn't bet on it. So to answer your question: Probably because if a Type 1 Diabetic uses a non-invasive glucose monitor to determine their insulin dosage, much of the time they will overdose, and possibly fall into a coma or die.
- Balgair 9y agoA co-worker of mine is doing a similar kinda thing but with circulating tumor cells, so I have some 3rd hand knowledge of these kinda tests. Fact of the matter is that the human body is, chemically and pathologically speaking, fucking bulletproof. Our bodies are just super freaking good at maintaining homeostasis. This means that a lot of tests like blood-glucose, cancer diagnosis, etc that are trying for non-invasive blood testing just have a HUGE parameter space to contend with. Apple's idea may work with calm light-skinned office workers, but will it work with sweating dark-skinned day laborers? African Americans are the population most at risk for DM-II. How about if your blood pressure goes all wonky? What about someone going through a growth spurt? Does it work when you put your arm in motor oil? What about people without arms? Lives aren't 'edge cases'; your device MUST cover all those real people with families and children. I'll believe their device when it passes FDA approval and the clinical data is out there for us all to see and argue over.
- criddell 9y ago> your device MUST cover all those real people with families and children Are you talking from a regulatory standpoint? Why couldn't Apple (or anybody) make a device that works on a limited range of skin colors? If you can't help everybody, does that mean you shouldn't help anybody?
- oktavist 9y agoWhile a lot of comments revolve around the efficacy of accurately monitoring for T1/2 diabetes and the past noninvasive trials and tribulations thereof, consider that the market for such a product is very limited by Apple's measure (10's of millions for an addressable market, versus billions for phones/watches). It seems much more interesting if they were chasing a general metabolic health or pre-diabetic application where the annoyance and lethargy of the FDA/medical community can be skipped entirely.